After nearly three years, this was my last week as a Pittsburgh Regional Transit commuter. I can no longer justify the costs the system’s unreliability imposes on me and my family.
I don’t consider this moving up in the world. If anything it’s a step backward. Sitting on the bus or the T was, for me, a relaxing buffer between work and home. I’d read or think or just look out the window and take in my world in a way that’s impossible while locked in to the road ahead. Sometimes I’d even draft my column on my phone.
I loved the idea of remaining a transit commuter for as long as I commuted. I imagined being wizened and grizzled someday (perhaps sooner than I’d like) and still confidently using the buses and trolleys that are, to my mind, integral to Pittsburgh’s identity.
Perhaps that future will still come to pass, but right now PRT has lost me. Losing one rider may not be a big deal, but the agency needs riders like me — transit users by choice, rather than necessity — to be sustainable.
An epiphany
It generally took about 45 minutes to travel the four miles between my Brookline home and the Post-Gazette’s North Shore newsroom. In the mornings, that meant a bus ride with 30-minute headways (the time between buses) to Station Square, where light rail trains were supposed to arrive every five minutes or so. The T would spit me out on the North Shore within sight of our building. That part generally went smoothly.
In the evenings, it was a trolley to South Hills Junction, where I’d transfer to an every-30-minute bus to a few blocks from home. This would often get hairy. The information about train arrivals on the screens in the North Side T station, and in my own smartphone app, was regularly inaccurate. If a scheduled train arrived late (or not at all), I’d be liable to miss my bus, leaving me to choose between walking or arranging transportation from a distant T Station or smelling sewage at South Hills Junction for the next half-hour.
This happened roughly once a week.
Then in May, PRT closed the Downtown subway for essential repairs. So I’d take the bus Downtown and walk across the Allegheny in the mornings, and do the opposite in the evenings.
I like a good walk, but in late May I was offered a reprieve: one of the newspaper’s disused cars for reporters. So for nearly two weeks, I drove it to and from the newsroom. And, unfortunately, I liked it.
Transit-by-choice
For the past decade, as my family went from zero to six kids, we owned one car. (All hail the Honda Odyssey.) Transit allowed us to continue this way when I went from working from home to commuting to the PG. Even when I’d get frustrated with a delayed trolley — not to mention my wife’s frustration waiting for me while dealing with a half dozen inconsistently angelic children — I knew we were saving a car payment, car insurance, maintenance, gas and parking.
This is the kind of calculation PRT needs to capitalize on. A transit agency doesn’t have to be perfect to be worth it. But it does have to reach a baseline of consistency — especially when the frequency of service has been cut back — to ensure the costs in convenience don’t overwhelm the savings in cash. If you’re making people organize their schedules around buses that arrive every half-hour, those buses (and connecting trains) better be there.
I’m fortunate to be a transit-by-choice rider. Reliability lapses are all the more frustrating when you absolutely need transit. But transit agencies need riders like me to contribute fares to keep the system going.
I understand that some recent service disruptions have been due to essential (and often deferred) maintenance. I endured evening subway closures and Mt. Washington Transit Tunnel closures and Saw Mill Run overpass closures. I was prepared to endure more. But the basic standards of reliability and professionalism were simply not being met.
The last straw
My first day back on transit after returning the company car, I was running late for my son’s Little League game — and if I missed the next bus, I’d miss the game entirely. I descended to the North Side platform, where the screen indicated a train was about to arrive.
It did not. And the next was not for 20 minutes, way past my connection time.
Ten minutes into the wait, a train not indicated on the screens showed up. I barely made my transfer — but I was beside myself.
The next morning, the bus worked just fine, as it normally does. I stepped onto the Station Square platform, during rush hour, and the screen indicated a 20 minute wait for the next train. I turned around and began my walk across both rivers.
And as I crossed the Smithfield Street Bridge, I began to research used cars for large families.
Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.