He stood against the evening sky like a figure not quite meant to be among mortals. There was no space between his red athletic shirt — this was not a typical golf polo — and his body, so his perfect, sharp silhouette appeared to belong to a machine, or a visitor from another plane, and not a man.
It was Sunday at the U.S. Open in 2007, and my father and I had settled in about 100 yards from the 18th tee box. Angel Cabrera had finished the final round five over par. Only one contender could catch him, with a birdie on the startlingly long and narrow closing hole. It was Tiger Woods.
As he stood behind his golf ball, envisioning the shot he needed to make, suddenly his entire torso swelled and his shoulders rose, and then he returned to stillness. Even from a football field’s length away, I felt I could hear the deep breath, the demonstration that even Tiger Woods experienced nerves, and the need to settle them. He was a man, after all.
Then he proved it beyond a doubt: His drive tumbled into the right rough. His subsequent par sealed his second-place finish, and Cabrera’s maiden major title.
Chilly greatness
It was an exhilarating experience, an encounter with human exceptionality that I doubt I will have again. Yet I remember even at the time finding it unsettling.
It wasn’t just Woods’ athletic excellence that made him seem beyond human. There was also something darker, which I can only describe as joylessness, in his performance that day. I remember feeling that while the all-time-great had otherworldly gifts, he never gave the appearance of enjoying using those gifts.
This was more than the seriousness of competition, or the mellowing of exuberance with age. (He was 31 at the time, still very much in his prime.) His performance wasn’t perfunctory, exactly, but it seemed to lack passion and purpose.
That deep breath produced in me a sigh of relief: He is human. He is real. He does care.
I came away happy to have witnessed such a remarkable person in the flesh, but also troubled. There’s little colder in the human experience than greatness without happiness.
Only human
What no one could have known at the time was that, despite being in the middle of a record run as the world’s top-ranked golfer, Tiger Woods was past his peak. Only three of his 15 major championships would come after that June at Oakmont.
And only two-and-a-half years later, he would come to grief in one of the most spectacular personal dramas and media frenzies in sports history.
The revelation of Tiger Woods’ serial marital infidelity, and the massive fallout in terms of reputation and lost endorsements, seems almost quaint in retrospect. It dominated both sports and regular news for months in late 2009 and 2010; it’s hard to imagine it lasting more than a few 24-hour news cycles today. And corporations becoming skittish over consensual, even if unfaithful, sexual conduct sounds absurd only 15 years later.
Yet the episode provided an insight into the psyche of one of the most famous men and greatest athletes on earth. What we saw demonstrated, more than any poor swing, that the icon was only human.
Know thyself
“I thought I could get away with whatever I wanted to,” he said during his nationwide apology telecast. “I felt that I had worked hard my entire life and deserved to enjoy all the temptations around me. I felt I was entitled. … I was wrong. I was foolish.”
A Greek tragedian couldn’t have scripted the downfall of an exceptional man any better.
In retrospect, I’ve come to think that what I perceived on that Oakmont Sunday 18 years ago was a man who not only looked beyond-human, but was intentionally presenting himself as such, because he believed he was. Because he had been told he was, and had excelled as if he were, for so long.
In the years since, Tiger Woods’ life has been far from smooth. His marriage ended, though he appears to be close to his children, including son Charlie, an aspiring professional golfer. He has had injuries and accidents, including a DUI in 2017 and a devastating single-car crash in California in 2021, two years after his triumphant return to the winner’s circle at Augusta National.
But at least now no one, least of all himself, would mistake him for anything but a man.
Brandon McGinley’s previous article was “The Trump-Musk breakup may be funny, but unserious governance is no laughing matter.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.