I would like to make a modest proposal: That we set aside the second day of the year as a bookend and counterpoint to the commercialism of modern Christmas by giving things away. So much new stuff — some of it needed and wanted, some of it very much neither — comes into our homes in late December. There’s no better time than now to take stock of what’s really necessary, to seek out organizations and people who can use what we don’t need, and to relieve ourselves of the burden of property that weighs us down more than it lifts us up.

Enough. At some point, we must be able to say: We have enough.

I’m haunted by the words of Basil of Caesarea, a fourth-century bishop and theologian. He wrote: “Now, someone who takes a man who is clothed and renders him naked would be termed a robber. But when someone fails to clothe the naked, while he is able to do this, is such a man deserving of any other appellation? The bread which you hold back belongs to the hungry; the coat, which you guard in your locked storage-chests, belongs to the naked; the footwear mouldering in your closet belongs to those without shoes; the silver that you keep hidden in a safe place belongs to the one in need.”

Along with other luminaries of the early Christian church such as Ambrose of Milan, Basil held that all excess property belongs by right to the poor. That means that when a person with an extra coat gives it to a person who has no coat, he is restoring to the poor man what is rightly his.

Advertise with us

It is a hard teaching. But in the wake of the annual excesses of the holiday season, it’s one that should make us think about how much more so many of us have than we need, and what we should do with it all. What do we owe the poor? (It’s fitting that the Catholic Church celebrates St. Basil on January 2.)

Today, the Catholic Church uses the jargon “universal destination of goods” to describe more or less the same teaching. This means that all the resources of the earth, including both raw materials and manufactured goods, are meant to be enjoyed by all. Only once every person has the basics to sustain a decent life can we begin to accumulate.

Does this sound utterly fanciful? Unnatural? Impossible? If it does, it’s only because we’ve organized human civilization is a way that makes it so.

In the 1986 film “The Mission,” the representative of the pope in colonial-era South America makes the terrible decision to turn over the Guaraní people, who had been protected by Jesuit missions, to Portuguese slavers. He hates himself for it, but he feels obligated by geopolitical forces to protect the church’s interests elsewhere by sacrificing the Indigenous people of the Amazon.

The Portuguese legate tries to assuage his conscience by telling him, “You had no alternative, Your Eminence. We must work in the world. The world is thus.” The cardinal shoots back, “No Señor Hontar, thus have we made the world.” Then, quietly and mournfully: “Thus have I made it.”

Advertise with us

Ever since I first encountered the teaching of St. Basil and other early Christians, I’ve been troubled by its implications. A society built on this teaching would be better and more just than our own. But is it possible?

In a world where both poverty and charity have become institutionalized, can any one person or family effectively live out Basil’s vision of justice? If we take the saint at his word, how do we know what counts as excess? Specifically, how do parents balance their obligation to the needy with their duty to provide for their family?

It’s easy to become paralyzed. If we can’t do it all, and do it just right, it can feel simpler to do nothing at all, to live as if we have no duties to the poor because the duties we do have are overwhelming.

Basil was also faced with a society that seemed to make his vision of justice impossible. He responded by constructing what has been called the world’s first hospital and social welfare agency, called the Basiliad. It soon became a small city unto itself — a place where the poor and the sick could find support, healing and dignity. It didn’t solve every social problem, but it moved his world in the right direction.

Individuals and families inspired by Basil rarely have the power and the resources to build their own cities of charity. But we can take smaller actions that are within reach to adjust our values and vantagepoint — and, crucially, those of the next generation as well.

Advertise with us

In our home, we ask every member of the family to take stock of their things on January 2. For the adults, that mostly means rifling through dressers and closets to make sure we actually need and use the clothes we have. For the kids, that means each picking out a few toys to give away, now that so many new ones have arrived.

The giveaways shouldn’t all be worn out — they should include some items that are in great shape and are still enjoyed. The needy deserve more than table scraps, and a sacrifice should smart a bit. By acclimating ourselves, and especially our children, to this feeling, we hope in the long run it will be more realistic to live out Basil’s moral vision even more robustly.

“We must work in the world. The world is thus.” That’s true enough. But it is also the calling of every person to take steps, big or small, to change the world for the better — so that future generations don’t have that excuse any longer.

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.