“Shut your eyes, and trust in me,” the great Sterling Holloway hisses as Kaa the cobra in Disney’s “The Jungle Book.” The boy Mowgli doesn’t trust him, of course, but Kaa has something he thinks is better than trust: the power of hypnosis. Who needs real trust when you can force your adversary to comply?

This has become the theory of government of the Gainey administration, especially with regard to City Council. While quasi-public interactions — but who actually watches City Council meetings? — between the executive and the legislature remain largely cordial, behind the scenes council members increasingly realize the trust they’ve felt obligated to place in the Mayor’s Office has been abused.

The problem is that in Pittsburgh’s strong-mayor form of government, there’s only so much council can do about it. The truth is, the system depends on trust — or, lacking that, the council’s ability to verify it isn’t being hoodwinked.

But the most robust tool for accountability — curious and aggressive local media — has atrophied in recent years, leaving City Council scrambling to figure out how to deal with an untrustworthy executive.

Advertise with us

Strong mayor, weak council

It’s easy to imagine Pittsburgh city government as a miniature version of Washington or Harrisburg, but municipal government works very differently. In a strong mayor-council form of government, the mayor has much more power, even if on a much smaller scale, than a governor or president.

And there’s a good reason for this: Municipal government is responsible for all the ground-level details state and federal governments aren’t, and efficiency requires an executive with a free hand to set priorities and make decisions. Councilmembers advocate for their districts and approve spending, but almost all that spending — and a good deal of changes to city code — is initiated by the Mayor’s Office, not the legislature.

The difficulty is that every week, the executive sends dozens of requests to spend taxpayer funds to City Council, but council has very few resources to vet those contracts and other proposals. As Councilman Bobby Wilson explained during Thursday’s budget hearings, he has three staff members whose primary responsibility is constituent services — no one has the time or expertise to pore through Mr. Gainey’s budget and bills.

And City Council as a whole has very few staff to itself. Besides half a dozen clerks, whose important roles are purely procedural, the legislature has a policy manager, a pair of budget directors, a solicitor and — that’s it. And the solicitor is new, arranged by Ms. Kail-Smith last summer in an early sign the Council President sensed her team was going to need to stand up for itself.

Advertise with us

Ms. Kail-Smith also has the budget director and the solicitor review the administration’s proposals before she places them on council’s agenda, a break from traditional practice, in which council deferred completely to the Mayor’s agenda. While these experts can check ordinances and resolutions for basic legitimacy, they don’t have the resources or authority to go deeper.

This is why the loss of an outside authority to hold city government accountable — a vibrant, curious and free press — threatens the ability of that government to function.

The Fourth Estate

This may come as a shock to some readers, but when it comes to local media, Pittsburgh is lucky: There are more eyes on local government here than in most other similar cities.

But it wasn’t long ago that several journalists loitered around the City-County Building every day — picking up gossip, anticipating legislation, looking into spending. That is no longer possible, fundamentally because news consumers don’t value it enough to pay for it.

Advertise with us

The media ensured the equilibrium of the political ecosystem, providing a means of verification that made a trusting and equal relationship between the branches of government possible. “

What Mr. Gainey and his team have realized, either strategically or intuitively, is that when media has atrophied (or is deferential and incurious), the balance of power tilts considerably in their favor. The Mayor holds the keys to all the capital improvements councilors’ constituents want, not to mention having his own political clout. Unless council is absolutely sure he’s up to no good, there’s very little incentive to challenge him.

This is why the Post-Gazette Editorial Page is particularly committed to reporting and commentary about City Hall. A strong-mayor system without a strong press is an unprecedented experiment in government, and we aim to restore the equilibrium.

Holding the mayor accountable

This dynamic will make the next few months one of the most important periods in Pittsburgh city government in recent memory. The city will have its first new controller, Rachael Heisler, in 16 years, and likely a new Council President, as Theresa Kail-Smith is rumored to be vacating the post.

Advertise with us

It is essential that whoever leads the council sees clearly that his or her task will be to extend Ms. Kail-Smith’s work to hold the executive accountable — and perhaps to entirely reimagine the relationship between the wings of the City-County Building’s Fifth floor.

One suggestion to save money and trouble in the long run: Increase staffing for both City Council and the Controller’s Office.

If the Mayor can have seven “communications professionals” to do nothing in particular, City Council can get more legislative professionals to vet the executive’s proposals and fulfill the chamber’s fiduciary responsibilities. And the controller can get more auditors and specialists to do more frequent and in-depth reports on city government.

Kaa’s spell is only broken when a more powerful force — the tiger Shere Khan — interrupts it. If city government can’t provide this force itself, an outside agency may have to do so.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.