In the first season of Mad Men, Don Draper declares that advertising is the business of selling happiness, and that happiness is “a billboard on the side of the road that screams with reassurance that whatever you’re doing is okay. You are okay.”

This was the task of Joe Rockey’s campaign for Allegheny County Executive: to reassure voters in this two-to-one blue county that it was okay to have misgivings about the Democratic candidate; that it was okay consider voting for the Republican; and that they would be okay if they actually did it.

In this, Mr. Rockey has succeeded beyond what most insiders and prognosticators expected, or even thought possible. While there have been almost no public polls of the race, private polls have shown the candidates converging. Some think the lines have crossed, or will cross before Tuesday. Others have pointed out that even if they do, early mail-in votes, cast during an earlier stage of the race, might save the Democrat from a mortifying defeat.

Whatever happens on Tuesday, it will be the best result any Republican could reasonably hope for countywide. If Joe Rockey can’t crest 50% in this race, it will remove the last iota of doubt that the county has converged with the city, where the Democratic primary is the only race that matters.

Advertise with us

Because not only has Mr. Rockey run a textbook campaign, his opponent has run a disastrous one.

Invisible candidate

Last Saturday, taxiing children and running errands, I passed through Brookline, Castle Shannon, Whitehall, Dormont, Green Tree, Carnegie, Collier and Robinson. I saw three yard signs for Democratic county executive candidate Sara Innamorato. I saw dozens for Joe Rockey.

Yard signs don’t vote — if they did, county treasurer John Weinstein would have won the Democratic primary by about 50 points — but they do indicate the organizational vigor of a campaign. Both my observations and my conversations with local politicos indicate that her campaign is pinching pennies.

The sheer number of signs doesn’t really matter, but it’s psychologically important to see that at least some of your neighbors support a candidate you have misgivings about. This is particularly important when many voters have serious misgivings about both candidates: Mr. Rockey for being a Republican, and Ms. Innamorato for her inexperience and stridently progressive profile.

Advertise with us

In this context, Ms. Innamorato’s decision to abandon the visual landscape to Mr. Rockey is confounding. No amount of television or digital advertising — where Mr. Rockey is also outpacing Ms. Innamorato — can make up for the impression that one’s neighbors are ashamed to signal support for the Democrat, but enthusiastic to signal support for the Republican.

It undermines Ms. Innamorato’s case that she’s safe and he’s nuts, and supports Mr. Rockey’s case that he’s safe and she’s nuts.

This is particularly important when establishing inevitability was, and still is, at the heart of Ms. Innamorato’s strategy, and establishing viability is — or, rather, was — Mr. Rockey’s biggest challenge.

Ferrari vs. Pinto

The visibility gap is representative of the overall stagnancy of the Innamorato campaign, which, whether due to complacency or mismanagement, never hit its stride after the May primary.

Advertise with us

By mid-October, Ms. Innamorato had performed poorly in multiple televised debates. Mr. Rockey’s funding advantage, and therefore airtime advantage, had only grown as his supporters became emboldened. And Hamas had attacked Israel, followed by a left-wing response that introduced many voters to the less savory elements of the progressive movement.

And yet, despite how the stars have aligned like a nighttime runway for Joe Rockey, he’s still a toss-up — at best.

Besides the intrinsic registration advantage, Ms. Innamorato is suspected to have a strong ground game, just as previous progressives have. But even here, there are signs of distress. If there are armies of Innamorato supporters fanning out across the county, why was her campaign completely absent from one of the biggest public events preceding the election, the Mt. Lebanon Halloween Parade? Joe Rockey marched, alongside a team of supporters.

Altogether, it’s the best case scenario for the Republican, better than Mr. Rockey had any right to hope for. As the finish line approaches, it looks like a Ferrari racing a Pinto. The question is whether the Pinto simply had too much of a head start.

Last chance

Advertise with us

Ultimately, this race is a choice not so much between two candidates as between two forms of governance: one-party and two-party. If this Republican running this campaign can’t defeat this Democrat running this campaign, it’s hard to imagine the GOP even bothering in the future.

And there’s good reason to believe maintaining the electoral legitimacy of the minority party is essential for the region’s overall political health. It’s the only way to ensure public leadership is responsive to the entire electorate, and not just to the (often opaque and dysfunctional) internal dynamics of a single party. Every ruling establishment needs a credible, critical voice to make it actually govern instead of coasting along.

Consider the current state of city politics, where every elected official must perform for the 20 to 25% most passionate Democratic primary voters, resulting in constant jockeying to court, or sometimes paralyzing fear of, the party’s activist base. The result: performative leadership that feels little political pressure to deliver practical results for the majority of Pittsburghers. And doesn’t.

Misgivings about the Republican, given the appalling state of the national party, are more than understandable. But so should be misgivings about submitting to the unchallenged rule of a local Democratic Party that hasn’t shown the gumption to discipline its own destructive radicals. A vote for Ms. Innamorato is, in all likelihood, a vote to banish Allegheny County Republicans into the outer darkness — certainly an appealing notion for some, but not one without costs.

What Joe Rockey needed to show, and has shown, is that Allegheny County isn’t just okay, but better off when there’s a legitimate Republican Party on the scene.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.