Aboard THE PENNSYLVANIAN —
It’s hard not to feel the pangs of faded glory taking the train east of Pittsburgh. The journey begins at what must be one of the world’s most offensive train stations, then passes into the Monongahela and Turtle Creek valleys before town-hopping through Westmoreland County.
Rankin. Trafford. Pitcairn. Manor. Jeannette. Orthodox churches. Industrial ruins. Mid-century furniture stores. Victorian mansions with peeling siding. Mural advertisements for insurance companies that no longer exist.
But then the train pulls into Greensburg Station, and Latrobe, and Johnstown. And while these structures, too, have lost some of their elegance, they are also consistently among the most thoughtfully and grandly designed buildings in town.
They are enduring reminders of the days when public architecture aimed first to represent and to uphold high civic standards and to elevate the everyday lives of everyday people, rather than merely to get the job done with the least effort and at the lowest cost.
What the train ride teaches is that ugliness is a political choice and that choice has public effects.
Choosing ugliness
“One entered the city like a god. One scuttles in now like a rat.” These are the words of historian Vincent Scully, oft-repeated by the late U.S. Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan, to describe the transition from the grand old Penn Station in Midtown Manhattan to the utilitarian underground labyrinths that replaced it.
They apply at least as well to the replacement of Pittsburgh’s grand Union Station with the basement waiting room that now passes as a passenger terminal. And while New York’s Penn Station has, at long last, been supplanted by the Moynihan Train Hall, Pittsburgh appears to be stuck with its DMV-style station for the long haul.
It is, I believe, the most depressing public space in the city. No matter how many times you’ve boarded an Amtrak here, you approach the windowless hall tucked beneath a dingy overpass convinced that this cannot possibly be Pittsburgh’s train station. And every time you’re disappointed.
It’s made all the worse by the fact it’s open, due to the schedules of the Pennsylvanian and (temporarily) the Floridian, only from 6 p.m. to 7:45 a.m.
The “station” is a charmless white room with a few rows of small-airport-style seating. When it’s empty it feels like a void, but it’s also too small to comfortably hold everyone waiting for a big departure. The room feels actively hostile to its stated purpose and doesn’t want people to be comfortable within. It makes people feel small and insignificant, like we’re a bother to the system for daring to buy a ticket.
It is seemingly intentionally ugly. Actually, it’s certainly intentionally ugly.
Democratic beauty
The intentionality isn’t direct, in the sense that some person or group set out with the object of creating the least appealing train station possible. Rather, it’s the indirect intentionality of deprioritization and neglect, of choosing other apparent goods over beauty and eventually leaving it in last place.
The old train stations in small-town Pennsylvania demonstrate that there’s another way.
Greensburg Station, for instance, was built in 1912. It’s a lovely red-brick structure that includes ornate concrete work, a grand portico and a clock tower with a green copper finial.
The Pennsylvania Railroad — that is, the private sector — built the station, but clearly didn’t prioritize frugality. This was, and is, a building the town could be proud of, and a public space that made, and makes, everyday people feel honored and worthy of enjoying beautiful things.
This reflects a fundamentally democratic ethic: grandeur and elegance should be accessible to all, not just to those who can afford exclusive luxury experiences. It’s the ethic that motivated the creation of the Carnegie libraries and the city’s museums and theaters and concert halls.
And it’s an ethic that once straddled the public and private sectors. Consider the grand post offices and even public schools, which symbolized the solidity of the government but also elevated their communities by being public expressions of the value of beautiful things for all people to enjoy.
It’s not a stretch, I believe, to see in the deterioration of public architecture the antecedent to the erosion of democratic norms and the rise of demagoguery.
Changing choices
First, ugly public architecture and public spaces signal contempt for everyday people and enforce social hierarchies. When public authorities prize frugality and utility above all else, that cedes elegance to exclusive private spaces. It says to the people that only the rich and powerful are worthy of enjoying beautiful things. This nurtures the populist impulse.
Second, public ugliness in the built environment signals the erosion of civic standards among the very leaders who are supposed to uphold those standards.
If civil authorities can’t be bothered to maintain standards of excellence, and in fact appear to think those standards are outmoded, why should voters prioritize traditional standards of republican virtue in their leaders? If all the people deserve is ugly public architecture, why shouldn’t the people elevate ugly characters (ostensibly) to fight for them?
It can be easy to conclude that, in public spaces and public persons, the ugliness is somehow beyond human control. But public ugliness is a choice. And by adjusting our public priorities in favor of beauty for everyone and creating lovely public spaces, we can build a more democratic society.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “The state must save Pittsburgh from failed PPS leadership.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.