Everybody in Pittsburgh has an opinion about the state of the Golden Triangle (including many who haven’t set foot Downtown for many years). Here are ten theses about Downtown based on my experience and conversations with others, including local experts and stakeholders.
It’s not only Pittsburgh.
Downtowns across the country are reeling since the COVID pandemic permanently changed working habits. A study by the University of Toronto that measured the number of mobile devices present in North American downtowns put Pittsburgh’s spring 2023 recovery — 61% of pre-pandemic activity — around the middle of the pack. Some typical comparable cities, such as Cincinnati, St. Louis and Louisville, are faring worse.
However, the Golden Triangle is one of the densest job centers in America, which means the health of Pittsburgh’s downtown is more important to the city, and the region, than other urban centers’.
The problem began before Ed Gainey.
Allegheny County homeless counts generally declined over the course of the 2010s until spiking in 2020 and plateauing in 2023. County data also show overdoses in the 15222 ZIP code, which includes most of Downtown and the Strip District, peaking in 2020 and 2021 and dropping the last two years. (Unfortunately, and unsurprisingly, neighborhood-level data from the city stopped being publicly reported in mid-2022.)
Numbers don’t capture the full picture — many homeless people go uncounted and many overdoses go unreported — but there’s no question Mr. Gainey inherited a challenging situation.
Perception forms reality.
If people think Downtown is dangerous, they won’t go. If fewer people go Downtown to work and shop and eat and enjoy themselves, then businesses will struggle and a higher — and therefore more visible — proportion of people Downtown will have bad intentions, or no intentions. This will validate the perception that Downtown is unpleasant, and fewer people will visit, and so on.
This also means visible public safety measures can make a difference, even if they don’t actually have much tangible impact.
Ed Gainey’s response has been more law enforcement-focused than Bill Peduto’s would have been.
Mr. Peduto’s administration had spearheaded multiple programs for non-law enforcement interventions for people suffering from addiction, mental-health struggles and homelessness. Those have largely become moribund under Mr. Gainey — including a lapsed $10 million collaboration with Allegheny Health Network that is the subject of some fuzzy accounting, at best.
Faced with the necessity to do something — anything — Mr. Gainey has reached for the simplest and bluntest tool at hand: cops making arrests.
Downtown is not uniform.
Pittsburgh is a city of neighborhoods, and Downtown is a neighborhood of sectors. Market Square is nearly as vibrant at lunch- and dinnertime as it was before the pandemic, and the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership’s data bear that out. The Wood and Smithfield corridors, especially near Sixth, have more disturbances. Grant and Ross Streets are pretty normal. The riverfronts are hit or miss.
Depending on which spots you pick, you can have widely varying experiences Downtown.
Weekend evenings are better than weekday mornings.
This is a point Mr. Gainey made in a (rather odd) interview with KDKA Radio’s Marty Griffin this week: People are coming Downtown for dinner and drinks and shows on the weekends; they are not coming Downtown, at least as much as they did, to work during the week. Bringing workers back to the office is one of the most important things the city can encourage, but it has few means to do so.
One of them is, in a very public way, to take commuting office workers’ concerns about Downtown safety seriously.
Private organizations are filling the void left by public authorities.
While the increased police presence has been appreciated by regular Downtowners, there is still a widely shared sense that the city has lacked a coordinated response to the neighborhood’s issues. Into the breach has stepped the PDP, which has not just advocated but spent hard money on staff to help visitors feel comfortable and cared for. Point Park University has also played an important role by bringing thousands of young people into the Golden Triangle.
Meanwhile, if corporate leaders think the city isn’t making their employees feel safe, they’re going to take matters into their own hands. Look for private police forces to sprout Downtown.
Point State Park is an oasis.
You will not see tents or other signs of homeless settlements in the park for a simple reason: The state won’t allow it. Nobody, as far as I know, thinks this is unjust or uncompassionate. That’s because it’s common sense that if a public place is to be enjoyed by the public, authorities can’t allow it to be captured by people who turn it into their own private settlement.
It’s a lesson that should be applied elsewhere in the Golden Triangle.
Hub-and-spoke transit concentrates troubles Downtown.
Almost all transit routes in Pittsburgh emanate from Downtown, a legacy of the city’s geography and the job density of the Golden Triangle. If a person’s only means of getting around is transit, he will almost certainly have to come Downtown to get where he’s going. That makes the neighborhood a natural clearinghouse for everything from drug deals to sleeping quarters — especially when it’s less populated by the usual crowds.
That’s also why the triangle formed by Smithfield, Sixth and Liberty, with multiple transit hubs and the now-closed Smithfield shelter, is probably the most challenging sector of Downtown.
The new Downtown will be very different.
There’s no going back to the days of Kaufmann’s and Gimbels, or even to the late 2010s, when there was talk of more new office buildings Downtown. Urban neighborhoods that have recovered and thrived since the pandemic have been those with a diverse mix of land uses, walkable amenities and price points. That means more places for people to live — and not just “luxury lofts” — so there are more Pittsburghers anchored in the Golden Triangle.
But it’s not going to happen by magic. It’s going to take hard decisions, strong communication and collaborative leadership from the Mayor’s office to unify public and private stakeholders behind a creative vision. But right now it’s unclear whether Ed Gainey has the skills, or even the interest, to see this through.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.