On June 28, Pittsburgh’s Chief Operating and Administrative Officer Lisa Frank argued to City Council that a $300,000 appropriation to a Homewood sports organization was needed to teach young athletes how to take care of fancy grass, so that they might one day care for a FIFA pitch in Brazil. Councilmembers unanimously approved the grant without debate.
It’s a representative episode in a relationship between the city’s legislative and executive branches that began as respectful deference to the new mayor, but has degraded into absurd and humiliating subservience. At least five of the city’s nine councilors must learn how to say ‘no’ to Mayor Ed Gainey and his officials, because right now Pittsburgh doesn’t just have a one-party political system; it has a one-branch political system. And that branch is being run with appalling incompetence.
Fear and loathing
It doesn’t take a Ph.D. in political science to understand why most city councilors don’t want to pull the reins on Mr. Gainey: They’re terrified of the consequences. To rebuke a progressive mayor — the fact that he has governed to the right of his predecessor is irrelevant to the political team he is perceived to be on — is to risk a progressive primary challenge, and the left has won nearly every Democratic race it has contested here in the past few years.
The result is the age-old politician’s quandary: Make a stand that puts reputation and reelection, and therefore the power to do good within the system, in jeopardy? Or remain compliant in order to ride out the current storm, while in the meantime quietly trying to hold back the deluge?
For the first year of Mr. Gainey’s tenure, the latter was a viable, even commendable option. As a new executive, he deserved time to learn the ropes — and City Council’s tradition of deference to the people’s choice for mayor mandated that his initial priorities be ratified. Early concerns, such as the prominence of SEIU political staffers in the Mayor’s inner circle, could have evaporated if those staffers matured into their roles as public officials rather than private activists.
As everybody — and I mean that literally — on Grant Street knows by now, that has not happened. A culture of backbiting and deception and unchecked caprice has settled into City Hall, marked especially by a phobia of all public and media inquiry (and not just this newspaper’s). The situation has curdled to a degree that has shocked even long-time city government hands, and left them grasping for comparisons. Usually they have to reach across time and oceans: “Soviet” is a popular adjective.
Whipping five votes
Pittsburgh’s nine city councilors are not ignorant of the disaster down the hall, and yet Mr. Gainey’s representatives are treated like emissaries to the colonies from the imperial metropole. Ms. Frank should have been showered with scorn for suggesting that a neighborhood athletic association was going to use $300,000 to prepare youth football players for careers in golf course agronomy. Instead, there was casual banter and a voice vote in the affirmative.
This week’s revelations about possible impropriety regarding the city’s police staffing study, however, may prove to be a turning point. In a statement, council has now vowed to investigate the executive branch’s conduct, “including the procurement process and ... the staffing study itself.”
In another step in the right direction, Council President Theresa Kail-Smith has been receiving, and vetting, Mr. Gainey’s agenda items at the end of the week before they are introduced in council. This is unusual in the city’s deferential political culture, and introduces a measure of control over what is presented for council to vote on.
This is important, because once an item gets to the chamber, it is all but impossible to stop it. Most votes are unanimous not because every member agrees with every Gainey proposal, but because it makes little sense to dissent if there aren’t at least five dissenters. Why attract negative attention from Mr. Gainey’s office or social media while also failing to stop the legislation?
This is especially true for issues made for campaign soundbites. No one wants to be against affordable housing, or enforcing the equal protection of the laws, or funding for Homewood sports, even if the proposed means are financially dubious.
But every time council gets out its rubber stamp, the culture of impunity in the Mayor’s office only deepens.
Conflict council
Take the $300,000 Homewood Community Sports appropriation. It’s possible it will do a lot of good for the kids and families of the neighborhood, but the stated reason for the grant (and for waiving the competitive bid process) — instilling a professional interest in what Ms. Frank called “high performance natural turf” — is brazenly dishonest.
For its part, HCS has never handled even $50,000 in a year, as evidenced by the fact it’s never submitted a Form 990 in its eight years as a 501(c)(3) organization. It also has no publicly disclosed board to oversee the use of such a windfall of taxpayer dollars. Nobody — including council and the oddly passive City Controller’s Office — can have any idea what this money will actually be used for.
City Council’s compliance with Mr. Gainey is no longer nobly upholding the tradition of mayoral prerogative; it’s passively enabling a return to the traditions of graft and self-dealing that for too long defined urban governance.
And I’m sure at least five members of that council agree. Now they need to act on that conviction.
Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.