It’s a constant refrain when talking with people who know just how fragile Pittsburgh’s public safety apparatus is: We’ve been very lucky. For now.

With a week of hot weather behind us, like many Pittsburghers I’ve been thinking about whether the city will have a hot summer of violence and disorder. Last year, as police manpower dwindled below 800, I had the same concerns — but cool heads generally prevailed. Crime has not risen in Pittsburgh as police presence has declined.

That’s neither normal nor abnormal: Studies of the relationship of crime to police manpower are inconsistent, with some showing no relationship and others showing significant reductions, such as drops of 13% in violent crime and 7% in property crime with a 10% increase in police staffing. Another claims that one murder a year is prevented for each 10 to 14 additional officers.

You can believe what you want about whether cops reduce the crime rate. Here’s what I know: If other underlying factors — poverty, drugs, gangs, boredom — lead to a flare-up of violence this summer, Pittsburgh’s police will be run ragged. And Pittsburghers will not feel — or be — as safe as they deserve.

Advertise with us

Diminishing returns

Graduating classes of police recruits have stabilized the bureau’s manpower above 750 sworn officers — but only temporarily. That’s because at least 35 cops are set to retire in July, when a pension-boosting clause in the police union’s contract kicks in.

The wave of retirements will knock the bureau’s staffing once again below 750, which is 100 officers fewer than the budgeted staffing. And that budget itself represents a decline from the 900 considered the baseline under Mayor Bill Peduto.

It bears repeating that the claims of Mayor Ed Gainey and Chief Larry Scirotto that Pittsburgh will soon return to budgeted staffing levels are absurd. Academy classes have shown diminishing returns: 24 then 15 graduates, almost all white men. This recruitment cycle, ten times as many candidates applied to the fire academy as to the police academy: about 1,500 to 150.

The best response the city’s leaders can muster has been lowering standards, including allowing candidates rejected by multiple psychologists to re-take their screenings.

Besides being dangerous in itself, lowering standards does not make policing more appealing. Exactly the opposite: By further diminishing the stature of the profession, it ensures that fewer qualified and quality people will want to join. Raising standards, while it might screen out more candidates in the short term, would bear more and better fruit in the long term.

Advertise with us

The problem is the administration has a crisis in the very short term, even though it refuses to admit it.

One per ten thousand

On a recent Sunday afternoon, 36 police officers patrolled the entire city of Pittsburgh. That’s six for each of the bureau’s six zones. That’s a little more than one for each 10,000 residents of the city.

It’s like having four or five cops on duty for all of Penn Hills or Monroeville or McCandless. Or one in Dormont or McKees Rocks.

You might remember the Matrix police staffing study, which recommended slashing police patrols by one-third because the bureau was “overstaffed” and responded to calls for help too quickly. Quite sensibly, Mr. Gainey dismissed that recommendation. But on that Sunday, staffing was less than half of what Matrix even recommended.

The fact this goes mostly unnoticed by everyday citizens is a matter of luck. Yes, Mr. Scirotto’s procedural reforms, such as moving away from parking enforcement (good) and no longer dispatching for non-violent crimes like theft and harassment (not good), have made each patrol officer more available for serious crimes.

Advertise with us

But with only three dozen officers on duty, a single serious crime in any zone would empty that zone, and possibly adjacent zones, of their entire police protection. Two or three on the same shift would empty the city.

Further, Pittsburghers are right to wonder how many crimes are simply going unreported because officers aren’t responding to them. They’re also right to wonder what habits and networks of crime may be forming beneath notice, which will mature into brazen violence in due course.

Time’s up

Meanwhile, morale is low and dropping. Sixteen officers have resigned from the bureau so far this year. These are mostly prime-age men and women moving to other agencies or leaving the profession entirely. Before 2022, there were typically around 10 resignations in an entire year.

Like deaths vs. births in Pittsburgh or funerals vs. baptisms in most churches, the losses are outpacing the gains. And there’s no end in sight.

The only solution is to change the way people think about policing. That means treating law enforcement as an honorable profession, as opposed to (at best) a necessary evil, and putting into place the kind of rigorous training and accountability that keeps it honorable. Unfortunately, this clashes with the ideology of the activists to whom the Gainey administration has proven completely responsive.

Advertise with us

And so Pittsburgh will continue to press its luck. When it runs out, it’ll be too late to do anything about it.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.