Tuesday’s election results should end the local progressive movement’s dominance of Pittsburgh-area politics. While the Democratic Party did well, following trends in Virginia and elsewhere, at the state and municipal level — highlighted locally by flipping the North Allegheny School Board — voters delivered a stunning rebuke to its top-of-the-ticket county candidates.

Even though Sara Innamorato’s layup may have circled the rim several times, it did eventually drop. On the scoreboard, that’s all that matters — but the near-disaster accentuated, or at least it should have, that the once dominant team isn’t dominant anymore.

Elected Democrats and other leaders who value governance over performance should be emboldened by Tuesday’s results. The Hallam-Gainey-Lee faction took the party to the very edge of the abyss. For the sake of the party, as well as for the sake of good governance, it’s time to act on the reality so many say privately that they see clearly: government by progressives isn’t working.

The election results should give these leaders all the leverage they need to cajole Ms. Innamorato’s administration toward the center. In just four years, they’ll face the same electorate once again.

Advertise with us

By the numbers

One-quarter of Democratic voters indicated they’d rather Allegheny County be run by a Republican newcomer than their own nominee. If it had been one-quarter-plus-2%, Joe Rockey would be the next county executive.

That 2% can be accounted for by just one issue: Ms. Innamorato’s campaign convinced just enough Democrats who otherwise preferred Mr. Rockey that he might threaten abortion rights. If the race had been contested on the basis of issues over which the county executive has actual authority — a fantastical scenario, I know — Ms. Innamorato would have lost a county that Democratic Supreme Court contender Dan McCaffery won by 25%.

While the red-blue map may look like the revenge of the suburbs, the underlying numbers tell a more complicated story: While Ms. Innamorato underperformed Joe Biden in nearly every precinct, she did so particularly in white-collar areas, both in and out of the city. In Squirrel Hill and Highland Park, for instance, the Democratic margin dropped by 30 to 40 points since 2020 — and 20 to 30 points since U.S. Rep. Summer Lee’s 2022 victory.

In the suburbs, Mr. Rockey flipped several precincts and an entire ward in deep-blue Mt. Lebanon, increasingly a southern colony of the East End. Upper St. Clair and Fox Chapel had gone blue in the age of Trump; they returned to pre-Trump form on Tuesday. She lost many smaller, less affluent majority Democratic boroughs, like Leetsdale, where the Democratic votes were down almost 11%.

Advertise with us

Progressives may want to say that of course the capitalist class opposes them, but that would be self-justifying nonsense: In the vast majority of precincts they shared, Ms. Innamorato did worse, often much worse, than the more radical Ms. Lee. The progressive brand is losing its luster, and fast.

The Innamorato pincer

The question is whether more mainstream Democrats and other civic leaders will respond to this reality, or continue to peer over their left shoulders with fear and trembling.

A goodly number of the officials at Mr. Smalls for Ms. Innamorato’s election night celebration would have been satisfied, and some downright thrilled, if the party had become a wake. And after the mail-in ballots and the first couple tranches of day-of results, that looked possible, if not likely. But fake disappointment had to give way to fake jubilation.

And then there was the dignitary who wasn’t there at all: Summer Lee, rumored to be punishing her old comrade for abandoning the Palestinian cause.

Advertise with us

Ms. Innamorato must know, as she should have known all along, that she’s in a pincer: The city’s old-line political establishment and much of her own party’s would have been more than happy with a Rockey administration. And the compromises she made to appease just enough voters have alienated her progressive base — and her ascension to the executive’s office sets up a contentious relationship with the progressive-led County Council.

This is an opportunity for the mainstream to reassert itself. This election showed that Ms. Innamorato needs them, both to govern and to win. And dependence always comes with a cost, if the party with the power has the will to exact it.

Leverage

Over the past several years, a combination of schoolyard bullying and electoral success has moved not just Democratic politicians but parts of the business and foundation communities to embrace, or at least to appease, the left. The electoral success is fading. It’s up to these leaders, elected and otherwise, if the bullying will still work.

Ms. Innamorato’s transition team contains a predictable mix of establishment and progressive people and institutions, from BNY Mellon and the Pittsburgh Foundation to the left-wing political organizations PA United and SEIU Healthcare. It’s abundantly clear which side asserted control of the Gainey transition and administration. The more mainstream forces in the Innamorato inner circle have a duty to demand responsibility and moderation from the executive-elect — and they have the leverage to back it up.

Advertise with us

Insiders have said throughout the campaign that Ms. Innamorato recognizes the errors of Ed Gainey — how could she not? — and desires to avoid them. But threats from the left — to withdraw financial support, to mobilize for a primary opponent, to spread damaging information (whether true or false) — can overwhelm that desire.

The only solution is for the other side to indicate that it won’t play ball with a bully.

If it’s clear Ms. Innamorato is handing over the county to special interests like the SEIU, the establishment needs to sound the alarm and withdraw its own support. There is no longer any reason, if there ever was, to prop up a movement that has shown its inability to govern and its penchant for self-dealing. It may look and feel like helping the city, but it’s actually a dereliction of duty.

But it shouldn’t come to that, because the forces of moderation and pragmatism have the leverage to stop it from happening. If they use it.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.