However high you think the stakes of the joint U.S.-Israeli war against Iran are, you’re almost certainly underestimating.

Yes, the conflict could reshape geopolitics for a generation or longer. It could result in global shortages of oil and and therefore many goods and of fertilizer and therefore food. It could define Donald Trump’s presidency and the fate of the Republican Party for multiple election cycles.

All this is terribly important, but it misses the most important reason this war is unlikely to be limited in time and scope: It involves a clash of millenarian, even apocalyptic visions of the world, and of the purpose of this conflict in particular.

Cosmic purpose

Millenarianism refers to a variety of beliefs, some theological and others strictly political, that foresee the dawning of a new age, defined by peace if not the full perfection of human society, after some triggering event, often preceded by a period of struggle and tribulation.

Advertise with us

The Islamic Republic of Iran, for instance, has an explicitly millenarian purpose. It was founded in 1979 as a unique experiment in theocracy based on Shia Islam, to which a very clear theology of apocalypse is central: Believers awaits the 12th imam, the Mahdi, who will set the world right.

While regime self-preservation is clearly top-of-mind for Iranian leaders, for true believers that preservation isn’t just about saving their own skins: It’s to ensure the regime fulfills its higher purpose. For some, this week’s events may even be a sign that the long-awaited millenarian moment is close at hand. Such people are likely to make choices and take risks that are not legible to secular pragmatists — and they certainly won’t fit the mold of art-of-the-deal-style adversaries.

Yet the Islamic Republic does not represent the only millenarian theology in play. The United States is the world’s largest, and basically only, stronghold of dispensationalism, an evangelical Protestant theology that holds that the modern state of Israel has an essential role to play in the end of this age and the dawning of the next.

Temple dreams

In brief, this involves the belief that Israel must expand its power and territory in order to construct a Third Temple in Jerusalem on the site now occupied by the Dome of the Rock, one of the holiest shrines in Islam. This is an essential prerequisite to the second coming of Jesus Christ, who will set the world right.

This would be a mere curiosity were it not for the fact that dispensationalist theology is massively overrepresented in conservative politics. Mike Huckabee, Trump’s ambassador to Israel, subscribes to the system. Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth’s theology is unclear, but he has advocated for building the Third Temple. Speaker of the House Mike Johnson has made remarks about a “biblical admonition to stand with Israel” that are in line with dispensationalism.

Advertise with us

There have even been unconfirmed reports of U.S. military commanders exhorting their charges to be prepared to fight for “Armageddon” in Iran.

Needless to say, this belief system requires the subjugation of Islamic powers in order for Israel to secure the Temple Mount. And Iran, the Jewish state’s most implacable enemy, is first on the list.

As for Israel itself, it is not a theologically millenarian state, but under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu there is a strong sense of political millenarianism: that the total defeat of Iran and its proxies will usher in, and is the only way to usher in, a long-awaited era of peace and security. Clearly Netanyahu sees this war as an extension of the attempted obliteration of Hamas in Gaza, with Israeli forces also making moves deep into Lebanon to solve Hezbollah once and for all.

Just like dispensationalism, while not directly setting U.S. foreign policy, is clearly contributing a millenarian sensibility that this war is necessary to solve Iran once and for all.

Clean slate

“Once and for all” — that’s the kind of thinking that is increasingly dominant not just in world affairs but in domestic politics. Many Trump supporters, for instance, saw him as the only way to achieve the “once and for all” defeat of “woke” liberalism, while many Trump opponents see his final humiliation, followed by the extirpation of the MAGA movement, as the only way to restore sane liberal politics “once and for all.”

Advertise with us

On the other side of the election, the war, the second coming, all will be set right. Or at least setting the world right will be possible, where it wasn’t before.

The predominance of this way of thinking, at least as much as dwindling missile stockpiles and the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, is why this war fills me with dread. Too many actors, I fear, see it as the best, last or only chance to achieve some final victory or to remove the final obstacle to some cosmic purpose.

This leaves no space for the continued existence of the adversary on the other side of the millenarian moment, with whom you will have to negotiate the terms of coexistence. It rules out compromise and off-ramps and rules in maximum effort and maximum sacrifice in order to achieve extraordinary and even other-worldly goals.

It sees the conflict not as the end of a paragraph in world affairs but the end of a chapter, perhaps even the end of a book. A complete ending, with a new story — a new world — on the other side. Or maybe just: The End.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Can Jack Hughes’ smile save America?”