“Agnes thought Lincoln was current president,” my wife texted about our 7-year-old daughter. “Legitimately shocked to learn about Trump.”
My first thought was that we really need to work on civics education. But my second was jealousy: How nice it would be to enjoy life as it comes without obsessing about people and events I can’t control.
The past two weeks, for instance, I’ve spent way too much time scrolling through social media, wading through and at times nearly drowning in misinformation, propaganda and AI slop, in order to remain informed about nearly every aspect of the U.S.-Israeli war on Iran. I know (or at least I think I know) more about crude oil, modern munitions and sea mines that I ever thought I’d need.
But, except in my professional capacity as a journalist, do I really need to know these things? Am I happier now that I apprehend the difference between Brent Crude and West Texas Intermediate oil? Is my life — or my family’s life — improved now that I know (and am probably too excited to tell other people, especially people I live with) that most Iranian oil is exported through Kharg Island, while the terminal at Jask on the Gulf of Oman has limited utility?
“Monitoring the situation” overseas may not be as numbing as following celebrity gossip or playing candy-based phone games — but it can become an equally unhealthy distraction from our most important responsibilities and our greatest joys, which are always close to home.
Digital vs. real world
Jim VandeHei and Mike Allen, founders of the news organization Axios, penned a column this week simply called “America’s Big Lie.” They argued that “Most Americans are too busy for social media, too normal for politics, too rational to tweet. They work, raise kids, coach Little League, go to a house of worship, mow their neighbor’s lawn — and never post a word about any of it.”
The idea is that America’s political and social dysfunction is overstated, mostly an artifact of a minority of “terminally online news junkies” who are radicalized by their algorithms and whose pathologies are amplified by an also-very-online media class.
I think the two media execs overstate their case: The effects of internet-driven polarization spill out into the real world and come to inform the perspectives even of the 90% who don’t peruse X daily. The race to the extremes in primary elections, for instance, isn’t just driven by doomscrollers but by voters’ dissatisfaction with their real-world circumstances.
But they are exactly right about the antidote to screen-induced despair over the state of America and the world: “Walk outside. Talk to your neighbor. Coach the team. Go to the town meeting.”
This is where we encounter each other’s full humanity and discover that politics makes up a very small part of the person. This is where we find hope for living together despite our differences. This is where we make the world better, by tending the tiny slice of it we are assigned to care for.
Close to home
I was born and raised in Pittsburgh and never intend to live anywhere else. Friends who live and work in more glamorous locales from time to time suggest that I should reconsider this commitment in order to make a go of it in (what they see as) the big leagues.
Times like these, when hugely consequential and fascinating events are moving quickly, test my localism. I’ve found it difficult to focus on and care about city permit reform and NFL Draft preparations when I have one eye and often both on The New York Times and the S&P 500.
Yet times like these really should reinforce localist instincts. As interesting as Iran is, there’s little to nothing I can do about it, whether I’m working from Brookline Boulevard or Massachusetts Avenue or Times Square.
I can try to better understand world affairs, and as a journalist I can help others come to understand them as well. That’s not nothing, but it only goes so far.
In studying land-use best practices or poking around City Council or digging into the county’s human-services bureaucracy, there’s a chance my work can actually change the way a community — my community — functions, so that more people live better, right here. All the better: These issues, while sensitive, typically aren’t as polarized along ideological lines. They’re things we can really talk about, and learn from one another about, without getting waylaid by partisanship.
This is why these pages have focused so much on the local, and why this work will remain so important regardless of the fate of the Post-Gazette.
Where good is done
“Why isn’t Lincoln the president?” my darling little space cadet asked. “Did he quit?”
We had to tell her the truth (gently). Ignorance may bring something like peace, but it’s not a virtue. Confronting reality is necessary, and sometimes faraway realities, whether distant in time or space, impinge on our everyday ones.
I dread that will be the case right now. It feels to me like early March six years ago when a seemingly faraway concern soon consumed all of us for months and years.
But obsessing over the news cycle courts another kind of ignorance, a worse kind: ignorance of the good people and good things right in our midst, and of the good we can and must do for them, no matter what’s going on in Jerusalem or Tehran. If only we would pay attention.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Apocalypse now.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.