I didn’t think I’d be writing this column two years ago, when Trump-endorsed candidates bombed across the country in the midterm elections. I thought he was finished.
I didn’t think I’d be writing this column six months ago, when I thought his surprising strength in the polls would fade over the summer, as the reality of Donald Trump replaced the idea of Donald Trump in voters’ minds. I thought he couldn’t last.
I didn’t even think I’d be writing this column 60 days ago, when Kamala Harris appeared to be leading a movement and the best Trump could hope for was a toss-up. I thought he had been overcome.
But each time I was wrong, and now I am forced to admit: I think Donald Trump will win. And the reason is deeply embedded in the spirit of American democracy.
Titles of nobility
In some ways it’s more remarkable that Republican success is in doubt than that it appears likely. After all, structurally this should be a GOP year, in the wake of high inflation with a historically unpopular Democratic president whose party has succeeded in three straight two-year cycles.
But the question isn’t why Republicans in general will win, but why Donald Trump, despite his manifest flaws and the furor he provokes, will win. The answer has more to do with the hierarchical structure of American society than with Trump himself.
As a rule, Americans dislike hierarchy. And even if they accept that some form of hierarchy is inevitable, Americans really don’t like it when people of status lord it over those without status. It’s a sentiment that goes back to the revolution itself, and is enshrined in the Constitution’s ban on “titles of nobility.”
Today, however, titles of nobility are more prominent than at any time in U.S. history, and those who carry them are more careless than ever about how they wield them. What titles? Ph.D. Ed.D. MD. JD. Prof. Bylines in media. Credits in film. Secretary of this, director of that.
There’s nothing new about a de facto American nobility, but what is new is that they’re almost all on the same political team: the Democratic Party. And most of those who aren’t Democrats are anti-Trump.
Heresy hunters
What’s also new is that they cannot shut up about how they deserve their nobility and to be in charge — and how anybody who questions them hates science, truth and democracy.
You think the economy’s bad because knock-off Cheerios doubled in price and you can’t afford a home on a machinist’s wages? Fool! The experts say the economy is brilliant.
You found changing COVID public health guidance to be confusing, and the insistence on accepting it without question or hesitation to be oppressive? Imbecile! The experts say to trust the science.
You’re not comfortable with an elementary school teacher introducing gender theory without notifying you first? Cretin! The experts say the gender binary is a superstition.
Whatever you think about the substance of these issues, and others where the normal differences that emerge in pluralistic societies are treated like dogma versus heresy, nobody likes to be treated like an idiot. Yet time and again the modern nobility — or, perhaps more accurately, the modern clerisy — insists there can be no rational dissent.
They really believe they are in charge because they’re right. (Or are they right because they’re in charge?) And they’re almost all aligned with the Democrats.
Carrick versus Lebo
But why does this mean Trump will prevail? Because America is a democracy, and there are never enough nobles to carry the day when the demos is roused. And this particular form of nobility, so assured of its own merit and right to rule, has squandered too much of the public goodwill it needs to remain in power.
Meanwhile Trump, precisely through his bombast, has made himself the tribune of just about every American who, each for his or her own reason, want to take the nobility down a peg.
Consider two communities: the Virginia Manor section of Mt. Lebanon and the Carrick neighborhood of Pittsburgh. The former, the preserve of the nobility. The latter, the home of the overlooked.
It wasn’t long ago that Virginia Manor was a Republican stronghold, and Carrick an unquestioned Democratic bastion. Drive through today, though, and Virginia Manor is a sea of Harris-Walz signs, while there’s much more visible support for Trump in Carrick — including a robust display of Trump-Vance memorabilia above the neighborhood’s Little League fields.
The reason for this change in Carrick, which has already been consummated in outlying counties? The modern American nobility of academic and corporate and government credentialed elites, just like all the aristocracies through history, doesn’t think those people are worthy, let alone capable, of self-government. And those people see this, and they don’t care for it.
So every time that nobility calls them fascist for opposing them, those people are further confirmed in their desire to unseat them.
The problem for Kamala Harris, and for the Democrats as long as they remain the party of the nobility: There are a lot more Carricks in Pennsylvania, and across America, than Virginia Manors.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Trump may win because Pittsburgh is a basket case.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.