Some of my favorite childhood memories were the wintertime days when I’d wake up and see the flakes gently falling, and then rush to my bedroom window hoping our street would be blanketed in white. If it was, I’d wait to hear the words every child in chilly climes longs to hear: “It’s a Synchronous Remote Teaching and Learning Day!”
I feel an almost physical pain for today’s schoolchildren who have been denied the wondrous anticipation and transcendent joy of the snow day. It gives them unexpected freedom to enjoy the day and their world, an experience that teaches more than any single day of school. The snow day comes when nature gives it, and the unpredictability, the serendipity, makes it all the better.
Now those days are all but gone.
Taught by the wintry world
But not for everyone. At the risk of boasting, I’m going to relate some of what our children have done during this once-in-a-childhood snowstorm (in addition to a little homeschooling each day).
They walked to a friend’s house to sled before I even got out of bed. They built an igloo with multiple entrances in our front yard. They helped shovel the piles of plowed snow along our sidewalk to make room for cars to pass.
One talked about making a buck by shoveling other people’s snow, but didn’t quite have the gumption to knock on doors.
I took a few sledding on a neighbor’s hill, and after the two-year-old gave up (too much snow on her face), the four-year-old told me confidently, “I want to sled all by myself.” So he did.
And our ten-year-old son and his buddies built a First World War-style fortification at the park, complete with trenches, watch towers and shelters. Then they trudged to the pizza shop for dinner. I can guarantee you there is no “teaching and learning” from any screen anywhere that would generate the look of pride in his tired eyes as he described his snow day.
The wintry world taught and the boys learned in a way no remote school day ever could match.
Adult problems
Why lose such a wonderful childhood experience, one known to anyone over about 30 who grew up with snow? Killing off the snow day solves adults’ problems, particularly school administrators and teachers’.
First, it removes the pressure to squeeze in more instruction to replace missed days. But that only means more official education is done, not real education, because the remote-learning method is a proven failure, especially for younger students.
It gives the appearance of educational diligence — administrators and teachers don’t get the snow days either — when, in reality, it results in students learning less both academically and from experiencing and exploring the physical world.
Second, it makes it much easier to close schools for the day, allowing school employees to stay home while burdening kids and their families, who have to figure out at-home arrangements. Without real snow days, if there’s any doubt about conditions, it’s easy to say that the “responsible” course is to move teaching to the screens.
This is why many Pittsburgh-area schools ended up closing all week. The break likely would’ve only been a couple days if decision-makers didn’t have the fig leaf of “synchronous remote teaching and learning.” Parents would have had to rearrange their schedules for just two days instead of five.
This just avoids making hard calls about asking people to do hard things, like navigating a less-than-perfect environment to get to school. In other words, the “responsible” course relieves those in authority from taking responsibility. They can wash their hands of it all by passing off education to the screens, even though we know they don’t work.
It’s yet another example of people in authority thinking first of their own liability — not just legal but political and institutional — and then choosing whatever appears to be the safest action. Real snow days require making choices with obvious trade-offs, including weighing the physical risk of icy transportation with the goods of camaraderie and education. “Remote learning” saves them from having to make the hard choice, but leaves those for whom the schools are responsible, the children, worse off.
Further, the less risky choice is not always the best one, especially for young people who need to understand that living well requires accepting and managing risk, not avoiding it. Risk-avoidant adults hand down a sterile vision of life and leadership. Meanwhile, the best teacher of risk management is right outside the front door, while the sad-sack students watch their safe and boring screens.
Essential education
This is the worst part of the demise of the snow day: It betrays a deep misunderstanding of what education and growing-up actually are.
A real snow day isn’t a day without education; it’s a day that teaches children lessons they don’t get from school. It teaches that sometimes forces beyond our control intervene, and we have to adapt, and that sometimes good things just happen. It teaches that nature can bring joy and beauty and danger in equal measure. It teaches children to explore their limits, with the added benefit of a soft white surface to land on.
And, perhaps most of all, a snow day is a necessary irruption of exuberance in an increasingly pessimistic world. That’s reason enough to cherish them.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Beyond good and evil in Trump’s new world order.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.