Sawdust. Horseshoes. Eggs on spoons. Water balloons.

This is not an attempt at free-verse poetry. These are the images that come to mind when I remember my dad’s company picnics at Settler’s Cabin Park. And the company was United States Steel.

My dad’s an aircraft mechanic, and he spent most of his career at iconic Pittsburgh companies: first Alcoa, where he met my mom, then CONSOL, and finally U. S. Steel. (The company insists on a space between the U. and the S., but I suspect the Japanese won’t be sticklers for that.) His job was to ensure executives and board members arrived safely for meetings and site visits and the like, all over the world. The names of the CEOs — Mr. Usher, Mr. Surma — live in my mind like figures out of legend.

About a decade ago, I became a member of a not-very-exclusive club: the fraternity of sons whose dads were laid off by U. S. Steel. That was Mr. Longhi’s doing, part of the weirdly cultish “Carnegie Way” efficiency program that sucked all the residual humanity out of Mr. Carnegie’s company. My dad says it should’ve been called the “Frick Way.”

Advertise with us

I’ll admit, it’s hard to argue the U. S. Steel of the 21st century needed three corporate aircraft — but my dad did a hell of a job keeping them in the sky, and I think he deserved better, after 20 years of service, than the suits brusquely telling him to turn around and go home one February morning.

Spirit of calculation

My dad is a member of the last generation to expect loyalty between workers and corporations to be a two-way street. It’s easy now to regard that attitude as naïve, but the truth is U. S. Steel was one of the last vestiges of the golden age of the American Dream. It was one of the last companies you felt you could grow old with. Until one day it wasn’t.

The number-crunchers will want to intervene here, like the Businessman visited by Saint-Exupéry’s Little Prince, to insist U. S. Steel’s lifelong financial commitments were what made the company weak, not great. This is the kind of thinking, of course, only someone on another planet, morally or physically, could indulge. It’s the same spirit of calculation that leads Scrooge to insist the poor die quickly “to decrease the surplus population.”

What weakened U. S. Steel, of course, wasn’t its generosity; it was a globalized economy, along with the cult of shareholder value, that made its generosity unsustainable. That the company’s legacy commitments to its workers, especially retired workers, contributed to its decline shouldn’t be regarded with disdain, but with regret: The economy should sustain workers in dignity throughout their lives. And it’s a failure, not the natural order of things, when it doesn’t.

Advertise with us

There is, then, a double irony in Nippon Steel’s takeover of U. S. Steel. First, of course, it’s the next step in the logic of globalization and maximizing shareholder value that had hollowed out U. S. Steel to begin with. But the fact it’s a Japanese company investing in American steel also puts the lie to the notion that competitiveness requires treating employees like disposable economic inputs: In Japan, the spirit of mutual loyalty remains much stronger than in America, and defined-benefit retirement plans — like the legacy plan my dad was fortunate to have from U. S. Steel — are much more common.

In other words, U. S. Steel is being bought by a company more like the U. S. Steel of old, than like what U. S. Steel had become.

Memories and museum pieces

While it had been withering for some time, as far as I’m concerned the U. S. Steel that made America great was gone for good when it no longer needed my dad.

And for my own children, both U. S. Steel and the economy that went with it are only memories and museum pieces. They think, despite my corrections, that the U. S. Steel Tower is the UPMC Building. Steel sites are now “heritage sites,” and even the ones that are going concerns appear like Carnegie’s other great love, dinosaurs, come to life.

Advertise with us

In the fall, we attended Rivers of Steel’s wonderful Festival of Combustion at the Carrie Furnace site in Rankin. The kids loved it: glass blowing and steel welding and iron pouring, all in the shadow of the hulking ruins of a world they’ll never know. It was a demonstration, in ways big and small, of what human beings are capable of making — the kind of things we simply don’t see very much any longer.

It was for them closer to the blacksmiths and butter-churners in Williamsburg than the economy of Amazon and Walmart and Highmark.

A thing of the past

While they gawked, I slipped away for a moment to an area outside the main festival grounds. There, propped against an old brick wall, was a broken sign that once adorned the mill with that iconic offset USS logo and the words “United States Steel.”

I stared at it, and I felt nostalgia for a world I barely knew — except through visits to my dad’s hangar, and those blue-collar company picnics, and the security our family experienced, for a little while, because there was still space in U. S. Steel, in Pittsburgh, in America for a man without a college degree to really be something.

Advertise with us

And I was glad that this lost world was being celebrated with such a festival, while hating that it had been reduced to a festival.

I knew, and know, that just up the river, U. S. Steel is still turning iron and coal into pipes and sheets of steel. But this scene left no doubt that the real U. S. Steel, like the eggs on spoons and water balloons, was already a thing of the past long before Nippon Steel came knocking.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.