Last spring, the Editorial Board published a series of editorials about delays in the execution of parks and recreation improvements by the City of Pittsburgh. The first thing I noticed as I researched them was how many projects seemed to be stuck in the “community engagement” phase of development.

Every project required a Development Activities Meeting (DAM). To schedule a DAM, you have to coordinate with a Registered Community Organization (RCO). Then there were typically further public sessions, also through the RCO, scheduled months apart, not to mention months (or years!) of online feedback. Just to decide on a playground design could take the better part of a year, even with the most efficient city workers piloting the effort.

And that’s the easy process: Larger private development projects also have to go through the Planning Commission and often the Zoning Board of Adjustment, each of which has lengthy waiting periods surrounding public meetings. And substantial changes have to go through the process again.

Every step in these processes exists for good reason: No one wants people to have their lives upset and their hopes for their community steamrolled by powerful public and private institutions. Yet it is not anti-community, or certainly anti-democratic, to ask if these processes are actually working in ways that benefit the people of Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

In many cases and respects, they are not.

Planning the commission

This question has come to the fore in a seemingly arcane, but actually consequential, dispute over the new O’Connor administration’s appointments to the Planning Commission. It is standard, given the commission’s power over development, for its members to reflect the mayor’s priorities, so appointments are both politically valuable and signs of bigger moves to come.

Enter David Vatz, founder of the advocacy group Pro-Housing Pittsburgh. Over the past few years, this group of enthusiasts has pressed for a wide range of policies calculated to increase the supply of housing in the city, including releasing a study showing the negative effects of inclusionary zoning. Vatz emerged as a keen critic of former Mayor Ed Gainey — and, more importantly for our purposes, of the way “community engagement” is practiced.

This caught the eye of the remnants of Pittsburgh’s progressive activist scene, who are pressing City Council to reject Vatz’s nomination. This effort was reflected in remarks made this week by Councilwoman Barb Warwick, who called him “divisive,” which in this case is code for “someone who publicly disagrees with me.”

The activists will not succeed, but the zeal of their opposition is helpful for understanding how community engagement actually works in practice.

Advertise with us

Rockwell vs. reality

It’s easy to have a romantic view of contemporary community engagement as the Rockwellian portrait of American democracy, inherited from New England town meetings centuries ago. You will lose that view the first time you attend or watch an actual public meeting.

In practice, these sessions are typically dominated by a very small minority of the community who have the passion and the time to show up, often at odd hours. While useful information does often emerge, the format is easily captured by the neighborhood’s most abrasive characters, as well as ideologues with agendas that do not express the views of the community they claim to represent.

This dynamic makes community engagement sessions particularly useful for paid activists, because it takes a relatively small number of them to show up and appear to represent the authentic voice of the community. Pittsburgh saw this in its most extreme form during the marathon Planning Commission meeting last January where inclusionary zoning was considered, which dragged on for nearly 12 hours as dozens of speakers, many wearing identical t-shirts, berated the panel.

If the officials reject the policy the activists favor, they can then claim that the decision is “undemocratic” because “the community” has been ignored. Threats to the current version of the community engagement process, therefore, represent a threat to activists’ ability to manufacture a false community consensus in order to extort concessions.

Less is more

Here’s how Vatz rather punchily put it on social media two years ago: “Community input should happen in an actual democratic process — elections.” To the extent that community engagement can be captured to frustrate the legitimate goals of duly elected officials, in fact, it can be anti-democratic in effect.

Advertise with us

To be clear, neither I nor Vatz is arguing against all community input in public and private development affecting the shared life of a neighborhood. Elections don’t settle every single issue faced by a political community, especially at the hyperlocal level.

At its best, community engagement allows facts and issues to come to light that policymakers couldn’t know about any other way than by listening to the people who live there. These processes can and must inform final decisions made by elected leaders or their deputies.

The problem comes when this process is meant to obtain (or captured in order to manufacture) an apparent consensus. That’s the romantic vision of direct democracy that didn’t work in ancient Athens and doesn’t work here and now.

What Pittsburgh needs — and Corey O’Connor appears poised to open — is an honest conversation about what makes community engagement effective and valuable, stripped of the idealism and romanticism that can let determined people manipulate the system. What I expect we’d find is that most people would be happier with their city if more projects got done, with less time spent bickering.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “10 (new) thoughts on Downtown.”