Contrary to reports in the national press, Tuesday’s primary victory for Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor over incumbent Mayor Ed Gainey was not about progressivism versus centrism. Despite the Gainey campaign’s efforts to turn the race into a proxy battle over national politics, the result doesn’t tell us much about the ideological trajectory of the Democratic Party.

That’s because this was only marginally an election about ideology. Much more so, it was an election about competence. And the lesson it taught is that there’s only so much incompetence voters will tolerate, no matter how much they want to like an elected official — and that abstractions fade into the background when the water fountains aren’t flowing and the potholes aren’t filled.

Yet Mr. Gainey’s tumultuous term and ultimate defeat will still have significant knock-on effects in Pittsburgh politics — not so much on progressivism as an idea, but on the particular alliances and tactics that have come to define the city’s unique brand of progressivism: strident, bullying, heedless, shameless, utopian. This scene’s aura of invincibility, pierced last year in a low-profile state House primary, has definitively dissipated.

It should now be permanently sidelined in favor of a pragmatic governing liberalism that can deliver progressive results the progressive clique couldn’t.

Advertise with us

Fear factor

It’s difficult to overstate how stifling the atmosphere of fear has been in Pittsburgh politics over the past several years — inescapable, choking, sulfuric. Numerous people I’ve spoken to in the past few days, in and around city politics, have described the sensation of a weight being lifted since the primary results were confirmed. I feel it, too.

It was a professional fear, of course, that the apparent progressive juggernaut would unseat, or render unelectable, anyone who didn’t use the right language, praise the right people, advocate the right policies. But it was at least as much a personal fear, because so often these campaigns didn’t stop at political defeat and aimed at reputational annihilation.

Take last spring, when Mr. Gainey, County Executive Sara Innamorato and U.S. Rep. Summer Lee all endorsed a primary challenge against state Rep. Abigail Salisbury, whose crime was failing to yield to Ms. Lee’s preferred successor in her old legislative district. The campaign for Ashley Comans was managed by the same local activists and national organizations, notably the SEIU-connected Working Families Party, as Mr. Gainey’s.

It called Ms. Salisbury — one of the most progressive members of the legislature whose legal practice is dedicated to serving nonprofit organizations — a “conservative” and heavily implied she was a racist. It was the same playbook the same people would use a year later against Mr. O’Connor.

Ms. Salisbury prevailed against this assault — by 26 points. This was the first clear sign that voters were no longer impressed by the progressive clique and its bullying tactics. And it quietly set the stage for Mr. O’Connor’s successful challenge to Mr. Gainey.

Advertise with us

Three’s company

The temptation now is to believe that Mr. Gainey’s defeat signals the political weakness of Ms. Innamorato and Ms. Lee. But that would seriously misread the situation.

Ms. Lee is an exceptional political talent who occupies a position, as a federal legislator, where people expect little of her except haranguing the Trump administration. Concerns about progressives’ executive competence are irrelevant to her appeal, and she seems to float above the diminished reputation of her activist base.

Ms. Innamorato, for her part, has largely avoided the pitfalls that doomed Mr. Gainey. She hired a professional, experienced leadership team, and has consistently demonstrated the humility and wisdom of knowing what she doesn’t know. While there have been missteps — her day-one raises for county workers may prove more damaging even than her unavoidable tax hike — she has grown into her role in a way Mr. Gainey never did.

While she obligatorily endorsed Mr. Gainey, most of her team has long understood that an O’Connor mayoralty would provide far better opportunities for city-county cooperation, which would benefit her and her constituents. (I suspect she knows this, as well.) An O’Connor administration will also, by gravitational forces, pull Ms. Innamorato even further toward pragmatic progressivism and away from the toxic activist scene.

Survivor

The spell Pittsburgh’s most strident and shameless progressives had placed over the city’s political life has been broken.

Advertise with us

The power of the activist-industrial complex depends almost entirely on fear. Only a very small minority will ever fully agree with them. But if they can force people to pretend to agree with them, out of fear for their careers and reputations, they can project power well beyond their numbers.

What they fear most of all, therefore, is being ignored, because their relevance depends on attention, and on others adjusting their behavior and beliefs in response. Corey O’Connor and his supporters — including his five City Council endorsers and Ms. Salisbury, among others — have shown that if you aren’t afraid of them, you can challenge them and emerge on the other side not just intact, but stronger than ever.

Then, deprived of their life-force, the activists shrivel up like a demon after an exorcism. And the once-possessed patient again experiences the forgotten lightness of liberty, and the ability to plan for a brighter future.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “How my, and Pittsburgh’s, optimism about Ed Gainey dissolved into disappointment.”