It’s one of the better-known stories of destructive “urban renewal” in American history: In the late 1950s, under the decisive leadership of Mayor David L. Lawrence, Pittsburgh razed the Lower Hill District to make space for a “cultural acropolis” overlooking the Golden Triangle.

As a result, thousands of people — disproportionately though not exclusively Black — were removed to other parts of the city; the thriving commercial center of East Liberty — also disproportionately though not exclusively Black — was reconfigured with wide roads and high-rises in part to receive refugees; and in the end, only the Civic Arena was built, with several acres of parking lots cutting off the Hill from Downtown.

The knock-on effects of this single decision continue to this day.

This week, the Penguins will open their 16th season in the Civic Arena’s replacement, and yet there are at least as many acres of fallow pavement in the Lower Hill as there were in the 1960s. This gaping void in the middle of the urban core continues to represent one of the great failures of governance and leadership in Pittsburgh. But today, instead of representing brashness and arrogance, it represents timidity and fearfulness.

Advertise with us

Haunted by the past

Fifteen years ago, the idea of an Arena District modeled on the Columbus neighborhood surrounding Nationwide Arena was one of the most exciting prospects in Pittsburgh. The Fifth and Forbes corridors were to be transformed. The Hill District was to be reconnected to the heart of the city.

The reasons all this has yet to happen are complicated. Some point to the Penguins and the Sports and Exhibition Authority, which ceded the land’s development rights to an ice hockey franchise that is not an experienced property developer. Some point to community organizations that have demanded a wide variety of privileges and concessions, limiting the options for development in an increasingly challenging construction and financing environment.

In the strongest formulation of this criticism, the vacant land is seen to produce a commodity even more valuable than profit: guilt. The emptiness is a potent, ongoing reminder of the 70-year-old crime of displacement, whose memory will fade once the land is fully reintegrated into the urban fabric.

Litigating this matter is for another day. What is clear is that, no matter the mechanics of the stalled development, there is an underlying and widely shared attitude that has contributed to the delay here, and to foot-dragging on development all over Pittsburgh: Whatever we do, we don’t want to repeat the mistakes of urban renewal.

Pros and cons

This is an understandable and honorable sentiment. While Pittsburghers today rightly honor the visionary and decisive leadership of David L. Lawrence, it’s also undeniable that his boldness, and that of the entire First Renaissance leadership set, sometimes cost the city and its people, especially those on the margins.

Advertise with us

The scouring of the Lower Hill didn’t just destroy that neighborhood: It sent refugees to Homewood and East Liberty and the North Side, altering their subsequent histories; it served as a tourniquet cutting off circulation to the rest of the Hill District; it interacted with redlining to create patterns of poverty and de facto segregation that persist to this day.

The consequences of major land use choices last generations, and are impossible to undo. City leaders have an obligation to learn from those consequences, and to attempt to remediate them where it’s possible and prudent to do so.

But the fear of repeating history can also become stultifying, and exact its own costs — including for precisely the communities harmed by yesteryear’s grand visions. Indeed, racial disparities in Pittsburgh, a city too often paralyzed by fear of change and of growth and of decisiveness, have only deepened in recent years. This way, too, has not worked.

Be not afraid

It’s time — past time — to look at the Lower Hill not just as a symbol of the sins of the past, but also of the sins of the present. That is: The vacant pavement should remind us not just of the fateful project that did happen 70 years ago, but of the numerous that didn’t happen, or have been too-long delayed, because of the culture of fearfulness and timidity that has since settled over Pittsburgh.

Projects that go unbuilt don’t just represent harms not done, but also opportunities not created.

Advertise with us

Oakland Crossings wasn’t built, so at a busy junction in a neighborhood that’s bursting at the seams, the most prominent structure remains the World’s Tallest Panera Bread. The high-rise at the Bloomfield supermarket site wasn’t built, leaving a field of pavement at the heart of one of the city’s most walkable and desirable sectors.

On the bright side, Esplanade, the most ambitious redevelopment project in the city since SouthSide Works over two decades ago, has after several years cleared all its governmental hurdles. While it continues to be regarded with suspicion by some as a vehicle for “gentrification,” hopefully the project will succeed and help to erode the city’s bias against development.

All of these projects would have had, or will have, some form of negative consequences. Every alteration of the urban fabric unsettles the status quo, often in unpredictable ways.

But that unsettling can also unlock new potential, for everyone, that can’t be accessed in the status quo. The paralysis that results from ignoring the pros and emphasizing the cons — as the empty Lower Hill continues to show — does nothing to move Pittsburgh forward.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “America the beautiful, flawed and complicated.”