About seven months ago, after the beautiful memorial service for former Allegheny County Executive Jim Roddey at the University of Pittsburgh, I wrote a column proposing a “Roddey Circuit” of events meant to bring together citizens and leaders from across the region and across the aisle. The idea was to model the civic virtues of the late Mr. Roddey by promoting trust and mutual understanding (and, perhaps above all, good humor).

On Thursday evening, I was honored to participate in the very first edition of the Jim Roddey Civic Circuit, hosted at Point Park University by Andy Conte, director of the university’s Center for Media Innovation. Tribune-Review columnist Joseph Sabino Mistick, who served as executive secretary to Mayor Sophie Masloff and as the Democratic foil to Mr. Roddey on Pittsburgh airwaves, joined me on stage to discuss the Roddey legacy and the state of politics in the city and the nation.

Former Pitt Chancellor Mark Nordenberg generously introduced the event with his own memories of and reflections on the life of Jim Roddey.

I’m generally not in the optimism business, but I came away from the evening reminded and reassured of the incomparable value of different people simply being, speaking and listening together. While I don’t think it’s enough to solve American politics (or to save the liberal international order), it is enough to nurture better relationships and better politics right here. And that’s enough.

Advertise with us

Political paradox

“This is the most important election of our lifetime,” people say every four years. And if enough people believe it, it becomes true regardless of the actual historical circumstances. In other words, especially over the past three decades or so, the stakes of politics have seemed to ratchet ever higher.

But it might be more accurate, if also more harrowing, to say that these years have revealed the reality — obscured by the façade of civility and the mirage of consensus — that politics always has been, and by its nature always will be, a matter of life and death. From health care to immigration to foreign policy, the results of political debates affect the well-being, the survival and the demise of millions of people and of entire societies.

In the face of this awesome responsibility, niceties like courtesy, respect and mutual understanding — let alone good humor — can appear weak and absurd. If I believe your views, if implemented, would increase suffering in the world, I have a moral duty to stop you — not to speak with you, not to listen to you, not to share a drink or a joke with you.

In this, however, is the paradox of democratic politics: It is a matter of life and death, but the only way to do it well is to act like it isn’t.

Cascading distrust

To actually do politics — as opposed to shrieking on social media to gin up buyers for whatever you’re selling — a person must understand the variety of interests and perspectives that people within the community have. This doesn’t mean abandoning or even seriously questioning one’s views, but it does mean understanding that taking others’ views seriously is the only way to persuade, and to achieve a compromise everyone can live with.

Advertise with us

In a functioning democracy, these political virtues aren’t reserved for the practitioners: They’re for everybody. That’s because it’s in the nature of representative government that, even after a landslide (or a tight but significant election like 2024), one side will rarely have the power to rout the other at the negotiating table.

If private citizens refuse to even try to understand why others might think differently from them, they will not understand the compromises struck by their representatives. Every concession will look like a betrayal, a sop to ignorance and brutality, rather than the necessary give-and-take between people of goodwill needed to get things done.

This attitude erodes trust, which has already been badly eroded. That leads to social and political insularity which, in turn, further reduces trust and the likelihood of rebuilding it. Social media aggravates this. Supposed to bring down barriers to understanding, it has instead raised them sky-high by empowering and rewarding those who traffic in shrillness, meanness and self-righteousness.

Practicing democracy

So, what is to be done? There’s no technical or policy solution for what ails our politics. That’s because it’s first and foremost a human problem.

Virtues, taught Aristotle, are habits. We aren’t born with them, though we might be blessed with inclinations to them. But we can form or re-form them, by making the choice to practice them over and over again.

Advertise with us

The Roddey Circuit is meant to be a venue to practice the habit — the virtue — of democracy, which requires openness to others’ personalities, views and experiences which can only be actualized face-to-face, person-to-person, soul-to-soul. This is all the more important right now, when the stakes of politics seem higher than ever, and the idea of civic friendship across ideological lines seems more absurd than ever.

It’s good in itself to try, and to start (following Aristotle again) at the level of the natural political community of the city. Maybe, hopefully, the model will spread.

I’m not sure if anyone involved with Thursday evening’s event understands precisely what we did, or how it worked, or what to do next. But there was agreement that it was good, for us and for the city we love, and that it’s worth doing it again. And that’s enough. It’s a lot.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “The future begins with Trump's inauguration on Monday.”