The Pittsburgh region’s famously old voters have quietly selected what must be one of the youngest cohorts of political leaders in America. While so much of the unelected leadership of the region hails from the Boomer generation (or even earlier), the political leadership is decidedly Millennial.
The question is whether these young leaders can be a disruptive (but constructive) force within the region’s hidebound systems of power — or whether they’ll just be assimilated into it.
Pittsburgh Mayor-elect Corey O’Connor and Controller Rachael Heisler are both 41 years old, while Allegheny County Executive Sara Innamorato is 39.
The region’s congressional delegation also has an average age of 40: Reps. Summer Lee (37), Chris Deluzio (41) and Guy Reschenthaler (42). The median age of members of Congress, meanwhile, is more than 57 years old.
Among Allegheny County’s delegation in Harrisburg, Democratic Reps. Aerion Abney, Jessica Benham, Lindsay Powell, Emily Kinkead, John Inglis, Brandon Markosek and Joe McAndrew, along with Republican Rep. Andrew Kuzma, are all under 40. In the Senate, Nick Pisciottano is 35 and Lindsey Williams is an elder stateswoman at 42.
Catalyzing youth
The typical lens for analyzing Pittsburgh politics in recent years has been “progressive” versus “establishment.” The transfer of power across generations has been largely ignored — but may be at least as important. But it will take Mr. O’Connor and Ms. Innamorato, in particular, being willing to make their relative youth more central to their political identities to catalyze this movement.
Consider this: Next April, for three days, Pittsburgh will get its brightest spotlight since the 2009 G-20 summit.
Yet during the NFL Draft, national sports media will surely make repeated and increasingly obnoxious references to Pittsburgh’s industrial past. After all, just look at the NFL’s steel-themed countdown clock on the North Shore. If VisitPittsburgh can convince ESPN to forego using b-roll footage of molten steel during the broadcast, everyone at the agency should get a huge bonus.
What a contrast it would be for the youthful mayor and county executive — they both look even younger than they are — to be a visible presence, as a team, during the festivities — say, introducing Art Rooney or Roger Goodell on television, or appearing together in a regional marketing campaign.
This wouldn’t be the obvious gimmick of 26-year-old Luke Ravenstahl appearing on Letterman. It would be the region’s top two elected officials, selected by the people to represent them, doing just that.
They would be the visible faces, the united personification, of a new idea of Pittsburgh. But they must be more than mascots.
More than mascots
All 16 of the Millennial officials mentioned above, for instance, have personal experience with the particular challenges facing precisely the generation of residents Pittsburgh needs to attract and retain.
That includes cost of living, access to childcare, youth- and family-friendly urban design, and housing affordability. And this means not just deep affordability, but accessible homeownership for middle-class families.
It could be incredibly constructive, for instance, for Mr. O’Connor to join forces with Ms. Innamorato to design a joint city-county program to attract and retain families, and for them both to work with the region’s Harrisburg and Washington delegations to secure whatever state and federal assistance might be available and useful.
Young leadership requires maturity and discretion, to be sure, but it’s a waste if it doesn’t deploy its distinctive advantages. Besides an innate understanding of the issues facing their generation, this also includes ambition, boldness, creativity and risk-taking.
These are all qualities Pittsburgh needs, that cut across ideological lines and that its young leaders might be more willing to exercise if they see themselves as a generational bloc.
In particular, it would be good for Pittsburgh for its young political leaders to see their task as transforming the city’s and region’s power structure, not just ingratiating themselves to it. And not primarily, or really at all, for ideological purposes, but for the purpose of empowering new people with new perspectives and new ideas that could make Pittsburgh a better place to live for more residents.
Pittsburgh’s problem
It’s amazing how frequently the question of what to do about Pittsburgh’s hidebound institutions comes up in private conversations about the future of this region. And yet the problem is clearly not a lack of young leaders, of which we have a surfeit. Nor do I suspect the problem is a lack of ambition, which is never in short supply in political circles.
Rather, it’s a lack of coordination, a lack of a sense of shared purpose that crosses ideological and other factional lines, and of the ability to organize creativity around such a purpose.
Now that the mayoral election is officially sorted out, Pittsburgh is faced with at least two years, and possibly many more, of Millennial executives.
Mr. O’Connor and Ms. Innamorato will have the power to set a regional agenda and to empower others — young people, newcomers, talented eccentrics (by Pittsburgh standards) — to reshape Pittsburgh from the inside out.
Working together, and alongside the city’s large cohort of youthful leaders, they can accomplish much more than they can by themselves.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “What is Pittsburgh’s role in Donald Trump’s America?”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.