In my parents’ basement there’s a yellowed page of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette with a feature photo of me on my father’s shoulders at a Pirates game. It’s a source of endless amusement that the caption identifies us as Tom and Brandon “McBinley.”
I never expected my accurately spelled name would appear as a regular byline in these pages, let alone on the masthead.
Yet this has been the gift bestowed on me by my city, by way of the Post-Gazette — its most tangible avatar. It’s a gift for which I am and will always be grateful.
Inside the green bags
What I remember most vividly about the Post-Gazette of my youth is the thud. On the driveway, the floor, the kitchen table, that beast in the green bag knew how to announce itself.
Unlike some millennial Pittsburghers, I didn’t examine box scores or columns or even, too often, the comics. I wasn’t a natural newspaper nerd.
But the paper still was a fixture of domestic life, like beer cans and leftovers and sibling rivalry. To be fair, there was a time when my family switched over (apologies!) to the Tribune-Review, and then a period when there was no paper in the home at all. But now, when we visit for Sunday dinner, there is the PG once again. Usually opened to the Insight section.
I know the paper doesn’t make the same thud anymore. But I would challenge our readers to look up the papers and newsrooms in peer cities, especially those owned by corporate conglomerates and private equity funds. And they will find stripped down journalistic operations far too small to serve their cities well.
Pittsburgh has been lucky to have the Post-Gazette, in this comparatively robust form, for as long as it has.
Pittsburgh’s nerve center
Knowing the economics of local journalism from the inside, I had gotten used to the fact that the PG wouldn’t always exist in this form — that it would over time, like the others, further atrophy.
What I cannot conceive of is a city without the Post-Gazette entirely.
This is not meant as a slight against our friends across town at TribLive, or for that matter at PublicSource or WESA or the New Pittsburgh Courier or elsewhere. But I suspect even those affiliated with these organizations would understand that the PG, with its legacy nearly as old as the country and its longstanding status as the city’s paper of record, has a special role in Pittsburgh’s identity.
In fact, I think it’s the most Pittsburgh institution in the city — yes, even more than U.S. Steel or the Steelers. That’s because while U.S. Steel captures the history and the Steelers capture the culture of this scrappy part of the world, the newspaper is the crossroads of everything: culture, politics, society, business, food, sports.
This is true even today, with its smaller size and, uh, middling web design.
When the PG was a physical fixture of everyday life, it was both a tangible and intellectual tether connecting people and families to the life of the city. In that way, even more than a manufacturing company or a sports franchise, it represented — represents! — the very essence of what it means to be a Pittsburgher. When you pick it up, or open the website, you’re tapping in to the city’s nerve center.
That’s why, for instance, so many of the paper’s digital subscribers don’t live here: It’s their connection to home.
Civic lobotomy
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, perhaps in some very different form, will continue to exist. I have to believe it will.
This is not a prediction or a revelation of inside information. It is only an expression of hope. It is a reflection of the reality that the true annihilation of the Post-Gazette would radically and permanently alter Pittsburgh, like a civic lobotomy.
This isn’t even about the effects of the loss of accountability journalism and access to basic information about the region’s shared life. Those things can be replaced, though only in part, by new or existing institutions.
It’s about the thud. The green bags. The gothic typeface. The ubiquitous newspaper racks that unaccountably remain in place. The archives, which are the first draft of Pittsburgh’s history from 1786 to 2026. The names of writers and editors that have entered Pittsburgh lore. The typos that botch the names of future editors.
The city that finds itself in something other than the Post-Gazette will be a different city from the one that has found itself in this paper, and its predecessors, for generations. And I can’t yet accept that this will come to pass.
My family didn’t keep that old page because of the unfortunate misspelling; they kept it because my dad and I were in the paper. We had become, for a brief moment but also for all time, part of the chronicle of our city. And that was worth celebrating and cherishing.
Just as I will cherish the gift of stewarding these pages, even if briefly, for the rest of my life.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How Pittsburgh can become the best version of itself.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.