The seven months between the primary election and the inauguration of Pittsburgh’s next mayor should be the time during which the city’s elected leaders and other stakeholders hammer out a constructive governing arrangement for the next four years.
That means healing (or at least bandaging) the lacerations inflicted during the primary, acknowledging the new political reality the voters created, and forging relationships and compromises that allow for a reasonably seamless transition to the next administration.
During the last two weeks, however, it has appeared as if the voters never actually had their say. In a remarkable show of force detached from political reality, Mayor Ed Gainey and his allies have deployed divisive campaign-style tactics against City Council itself, and it’s unclear there’s a majority willing to push back.
But the council will have to find its footing quickly, because it has the responsibility to enforce the results of the primary (and therefore the election): Corey O’Connor won, and it would disrespect the voters to let the loser suddenly run roughshod over the legislature — a majority of whom endorsed the winner.
Seven months in limbo
The lame-duck period for Pittsburgh mayors, owing to the city’s single-party rule, is far too long, and is awkward for everyone involved.
Mr. Gainey is still mayor, with all the powers of the office that voters granted him four years ago. He still has policy priorities that he has every right to pursue, such as inclusionary zoning.
But those priorities have also been effectively rebuked by referendum. There’s no good reason for city council to seriously consider them, or certainly to pass them into law, during the lame-duck months. While Mr. Gainey retains his authority, the voters have revoked his mandate, and his leverage.
Meanwhile, Mr. O’Connor is not yet mayor, but now has the mayor’s leverage — the ability to make promises and threats for 2026 and beyond. But using it to influence the city’s legislative process could be seen as meddling and therefore could backfire, either privately or publicly.
As for city council, a majority endorsed the eventual winner, an unprecedented movement against a sitting mayor. This should mean the transition to Mr. O’Connor’s priorities has begun. But each member is still an independent person with his or her own interests and priorities. Further, Mr. Gainey is still in charge.
And, as he demonstrated last Wednesday by sending dozens of activists and community leaders to a council meeting under false pretenses, he can still generate a crowd.
Planned ambush
To the dozens of community leaders who were told by Mr. Gainey’s allies that city council (or, bizarrely, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board) was angling to “raid” the Stop the Violence Fund: You were lied to, and you were used.
Here’s what happened. The fund, created in 2020 to fund violence prevention efforts in the city, has long been scrutinized due to its lax accountability structures. This reached a climax in April, when City Controller Rachael Heisler sent a letter to city council detailing the fund’s serious shortcomings.
In June, Councilman Khari Mosley and Council President Daniel Lavelle introduced legislation to restructure the Stop the Violence Fund, at least in part to address these concerns. I understand that a majority of the council had expressed support for the bill. It was going to pass.
Yet members and allies of the Gainey administration seeded in activist circles the false idea that city council was holding the fund’s resources hostage, and might even defund it. The result was about 100 speakers at the key meeting on Wednesday, July 2, who accused the council, and seemingly Councilmen Anthony Coghill and Bob Charland in particular, of cruelly seeking to make Black communities less safe.
The Gainey administration and its most loyal defender, Councilwoman Barb Warwick, made the absurd claim that the crowd was stirred to action by a Sunday editorial in the Post-Gazette that echoed Ms. Heisler’s concerns about the fund and recommended pausing or slowing deposits while its $16 million surplus was carefully drawn down.
I only wish our editorials could be so inspirational: Of course, they all know that the ambush was planned long before the article was published.
Meanwhile, the Lavelle-Mosley bill passed unanimously. As it was always going to. The purpose of the spectacle was to show that Mr. Gainey still has firepower at his disposal. Mission accomplished.
Hold the line
Now it falls to city council to hold the line. One of the lessons from the primary should have been that these dishonest tactics, and activists’ antics in particular, have lost their luster. Mr. Gainey and his allies tried the same browbeating strategy on the electorate, and they lost. There’s no reason why city council should let them win.
Doing so would betray the voters.
That means, specifically, that the council should let Mr. Gainey’s radical inclusionary zoning bill, which would smother the last smoldering embers of Pittsburgh’s housing construction market and result in more expensive housing across the board, expire without action. If Pittsburghers wanted expanded IZ, they would have re-elected Mr. Gainey. They didn’t.
But more than that, the council must not be afraid of aggressive, gaslighting political tactics. They face much more political danger, and they fail in their duties to represent the people of Pittsburgh, if they allow themselves to be cowed by the losers.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Loving your country when it’s hard to.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.