There is a moment in the Apple-produced television show “Pluribus” where the hivemind that has taken over most of humanity gets excited that Carol, one of the few humans immune to the newly collective consciousness of humanity, is writing again.

The author of a highly successful romantasy series, Carol might be the last creative mind that is not a part of the cooperative. And unlike the one-thought-think-tank that is the rest of the world, Carol is capable of making something completely true to herself, something new.

The sci-fi series delves deeply into what it means to be one of the last humans in the world able to generate a free thought, and central to Carol’s determination to remain an individual is the beauty and ugliness of independent thinking.

Carol’s desire to get back to the keyboard delights the hivemind, even as they work to bring her into their fold. To them, a new novel by Carol means that new narrative ideas will be generated, giving them a story that hasn’t already been told. Turns out, one of the problems with collective thought is a lack of originality.

Advertise with us

When humanity is reduced to sharing one consciousness, trained on everything that has come before, it longs for something new, something thrilling, something utterly and perfectly human.

Look at this stuff

Vince Gilligan, creator of both “Pluribus” and the “Breaking Bad” universe, doesn’t blame you if you think that “Pluribus” is commentary on artificial intelligence. After all, the nature of AI is that it’s built and trained on previous work generated by millions of humans. It may as well be a hivemind.

But his work on the show began before the advent of AI agents like ChatGPT. “I wasn’t really thinking of AI,” he told Polygon, “because this was about eight or 10 years ago. Of course, the phrase ‘artificial intelligence’ certainly predated ChatGPT, but it wasn’t in the news like it is now.”

“I’m not saying you’re wrong,” he continued. “A lot of people are making that connection. I don’t want to tell people what this show is about. If it’s about AI for a particular viewer, or COVID-19 — it’s actually not about that, either — more power to anyone who sees some ripped-from-the-headlines type thing.”

So while the show may not be intentionally parodying our culture’s current obsession with the flat and cheery affect of AI chatbots with characters like Zosia, who speaks for the hivemind in a perpetually upbeat tone, it cannot help but comment on what happens in a world without creativity.

Advertise with us

And the truth of the matter is that we long for the only-human excitement of imagination. So does the hivemind. So will artificial intelligence. A system trained on predictive models based only on what has come before confronts its limitations when asked to envision something outside of what has already been.

Which is wild, when you consider how good my children are at inventing entirely new universes, creatures and stories as-yet untold. Turns out, even small, still-developing humans are better than AI at one thing: innovation.

Isn’t it neat?

The argument for artificial intelligence replacing most of our jobs is that most of our jobs are not creative. The TPS reports of the world, along with code and most spreadsheets, can belong to the robots, but our novels and inspirational texts should remain in the realm of artists.

But that’s not what’s happening. More and more novelists are admitting to using AI agents like ChatGPT and Claude to generate the writing, as are journalists. This weekend, an editor at Cleveland.com blasted a potential new hire for wanting to avoid using AI on the job.

“Because we want reporters gathering information, these jobs are 100 percent reporting,” wrote Chris Quinn, editor of the Plain Dealer. “We have an AI rewrite specialist who turns their material into drafts. We fact-check everything. Editors review it. Reporters get the final say. Humans — not AI — control every step.”

Advertise with us

He continued: “By removing writing from reporters’ workloads, we’ve effectively freed up an extra workday for them each week. They’re spending it on the street — doing in-person interviews, meeting sources for coffee. That’s where real stories emerge, and they’re returning with more ideas than we can handle.”

Telling a would-be journalist that writing is no longer a part of the job is mind-boggling and “soul-numbing,” to quote critic Stephen Whitty.

Writing is crucial. It is during the process of writing that thoughts are organized, that soul-lifting sentences are generated, that observations become art. A newspaper written by artificial intelligence, even if managed and controlled by humans, will lead to more cliché, less original thought, stupider observations, and that flattened-yet-inspired tone, with consummate lists of three, that have begun to dominate AI-generated text.

Where the people are

Writing is not just spitting out a formatted list of facts. Writing is an art, and even when it’s professional or technical in its nature, it benefits from having a human being at the helm. Ideas come to writers as they write.

If one simply plugs in data like interview notes and quotes, along with a prompt, one avoids the act of thinking through an idea, stress-testing it as they figure out how to assemble an original argument.

Advertise with us

Again, this might be fine in some fields. But journalism requires a human touch. Slow journalism is better than too-fast journalism, as critical distance and perspective help reporters put what they’ve seen in a larger context.

But a culture that cannot bother to write its own stories will give up too much in exchange for time saved. We’ll become a hive mind, hungry for anything new, having given it all up for the ease of never having to think again.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “The Washington Post is making a big mistake.”