A two-term at-large county councilor who helped to midwife the county government we know today, including consolidating outdated row offices. A trial lawyer who took the most powerful man in West Virginia to the Supreme Court — and won. A reformer who knows the criminal justice system, and its flaws, from the inside, having freed innocent men and achieved better conditions for pregnant inmates at the Allegheny County Jail. A visionary whose idea for a countywide riverfront park was ahead of its time, and could still transform the region.

That’s Dave Fawcett’s pitch to become the next Allegheny County Executive. And it’s far from the weakest on a slate of candidates for the Democratic nomination that has drawn a good deal of sighs and whimpers from the electorate.

The fly in the ointment, politicos will tell you, is that Mr. Fawcett served on county council from 1999 to 2007 with an “R” next to his name, though he changed parties a decade ago now. If he threatened to join the apparent top tier of contenders — State Rep. Sara Innamorato, City Controller Michael Lamb and County Treasurer John Weinstein — the ads branding him an elephant in donkey’s clothing would cascade onto the airwaves.

But based on experience and competence, not to mention practical-progressive bona fides, Mr. Fawcett should be among the frontrunners for the biggest public job between Harrisburg and Columbus. Why isn’t he?

Advertise with us

Wag the dog

Because we have a political system defined by partisan loyalties and controlled by a tiny proportion of primary voters. An absurdly small number of voters will pick Rich Fitzgerald’s successor. A dozen years ago, Mr. Fitzgerald scored about 66,000 votes in his primary against the late Mark Patrick Flaherty, or 55% of Democratic primary voters. But that was only about 7.5% of registered voters in the county.

The winner’s vote share in this year’s more crowded field will almost certainly be smaller, and the result more decisive. Even if we assume a historically high off-year primary turnout of 30%, with no candidate likely to crest 40% of the vote, the next county executive will likely be elected by, at most, 12% of registered Democrats. That’s about 60,000 people in a county of 1.25 million.

That means there’s no incentive to build a broad countywide coalition. Ms. Innamorato can rely on a surge of progressive momentum without thinking twice about the supermajority of voters who don’t care for that kind of politics. Mr. Weinstein can rely on the creaky gears of the old Democratic labor-patronage machine, even if it’s less relevant than ever. And Mr. Lamb can rely on residual affection for Mr. Fitzgerald to try to pull him over the finish line.

Jokers to the right

Advertise with us

The historic weakness of Allegheny County Republicans — despite the efforts of county GOP chairman Sam DeMarco, without whom the situation would certainly be worse — exacerbates the problem. Back in 2011, Mr. Fitzgerald represented the left wing of the local Democrats, but had to campaign with the general election in mind. The primary did not obviously decide the race. A poll taken a month before the November election showed the Democrat up 10, but with only 41% support.

While he eventually shellacked Republican D. Raja by 24 points, that result was not guaranteed, or even foreseen by many political observers. After all, Mr. Fitzgerald had served on a county council that, at one point, only favored Democrats 8 to 7. Now there’s a chance it could be 13 to 2 or even 14 to 1, with the at-large carve-out the only redoubt of opposition.

The reason for this shift isn’t so much party registration — in fact, this year in Allegheny County 50% more Democrats have become Republicans than vice versa — as it is Democratic success in the suburbs, which has obliterated the GOP’s traditional geographic advantages. This doesn’t matter as much in countywide elections, but Republican county executive candidate Joe Rockey, whatever his virtues, must feel more like a sacrificial lamb than Mr. Raja did 12 years ago.

Even some Democratic pols lament the loss of a moderating influence on their right flank. It’s bad for democracy when candidates and elected officials don’t have to worry about 30% to 40% of the people they’re supposed to serve. It incentivizes leaders to focus on niche constituencies and causes rather than develop broadly popular and practical public policy.

And that will eventually hurt the ruling party itself. Niche governing has it limits. A majority will soon get tired of feeling unrepresented in government, and of being led by people who are better at politics than governing.

Advertise with us

Leaky Fawcett

Which brings us back to Mr. Fawcett, whose profile is more impressive than his polling. Ms. Innamorato talks about criminal justice reform, while Mr. Fawcett has actually gotten people out of jail. Mr. Weinstein talks about “going green” in the treasurer’s office, while Mr. Fawcett has actually cracked down on polluters. And Mr. Fawcett worked with Mr. Lamb on his signature issue of government reform, specifically the consolidation of vestigial county row offices.

This doesn’t mean Mr. Fawcett is the best candidate, but it does mean he should be in the top tier. The problem is he doesn’t have an obvious 60,000-vote niche — and that old red “R” is a scarlet letter for the passionate primary voters who value purity more than policy.

One reform this episode suggests is ranked-choice voting, in which voters select multiple candidates in order of their preference. The candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated, and his voters’ second-choice selections are distributed. This continues until someone reaches a majority.

Especially in a crowded primary, ranked-choice rewards appealing to a broad cross-section of the electorate. It makes it possible for such candidates to overcome those with a small but passionate base.

Advertise with us

The Dave Fawcett problem also points to a more grassroots solution: More people should vote in local elections. Turnout for these races should be as high as for presidential elections. The county executive, not to mention suburban mayors and township supervisors and borough councilors, affects everyday life far more directly than Joe Biden or John Fetterman. If people don’t want to be ruled by a tiny minority of primary voters, outvote them.

Whatever happens in this race — which remains dynamic with a little more than two weeks to go — the winner must govern with the entire county in mind, and not just his or her bespoke 5% of the electorate. The last thing the region needs is for the City of Pittsburgh’s current dysfunction to spread countywide.

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.