It was an opportunity to actually help people, to offer real solutions to real problems. Instead, the politicians turned it into an opportunity to show off for their friends and stigmatize an enemy, and in the process further divided the community.

I could be talking about any number of recent episodes, but today I’m talking about the Adda Coffee imbroglio, in which local elected officials, in their progressive zeal — or their zealous desire to appeal to progressives — continue to show they are losing touch with the public purpose of their public offices.

On Jan. 10, the employees of a small chain of local coffee shops announced their intent to form a union. Fair enough: The work can be physically and emotionally demanding, and the varying needs of cafes can lead to inconsistent hours that make scheduling one’s non-work life all but impossible. It’s not at all extreme for such workers to want a say in how their workplace functions, and while there are more collaborative options, unionization is the typical way to ensure this.

The next day, the business owner, entrepreneur and former tech executive Sukanta Nag, shuttered the entire operation — all four Adda locations — for good. Well, fair enough: Mr. Nag has said the business had only ever lost money and that he closed it for that reason.

Advertise with us

It’s easy to understand why a part-time coffee shop owner might not want the hassle of dealing with a union. While federal labor law restrains employers from shutting down a particular location in response to union activity, it does not (and, without a terrifying invasion of liberty, cannot) stop an owner from closing a business entirely.

That should have been the end of it. The workers took a bold step based on a miscalculation of Adda’s profitability and Mr. Nag’s desire to persevere in the cafe business, and they lost. Whether to stay in business is Mr. Nag’s decision and his alone.

Enemy of the people

A few days later, however, a gaggle of politicians rallied outside one of Mr. Nag’s other businesses, a Sharpsburg event and gallery space, and proceeded to heap vituperation on him.

Newly-minted County Executive Sara Innamorato, whose job description includes attracting businesses to the region, vaguely and somewhat darkly declared, “We will not stand for it.” Lieutenant Governor Austin Davis, an envoy from an administration that has made economic development and business partnerships a cornerstone of its governance, called the closure “unconscionable and shameful.”

Advertise with us

Several state legislators joined the group. Politicians and media seem to have accounted for a significant majority of the attendees.

This was a public shaming of a private person, given credence and force by public officials, using the public platform and public trust given to them by voters. It was an attempt to use this public power, without anything resembling due process, to exact vengeance on a disfavored person by hurting his other business.

It was, in short, an outrageous abuse of public office.

Further, there’s no remedy the politicians could offer the workers they claim to support. How, exactly, is Ms. Innamorato not going to stand for it? Does she propose to force Mr. Nag to reopen his coffee shops and continue to lose money? This is not how government works, at least in this country.

Capital and labor

Advertise with us

Labor unions and small businesses — especially low-margin small businesses like coffee shops — are rarely a healthy combination. (Apparently successful union efforts at La Prima and Coffee Tree Roasters are notable exceptions to this rule.) Besides the potential increase in labor costs, the administrative overhead is a tax on a business’s earnings and, at least as importantly, on the owner’s time and attention.

Now, if a business owner can’t figure out how to provide dignified wages and working conditions while remaining solvent, that’s on the owner. Owning a business comes with significant moral responsibilities to one’s customers and above all to one’s employees.

That includes not closing the business without warning. It treats the workers as nothing more than economic inputs, rather than the partners they could and should be.

But local politicians’ stark good vs. evil, capital vs. labor framing isn’t the way to encourage more dignified businesses. It’s the way to chase businesses away by framing owners as enemies — and to encourage workers to make brash decisions that end with nobody happy.

The particularly frustrating aspect of this episode is that, if the politicians could stop grandstanding for a single moment, there were important lessons to be learned from it. In fact, this should have been a perfect opportunity for Ms. Innamorato to bring up her campaign promise to start a county task force on employee ownership.

Advertise with us

Working together

It’s good for both small businesses and their employees when workers have a sense of ownership over their workplace — or, better yet, a real ownership stake in it. Research consistently shows that workers are more loyal and diligent, and businesses more profitable and sustainable, when employees take part in the ownership of the company.

An employee stock ownership plan (ESOP), for instance, allows workers to receive equity in the company as an employment benefit. Then there is full employee ownership, which is a course the Adda debacle might have taken if the two sides approached their situation more collaboratively. Instead, a showdown resulted, predictably, in mutually assured destruction.

Ms. Innamorato and Mr. Davis could have lamented the outcome of the Adda mess and pointed to a real way forward: an emphasis on raising awareness about and incentivizing employee ownership programs that bring small-business workers and management onto the same team. Instead, they used their power to try to turn a private citizen into a public enemy — and helped neither the community they represent, nor the workers they claim to support.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.