I’ve never believed in History with a capital H. I adore history — the stories, the people, the choices, the ideas, the movements, the events, the heroism, the squalor, the comedy, the majesty that make up our inheritance as human beings. What I don’t believe is that history has an independent existence or directedness, that there is some kind of final point toward which human civilization is inevitably progressing or evolving.

No one and nothing is “on the wrong side of History,” or the right side. History has no sides. Pol Pot was wrong not because (most) people who came after him decided he was wrong, but because what he did was objectively wrong.

Indeed, the judgments of History are unstable. Columbus was a hero, then a monster. But in the end, categorizing him as strictly good or evil reveals more about ourselves than it helps us understand him.

We don’t have any reason to believe the people of today are more intelligent or insightful than those 50 or 500 years ago, or 2400 years ago when Plato and Aristotle were writing. Today’s world isn’t better than it was at any particular moment in the past. I see no reason to believe it is getting, or will get, better still.

Advertise with us

Therefore, I say without moral judgment that with the second inauguration of Donald Trump, a genuinely new historical moment is dawning. The future is here.

The long slide

William F. Buckley famously wrote, “A conservative is someone who stands athwart history, yelling Stop.” His remark is a lodestar of American conservatism, but I’ve never found it very compelling.

Buckley’s formulation accepts the progressive view of History, while assigning conservatism the role of speedbump, or scold, to the advance of the liberal order. And that’s largely how the Right has operated since the end of the Second World War.

Even when the Right seemed ascendant, such as the Reagan-Thatcher years, nearly without fail it operated within the bounds of the post-war liberal order. To this day, the waning establishment wing of the American conservative movement sees itself as maintaining and strengthening that order.

Thus, despite periodic applications of a conservative veneer, the underlying culture of the West consistently moved toward the apparent perfection of expressive individualism: “everyone young going down the long slide // To happiness, endlessly,” as the English poet Philip Larkin slyly put it.

Advertise with us

Until now. For the first time in generations, the Right is the engine of human affairs.

Obsolete leaders

We are experiencing an inflection point, when everything most people in the West thought was settled — borders, sovereignty, currencies, globalism, colonialism, the ultimate hegemony of liberal democracy, the consensus that liberty and individualism are the paramount human values — has become unsettled.

I don’t just believe this because Donald Trump was elected, though his victory solidified it. I believe this because of Giorgia Meloni, Viktor Orbán, Geert Wilders and Herbert Kickl.

I believe it because of Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Narendra Modi. I believe it because in the coming years France, Germany and the United Kingdom will almost certainly choose governments of the Right, and likely the New (or far) Right.

I could believe this is a historical blip if the defenders of the liberal order had shown even the slightest understanding of the threat they’re facing, let alone the capacity to counter it. But Joe Biden, Kamala Harris and Justin Trudeau have been humiliated. Keir Starmer will be destroyed. Olaf Scholz is overmatched. And Emmanuel Macron will soon exit the stage.

Advertise with us

They are like the statesmen of Europe before the Great War: men and women of the past, oblivious to their own obsolescence, and complacent in their ignorance of the new world on the horizon.

I’m not saying democracy is doomed, and certainly not that it should be. I am saying that liberalism is facing its greatest systemic crisis since the Second World War.

Liberalism’s defenders have deluded themselves into believing that perfecting the liberal system is the endpoint of capital-H History. It is partly because of that illusion that the global order will look very different five or 10 years hence.

Political laboratories

It will be tempting to reckon these years a battle between democracy and autocracy, but this is simplistic. Rather, it will be a time of experimentation, when a wider variety of political options are available to Western nations than at any time since the 1930s.

Much of that experimentation will occur broadly within the bounds of democracy, but with a more vigorous executive, or with the emergence (as Mr. Biden described this week) of oligarchic elements, or with structural changes to electoral and representational systems. Some will follow Mr. Putin and Mr. Xi beyond democracy.

Advertise with us

But the criterion by which these experiments are judged can’t just be how closely they resemble the passing liberal order. Only those who have visibly benefitted from the way things are care about keeping the world that way. The lesson of all these elections is that there are a lot more people who feel alienated from the system than attached to it.

I don’t know whether what comes next will be better or worse. (I usually assume worse.) But something is coming next, beginning on Monday. Those who try to hold onto the liberal order as we’ve known it will turn themselves into Buckley’s speedbump.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “‘Imagine’ at a funeral, and the decline of Jimmy Carter-style Christianity.”