The party has fallen into chaos. Elected officials publicly torpedo members of their own party. Legislators jockey to show their fealty to ideological purity, and the most powerful members see any association with the party’s establishment as a sign of corruption. People once on the fringe are now in the center, and ideas once considered extreme are now accepted.

The approval of fringe media figures matters more than party endorsements. And the party establishment, or whatever’s left of it, simply watches, helpless to resist being co-opted — or destroyed.

I’m writing, of course, about the Democratic Party in Pittsburgh.

Breaking ranks

Advertise with us

In the Republican congressional conference, which just took three weeks and four candidates to select a Speaker of the House, the disease is far more advanced. But in the local Democratic Party, we can see the earlier stages of the same pathology — beginning with pusillanimity in dealing with ambitious fringe forces, and those who enable them.

While strong party structures have their downsides, they generally have the virtue of disciplining ideologues and reining in (or keeping out) potential extremists. For this reason, however, the new wave of local progressives sees the institutional Democratic Party as an intrinsically corrupting force that saps the energy from popular movements that, they believe, alone have the answer to our problems — just the way MAGA conservatives see the national GOP.

Neither establishment effectively kept out these incursions, and now both are terrified of the once-fringe elements who are leveraging the parties’ respectability to bring themselves into the mainstream. They’re so terrified, in fact, that the fundamental rules of party discipline are breaking down, and it’s even worth wondering what purpose the party structures serve any longer.

Take two Allegheny County Council races, where Democratic officials are taking sides against their own party’s labor-endorsed nominees in favor of independent socialists — without any rebuke from the party itself.

In the 10th district, which stretches from the Hill District through the East End to Forest Hills, two-term councilor and 25-year United Steelworkers employee DeWitt Walton is being challenged by community organizer Carl Redwood. And in the 13th district, which goes from Bellevue to Bon Air by way of Downtown, Democratic nominee (and Allegheny-Fayette Central Labor Council endorsee) David Bonaroti is being challenged by veteran and personal trainer Sam Schmidt.

Advertise with us

In both cases, the independent socialist insurgents are running far more energetic campaigns than their Democratic opponents, and the races are considered competitive. But most remarkable of all, Democratic officials — specifically county councilors Bethany Hallam and Anita Prizio and city councilors Barb Warwick and Deb Gross — have endorsed against their own party’s, and trade unions’, candidates.

It’s reminiscent of national Republicans openly supporting right-wing primary challenges against their own colleagues — all the way down to the party establishment’s impotence, or cowardice, to do anything about it. And to the extremism of the candidates being enabled.

Approving of terrorism

I don’t particularly care, nor should voters particularly care, what candidates for local office think about foreign affairs. I’m much more interested in what my city and county councilors think about parks funding than where they stand on the dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

But there are cases where a local politician’s overseas views should give voters pause — not because they have power over foreign policy, but because those views tell us something about the person’s relationship with right and wrong.

Advertise with us

For instance, on Oct. 7, as Hamas terrorists raped and massacred their way across southern Israel, at-large county councilor Bethany Hallam retweeted a post approving of the incursion. Three weeks later, after the full scope of the atrocity has become clear, Ms. Hallam has neither deleted it nor apologized for sharing it.

Where Ms. Hallam stands on the conflict in the Levant isn’t my concern; that she approves of violence against innocents as a political tactic very much is, and should be for all the people of the county she represents.

The same goes for the independent county council candidates Ms. Schmidt and Mr. Redwood, who continue to stand with an organization that believes the only just solution in the Holy Land is the end of Israel.

Enabling extremism

In the days after the Hamas attacks, the Pittsburgh chapter of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) released an infamous statement including the slogan “from the river to the sea,” which refers to Palestinians’ supposed right to all the land between the Jordan and the Mediterranean. Of course, the only means to vindicate such a right is the uprooting of the Israeli state, and likely the removal of most or all of its Jewish residents.

Advertise with us

While county executive candidate Sara Innamorato condemned the statement and repudiated her previous association with the DSA, Mr. Redwood and Ms. Schmidt have doubled down. In fact, on Tuesday, Ms. Schmidt wrote that she is a “proud member of the DSA, an organization that exemplifies moral integrity.”

County councilors may not have a vote on Israel policy, but it says something frightening about a person’s character if she believes annihilating Israel, or any nation, “exemplifies moral integrity.”

Two days after Ms. Schmidt praised the organization that wants Israel eliminated, and one day before the fifth anniversary of the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting, city councilor Deb Gross reaffirmed her endorsement.

If no one in party leadership is willing to stand against this, what is the point of the party at all?

Avoiding trouble

Advertise with us

Not long ago, party leaders would have rebuked, if not excommunicated, a Democrat endorsing against her own party, much less associating the party with such malignant views. Now — nothing. Nothing matters, except avoiding trouble with the progressives.

Just like national Republicans appeased and appeased and appeased their own bullying right flank, until suddenly the right flank became the central column.

And just like the Republicans in Washington, the Democratic leadership of Pittsburgh will only have itself to blame when those who were once called extremists become the new establishment.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.