A decrease in violent crime this year in Pittsburgh has masked the deepening crisis in the city’s Bureau of Police. Propelled into office in part on a police reform platform, Mayor Ed Gainey is stuck between a political base of activists and prosperous progressives who hold as a first principle that police are a blight on society and the hard realities of fulfilling the first responsibility of municipal government: public safety.

The result has been a collection of contradictory policies and downright false public claims meant to assuage both activists and the wider public that their concerns are being respected.

People on either side — police reform activists and workaday Pittsburghers concerned about crime — may be tempted to suspect the administration is appeasing them while pursuing a grand strategy in favor of the other side. But the truth is there’s no strategy at all, except for trying to gaslight everyone just long enough to win reelection in 2025.

No coherent strategy

Advertise with us

In May, the Gainey administration finally released the results of a police staffing study — mired in controversy due to procurement irregularities — which recommended reducing the number of patrol officers by one-third, from 90 to 60 in each of the six zones. The gist of the report: Pittsburgh police had too much free time.

Everyone with knowledge of the force found this suspicious, and the public recoiled at losing nearly 200 neighborhood patrol officers. But anti-police activists cheered: This was the imprimatur they’d been waiting for.

So Mr. Gainey and new Chief Larry Scirotto held a press conference where they said they approved of the study overall, but that the patrol officer reductions went too far. But six months later, those reductions have been quietly implemented — and then some. Most zones are down to 60 officers, while Zone 6 — the biggest (and safest) containing the West End, Beechview and Brookline — is in the low 40s, or less than half of what had previously been considered full staffing.

At the same time, the administration has committed to the idea of maintaining an overall force of 900 officers — while cutting next year’s budgeted figure to 850. This gives the illusion of having cut police funding to satisfy one side, while promising the other side they don’t really mean it.

But it’s absurd to believe, as Office of Management and Budget director Jake Pawlak has claimed, that the force will return to 850 by the end of 2024. Here’s the truth: Pittsburgh is on track to lose 10% of its police officers this year to either retirement or resignation, despite a historic raise this year. If that rate continues next year — and given the quality and quantity of officers with exit plans, it will likely be at least that — the force will be below 690 this time next year.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, academy classes are showing diminishing returns. This year’s June class has 27 members, and the November class only 19. At most one of three 2024 classes will be complete by the end of the year. So the very best case scenario is that in a year we’ll be right where we are now: 763.

Meanwhile, to maximize the impact of fewer officers, the Gainey administration has countenanced disbanding the bureau’s community relations office while starting up a ’90s-style street crime division, which will weaponize community outreach for crime fighting and bring more people of color into the criminal justice system for low-level offenses.

The only way to make sense of it all it this: In trying to keep everyone happy, the Gainey administration is working toward a smaller, more brutal police force. That is, the worst of both worlds.

A matter of respect

The bedrock of the problem is this: Not enough people want to be Pittsburgh police officers. That includes hundreds of people who are currently Pittsburgh police officers, and no longer want to be. Yes, it’s that bad.

Advertise with us

This raises the uncomfortable question of why so few people want to be city cops. Whereas a generation (or even a decade) ago, it would have been commonplace for a middle-class family to enthusiastically support a child’s law-enforcement vocation, now most families would discourage it. The reason: The public respect accorded to police officers no longer matches, and justifies, the inherent difficulty and risk.

Holding police in too high regard has its own dangers, especially when that means the justice system treats them as above the law. When honor translates into impunity, it leads to dishonorable behavior. Just ask the Catholic Church.

But that is no longer the culturally dominant attitude, at least in urban centers. Consider this typical response to concerns about police recruitment and retention: Good riddance — if you don’t want to be a city cop under current conditions, that just shows you were only in it to brutalize the citizenry.

This is dangerously ignorant. Making policing unrespectable will not attract people who want to spend their entire careers swimming against waves of cultural and political disapproval: It will attract people who don’t give a rodent’s behind about being respectable.

And that’s exactly what’s happening in Pittsburgh right now. Faced with burgeoning workloads, performative scowls from the Mayor’s Office and a decline in the culture of the bureau — to use Mr. Scirotto’s cliches — it’s not the “warriors” leaving the force: It’s the “guardians.”

Advertise with us

No more happy talk

For now, the effects of the bureau’s crisis aren’t very visible, at least in terms of violent crime. Homicides returned to 2020 figures, while the bureau’s 65% clearance rate this year is respectable. Even so, Mr. Gainey felt the need to embellish that number in his budget address, claiming an 80% rate.

But the decline of the Pittsburgh police is not sustainable. While Mr. Gainey inherited a force reeling from the dual shocks of 2020 — a pandemic that paused academy classes and a racial justice reckoning that placed law enforcement in a more negative light than ever — he cannot shirk responsibility for strengthening it.

And that will begin by being honest about the crisis, no matter the political cost. Trying to keep everyone happy will end up with everyone less safe.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.