The columnists, contributing writers and others this week will be commenting on Donald Trump’s first year, on the anniversary week of his second inauguration.
The most common mistake people make in analyzing the political career of Donald Trump is focusing far too much on right and wrong.
Now, I’m the last person to argue that morality shouldn’t bear on public affairs: When deciding how to act and what choices to make as a public person, good and evil must be the first consideration. And it’s certainly legitimate and necessary for commentators to pass moral judgment on leaders and their actions.
But that can’t be the only criterion of analysis. What Trump has done, and what he represents, and what the consequences of his leadership are and will be — these are not just moral questions but historical ones, whose importance cannot be contained with the categories of good and evil. The conviction that Trump is a bad man who has done bad things may be true, but the historical moment in which he’s operating is much, much more complex.
That is, answering the question “What is happening and what does it mean?” must include, but cannot be limited by, answering the question “Is what is happening good or bad?” Indeed, focusing too much on the latter can easily blind us to important aspects of the former.
With that in mind, I’d like to argue that the first year of Trump’s second term in office, culminating in saber-rattling over Greenland and the meeting of the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, proves the 2018 remark of Henry Kissinger that Trump “may be one of those figures in history who appears from time to time to mark the end of an era and to force it to give up its old pretenses.”
And that the person who most clearly and coldly understands this reality is Mark Carney, the prime minister of Canada.
Carney’s greengrocer
On Tuesday, Carney delivered — and, it is said, personally wrote — one of the most incisive and consequential political speeches in recent world history. With the detached precision of a professor and the gravitas of a statesman, in 15 minutes he diagnosed and declared the end of the post-Cold War (post-Second World War?) global order, while describing a plausible strategy to forge a new one.
It would be one where the United States is no longer a protagonist.
The speech crystalized one of the most powerful acts in politics: Saying out loud what everybody knows, but has been too timid to speak. In this case, the fact not only that the “rules-based international order” has ended, but that it was always a bit of a sham.
To do this, Carney brilliantly reversed the context of Vaclav Havel’s greengrocer. Havel, the Czech dissident-turned-president, described how the Soviet system was a sham, but it worked because everyone agreed to participate in the sham. Shopkeepers, for instance, would put signs in their windows proclaiming the final victory of communism even when they didn’t believe it. But when one greengrocer takes the sign down, the façade begins to collapse.
Canada, Carney announced, is taking down its sign.
End of an era
What he meant is that the global order by which powerful countries agree to restrain themselves by abiding by international laws and standards, designed at least in theory for the good of all, has ended. And there’s no good in “middle powers” like Canada keeping up the charade, when they’ll only be punished for it.
The subtext is that the actions of Donald Trump — tariffs, Venezuela, Greenland — represented the final tipping point. But what was so important and honest about Carney’s speech was that it acknowledged that this order was always “partially false.” Strong countries got away with things weaker ones didn’t, or turned a blind eye to allies’ transgressions and not to adversaries’.
Trump didn’t break a perfectly healthy global order. He recognized the sham and has behaved as if it were a sham, further revealing the reality of the sham. To return to Kissinger’s words, he has catalyzed “the end of an era” by compelling it to abandon the pretense of its own neutrality and stability.
The fact the rules-based order was a bit of a sham, and was eventually going to collapse under the weight of its own contradictions, doesn’t justify intentionally tipping it over, causing what could be an era of grave global instability. This is not a noble undertaking.
But it’s also seriously incomplete, even dangerous, to simply label it bad. It’s history, and coming to terms with it requires thinking beyond good and evil.
Embracing reality
Indeed, this kind of global transition is a historical process that has occurred over and over again in human affairs.
The catalyst this time — a reality television star threatening the people who invented LEGOs over a strategic territory in the game of Risk — is unusually silly. But the people and events that finally turn the page on historical eras are rarely as grand as we suppose. The man who descended the golden escalator actually seems pretty on-the-nose for arriviste America’s contribution to the great historical drama of the 21st century.
One of the most important statements in Carney’s speech was only five words long: “Nostalgia is not a strategy.” Emphasizing Trump’s malice can easily lead to mythologizing the old order, and then wishing and working for its restoration. That is a fool’s errand. That is not how history works. That world is not coming back.
The question for Canada, America and the rest of the world, cannot be how to restore the pre-Trump world, but how to thrive in the world Trump is, by an accident of history, bringing into being.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “New year, new mayor, new coach, new Pittsburgh?”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.