Pittsburgh’s always behind the times. It’s one of the things I love about my hometown.
Fashions land here years after they’ve hit New York and Los Angeles. Before streaming and COVID emptied the theaters, movies would debut here weeks or months after the coasts. Lawrenceville became hipster long after Williamsburg and Bushwick set the tone, then it followed them into gentrification.
Unsurprisingly, Pittsburgh also tends to play catch-up on political trends. Conservative “blue dog” Democrats died out here several years after they went extinct elsewhere (and a few still manage to hang on). And the new, strident progressivism remained in incubation here even as it seized power in other cities. Only in the past two years has the movement reached something like full flower, with the elections of Mayor Ed Gainey and County Executive Sara Innamorato.
Being late adopters comes with a practical advantage: We can see how things have gone elsewhere before jumping headlong into ’90s revival fashion or the “Cats” movie or experimental cuisines. This partially explains Ms. Innamorato’s narrow escape in last year’s general election, and district attorney candidate Matt Dugan’s spectacular collapse: Pittsburgh can see where other cities’ progressive experiments have gone.
Indeed, as Pittsburgh has largely let the progressive wave wash over the city, elsewhere the tide has been going out.
Do something
“Big blue cities are embracing conservative anti-crime measures” ran the headline in Politico this week.
In San Francisco, voters approved referenda on Tuesday to remove restrictions on police officers and to require drug testing for recipients of some social programs. In Washington, D.C., the city council passed anti-crime legislation this week that targets carjacking and retail theft, and that will allow judges to keep more defendants in jail before their trials. And in New York City, Gov. Kathy Hochul has followed Mayor Eric Adams’ tough-on-crime policies by ordering the state’s National Guard to police Gotham’s subway system.
In all three cities, and all over the internet, progressives have howled. Truth be told, some of their arguments are sound. Simply putting more people in jail won’t address the root causes of crime, such as social dysfunction and economic despair, and in the long run will likely worsen them. Further, across the country crime rates are genuinely down over the last year, including in most cities.
Washington is a notable exception: Violent crime was up over a third in 2023. In Pittsburgh, however, based on official figures (which some dispute) crime was substantially lower last year than the year before.
But the crime that’s happening is certainly more visible, in part due to social media and in part due to the nature of the crimes. The retail theft and carjackings experienced in other cities — trends which Pittsburgh is, once again, blessedly behind — bring crime into the everyday consciousness of everyday people, making everyone feel less safe.
It’s an iron law: People who are accustomed to security will not tolerate feeling unsafe in their person and their property, and no amount of data analysis can alleviate that feeling. And they will demand that something must be done, and politicians will have to comply.
It may not be fair, but it’s human nature.
Security vs. anxiety
It’s not my purpose here to criticize the reforms and social programs progressives advocate for. Rather, I’m making a observation about political reality: Progressive priorities will never have a durable, critical mass of support if they coincide with, or are perceived to cause, declines in quality of life for everyday people.
That means concerns like crime and unsheltered homelessness and public drug use. That also means draining government budgets such that basic services — smooth streets, clean public spaces, ample parks — become threatened.
A progressive might respond that the phrase “everyday people” smuggles in a priority for the comfortable middle class that undercuts what should be our priority for the poor and the marginal. Focusing on the comfort and security of these “everyday people,” especially for the more ideological left-winger, is exactly how the poor become and remain poor, and the marginal become and remain marginal.
The Marxist in me — trust me, he’s in there somewhere — wants to agree. But in practice, it simply doesn’t matter: In a democracy you can’t remain in power by appearing indifferent to, let alone exulting in, dispossessing everyday people of the security and services and lifestyle they have come to expect.
In other words, while we are always called to make progress toward a more just society, the political program known as progressivism is a luxury for times of prosperity and security. It requires effective management of public money and the wider economy, so there’s ample resources to spend and the perceived costs to most people are negligible.
Social and political experiments don’t fly in times of fiscal fragility and middle-class anxiety.
Melting away
So if San Francisco and New York are past peak progressivism, does that mean Pittsburgh is right behind them, as usual? The comparisons aren’t perfect, because the bigger cities went farther, especially on criminal justice, than Pittsburgh has. It’s hard to roll back progressive criminal justice policies that never happened.
But the more pressing concern for progressives is this: They are presiding — whether by coincidence or by cause-and-effect, it doesn’t really matter — over the end of a too-brief era of optimism in southwestern Pennsylvania, and its replacement, once again, by the anxiety of decline.
Homelessness and drug abuse may be the most visible manifestations of this mood shift, but more important is the coming city budget crunch that is quietly undermining the very foundations of Pittsburgh’s civic life and regional confidence. A retreat to the core services of public safety and public works is all but inevitable.
When that occurs, progressive visions, no matter how appealing, will melt away in the acid bath of fiscal necessity, and the only question will be who can marshal the city’s dwindling resources most efficiently. Pragmatism will once again be the order of the day in Pittsburgh — late, as always.
Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.