It was November 2019, and I was driving to Cincinnati to give a speech. At the time I was a book editor for a Catholic publisher, but I was nurturing a writing and speaking career of my own. A priest friend invited me to give a talk at his parish in suburban Ohio — but I was preoccupied with something else as I rolled down Route 22.

This young priest had recently befriended a bestselling author who was, to many people at the time, one of the most interesting people in America. More than that, he had educated this person in the Catholic faith and brought him into the church. And I was desperately hoping — though I didn’t want to seem too eager — that this author would consider attending my event.

When I got to the lectern, after a long dinner with Dominican priests at which a great deal of wine was poured, there at the back of the hall was JD Vance.

The apprentice

Of all the favorites to be Donald Trump’s vice presidential nominee, Mr. Vance was always the most interesting. Anyone else — Florida Sen. Marco Rubio, North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum, Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin — would have been a bridge to the hawkish and Chamber of Commerce wings of the pre-Trump GOP. But Mr. Vance represents a clean break.

Advertise with us

Not only that: He represents a clean break that will last.

I don’t think voters or commentators have yet realized just how important his selection is. Everyone can see he’s Mr. Trump’s apprentice, the heir to the MAGA throne. But that understates his significance. JD Vance is 39 years old. If the ticket prevails, he will likely be a fixture of American politics, in some form or another, for the next several decades.

No person since at least Ronald Reagan, and possibly Franklin Roosevelt, has dominated and defined American politics like Donald Trump has for the last decade. But it’s possible that a century from now historians will remember Mr. Trump as the man who cleared away the broken-down old order, within the GOP and in American politics generally, so another — with more time and a more complete vision — could build the new one.

In other words, while Mr. Trump will always be the defining figure of this era of American politics, Mr. Vance may prove to be, in the long run, the more important one.

Expansive vision

To my delight, my priest friend told me that JD wanted to hang out after my talk. We ended up at a Cheesecake Factory in suburban Cincinnati.

Advertise with us

I don’t remember the conversation in detail — I did not know, or have any reason to think, I was speaking with a man who might live at the Naval Observatory only five years later. But I do remember we talked at length about what was ailing American society, and what to do about it.

Mr. Vance was more hopeful about responding to the crises of the post-modern age — economic, political, spiritual — through government and politics than I was. My focus was on forming healthy families and friendships and local communities, in the hope that these would bear fruit for the wider society. While he did not give the impression he intended to enter politics himself, he was clearly thinking much bigger: about how political power could be deployed to significantly reshape American society.

To understand JD Vance, his potential role in a Trump administration and his influence beyond, you must understand this: His views are not reducible to a collection of “positions” on “issues.” His interests and intellect are far more expansive.

Mr. Vance is interested in the entirety of the American regime — that is, the corporate-governmental-international superstructure of our political order. And he thinks it’s fundamentally broken, because so many of the people who live under it are not thriving, not reaching their full potential as human beings living in community with one another.

Vice President Kamala Harris famously enjoys asking her listeners to imagine “what can be, unburdened by what has been.” But in this moment, she represents the party and ideology of the status quo, of tweaking but ultimately maintaining the current order. Her catchphrase describes the brash and youthful conservative-revolutionary politics of Mr. Vance much more closely than her own.

Advertise with us

Man of the future

In the years since our cheesecake summit, Mr. Vance and I have crossed paths on a few occasions. I was enthusiastic about his Senate bid, then disappointed by the Trumpian, then super-Trumpian, turn it took. It seemed to prove what I had always felt: You can’t get into that business without losing yourself.

But there is another interpretation: Mr. Vance believes the American order needs to be re-ordered, from the top. He thought Mr. Trump was not the correct means to achieve that end. Then, once he got into the game and saw the system from the inside, he decided Mr. Trump was the only means to achieve that end.

Then he played his cards as well as any politician in generations to get himself on that Milwaukee stage in less time than it takes to get through airport security.

You can admire or deplore his skill, but you can’t deny it. While he may not yet have the presence of a more seasoned politician — or, in his inimitable manner, Mr. Trump — he has the intellectual confidence and vision to bring to pass the kind of transformation Mr. Trump can only gesture toward.

The man at the back of that parish hall may turn out to be one of the most important people of this century.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Even after Trump assassination attempt, we're still sleepwalking toward the tripwire.”