In 1948, a country burst into civil war. Someone assassinated the Liberal Party’s presidential candidate and after people rioted in response, the Conservative Party, who controlled the government, began to systematically punish anyone who took arms against the regime.

The Liberals fought back. Both sides escalated.

The civil war that followed, called “The Violence,” cost hundreds of thousands of Colombians their lives and accomplished little for either party. This was not a North fighting a South. This was a war of grievances based on political beliefs, not on geography.

It was a war of neighbor against neighbor.

Advertise with us

That grudge from long ago

The Liberals, who were right of center and part of the establishment, never mounted an organized, national resistance against Conservative violence, though some resisted through legal means. The Left tried but splintered into many small groups, from neighborhood defense organizations to paramilitary groups and guerrilla warfare.

The conflict lasted, officially, until 1958. But the violence in Colombia has never completely disappeared. Many of the guerrilla groups founded during The Violence still fight today.

Colombia suffered “affective polarization,” the gap between people’s commitment to their own political party and their animosity to the other. I’ve spent over a decade of my life working on a book about this conflict, centered on both Colombian history and my grandmother, trying to make sense of both.

Writing “The Violence: My Family’s Colombian War” showed me that that kind of polarization benefits the people at the very top of the political food chain and no one else. Everyone else suffers.

The U.S. is not currently in a civil war, thank goodness, but we are experiencing the greatest affective polarization since the 1860s. We have to worry that it could lead to “A Violence,” as it did in Colombia.

Advertise with us

The assassination of Jorge Eliécer Gaitán marked the official beginning of the conflict. For decades before, though, rhetorical violence had become normalized in Colombia.

As the Colombian newsmagazine El Espectador put it (translated by me), “various opposing factions resorted to aggressive rhetoric that cast their adversaries as enemies of society … in which the worst of evils converged.”

When the flashpoint finally came with the assassination, the violent rhetoric enabled violent actions. In casting their political enemies as their existential ones, Colombian politicians fomented the dehumanization of the other side.

And once the opposition became inhuman, it was a whole lot easier to pick up a weapon against people. To see the other side as an obstacle to progress, or as the embodiment of sin, raised the collective blood pressure and led to bloodshed.

It wasn’t until the coordinated efforts of a third party, the extremely leftist guerrillas, that Liberals and Conservatives found a way to soften their language toward one another. Having a common enemy helped. By changing the rhetoric, they were able to form something called the National Front in 1956, with both parties agreeing to alternate being in power until 1972.

Advertise with us

Don’t feel like giving in

And now, in 2026, as a student of violent conflict, I was not surprised when President Donald Trump started a war with Iran. When he was a private citizen, he once suggested that then-President Barack Obama would do something similar in response to low approval ratings.

War almost always unites people, and I can see how starting one, especially one that was supposed to be quick and easy and over in a couple weeks, felt like a good way to rally Americans together. And divert their attention from other issues, like the economy and the Epstein files.

Still, history doesn’t always predict the outcome. Trump did not count on so many in the center being so opposed. He also didn’t count on how unpopular the war with Iran would be with his own people, as so many voted for him because they believed his promise that he would keep America out of foreign wars.

But, most importantly, he never softened his tone, his rhetoric, toward his domestic political opposition. (And now against the pope.)

MAGA, as a movement, has made no outreach toward the center. There was no photo-op of Trump and Democratic leadership debating war plans. In fact, Trump and his followers have become more insular, choosing to only listen to those who are unquestionably loyal.

Advertise with us

And by continuing to speak so contemptuously of the other side, the president has made it impossible for people to come together — no matter how many wars he might start.

The cold drop

History can tell us when things aren’t going well. And these days, history is ever-present.

One wouldn’t be remiss to blink a few times after encountering an international geopolitical situation that includes an existential war in Persia, a world leader beefing with the Pope, the toppling of a Hungarian empire and U.S.-supported dictatorships emerging in Latin America. And children dying from diseases that once killed them but are now easily preventable.

It’s like the last thousand years have collapsed upon themselves. And it turns out, historically speaking, we’ve learned very little when it comes to maintaining the peace.

We should look at what happened in Colombia in 1948 — and other nations that suffered rhetoric-driven civil wars, like Chile and Argentina in the 1970s — to understand what happens when civil discourse collapses and the rhetoric of hatred takes over, when affective polarization becomes the norm, and people take to violence.

Advertise with us

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “The real Trump Derangement Syndrome.”

She will be appearing at 7 p.m. April 30 at Carnegie Library to discuss her new book “The Violence: My Family’s Colombian War” with Tony Norman. Free tickets are available through Pittsburgh Arts & Lectures.