Last year, I spent a day on the trail with state Sen. Doug Mastriano’s campaign for governor. I made no promises to get that privilege except my goodwill, and the campaign explicitly did not ask for a puff piece. Even so, promises of further access dried up after I published my first column based on my experience, which was — as agreed! — not a puff piece.

The unprecedented media strategy of the Mastriano campaign held that the risks of engaging with the “mainstream media” in any way outweighed the benefits — and after a one-day exception, that included me. They set out to demonstrate that a candidate could succeed by interacting only with compliant media, in this case right-wing outlets like OAN and Newsmax, while completely ignoring the outlets with the broadest reach.

Needless to say, it didn’t work, and Josh Shapiro delivered a 15-point thumping.

A year later, the administration of Mayor Ed Gainey is attempting a similar move: completely ignoring, also on spurious ideological grounds, by far the largest media outlet in the city — this newspaper — while strictly controlling access to information by other outlets. This is a more brazen strategy than the Mastriano campaign’s, however, because Mr. Gainey isn’t a candidate. He’s a public official.

Advertise with us

Curiously, however, this cynical move has failed to generate the kind of criticism Mr. Mastriano endured for dodging accountability in this way. It would set a terrible precedent, which other elected officials here and elsewhere would copy, if this were to become the accepted norm in Pittsburgh.

Selective solidarity

Let’s get this out of the way: No one really believes Mr. Gainey and his associates are spurning the Post-Gazette as a matter of “solidarity” with unions during the newspaper’s labor dispute. And those who pretend to believe this are embarrassing themselves.

One tell, of course, is that other media outlets in town with complicated relationships with organized labor — the other daily has never allowed a union to get a toenail through the newsroom door, and the NPR affiliate has a publicly contentious relationship with its own nascent union — aren’t getting the same treatment. It seems the administration’s “solidarity” only extends to North Shore Drive.

And the other tell is that Mr. Gainey doubles down on this transparently fake “solidarity” when the Post-Gazette has the temerity to do its job by holding his administration accountable. When the Editorial Board published evidence of unethical and possibly illegal conduct by his officials regarding a controversial study of Pittsburgh police, the Mayor responded the next day with an absurd thread of tweets renewing his “solidarity” by refusing to respond to “any story the paper publishes.”

Advertise with us

In any other context this would be recognized for what it is: a public official scandalously attempting to dodge accountability for misconduct by undermining the non-compliant press. It’s exactly the kind of conduct liberal activists and mainstream journalists fretted about in the unlikely event of a Mastriano gubernatorial administration.

And yet in a toadyish display that would make Kremlin sycophants blush, “progressive” local Twitter accounts rose in applause.

Democracy dies in darkness

This all would be less ominous, if still deeply problematic, if the Gainey administration had a normal — that is to say: transparent, respectful, adversarial — relationship with other Pittsburgh media outlets. But they’re hardly being treated any better.

A small example: The Mayor’s office does not release Mr. Gainey’s daily schedule, so no one knows what he’s actually up to. This is extraordinary, and should arouse suspicions about the competence and trustworthiness of his (burgeoning) communications staff.

Advertise with us

Another, more serious example: The administration avoids, to the very limit (and I suspect beyond the limit) the law allows, requests for public records under the state’s Right-to-Know Act. As a matter of course, the city now asserts its right to take 30 days, as opposed to five, to respond to RTK requests due to a “bona fide staffing limitation.”

But the administration has added several public relations staffers under the Mayor’s direct control. If the city has the resources to expand Mr. Gainey’s personal collection of flacks — whose job seems to be mostly to say “no” — surely it has the resources to comply with state law to provide public records in a timely fashion. Five days, say.

The odd thing is that it’s clearly considered uncouth for members of the press to observe these facts (at least in public), even though they go to the heart of Mr. Gainey’s public and, dare I say, democratic responsibilities. It’s not for me to speculate why they don’t, but whatever the reasons, it’s a dangerous game to play: If he is allowed to get away with it, others will try.

Mayor Mastriano

My negotiations with the Mastriano campaign included potentially conducting a formal interview, which would have been a huge exclusive. But I’ll never forget when I received the campaign’s redactions from my list of proposed questions: It was clear they would accept nothing remotely challenging, even strictly about policy.

Advertise with us

I wasn’t really offended by this: It was the campaign he wanted to run, and it was up to the people of Pennsylvania whether they would reward it. They didn’t.

Ed Gainey is not a candidate. He is the mayor. His stonewalling of his city’s press is not a campaign strategy. It is a public policy. And it is corroding the political and media culture of this city.

In December 2021, I conducted the first interview with Mr. Gainey to be released after his inauguration. The transition team did not screen my questions, and the interview was a pleasure to perform.

Since then, however, the curtains have slowly been drawn shut, with peeks behind granted as a privilege rather than offered as a public duty. And ignoring that fact does no one — not the people of Pittsburgh, not its media and not Mr. Gainey himself — any favors.

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.