On my pathway to becoming a U.S. citizen, I was asked several times during my naturalization interview if I was an agent of the Communist Party. This is a standard question, asked of all people who undergo the process of becoming permanent Americans.

I was a middle-schooler at the time, and I remember tremendous confusion at being asked such a thing in the first place. It was South Texas in the mid-1990s, and I was going through a simultaneous Ace of Base and Weezer phase. Who on Earth would think I was a Communist?

I remember answering honestly (“no”), perhaps with too much bemusement in my voice. My interviewer from Immigration and Naturalization Service (the former name for what is now U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services) chuckled after asking the question as if it were clear to her too — I was a standard American preteen. I was worried about my allowance, not about who controlled the means of production.

Still, being a member of the Communist Party is disqualifying for anyone seeking American citizenship, according to the Internal Security Act of 1950, which amended the Immigration Act of 1918, making sure grounds for exclusion existed “specific to members of communist or totalitarian parties, affiliates of such groups, or to aliens who advocate the doctrines of world communism or any other form of totalitarianism.”

Advertise with us

And as they say, “the law is the law.” My interviewer had to ask, and I had to answer.

Live those dreams

Snippets of Governor Josh Shapiro’s new memoir “Where We Keep the Light” have begun appearing in select outlets, including the New York Times, CNN and The Atlantic. In it appears a headline-grabbing anecdote, in which, back in 2024, a member of the Kamala Harris campaign asked Shapiro, “Have you ever been an agent of the Israeli government?”

Shapiro was immediately uncomfortable. As he writes it: “Had I been a double agent for Israel? Was she kidding? I told her how offensive the question was.”

Shapiro contends that being asked such a thing as a Jewish man is patently disrespectful, conflating his faith with his patriotism. And under normal circumstances, I would agree.

But in this case, I’m not sure. Shapiro did volunteer work in Israel and worked for the Israeli embassy, which is not that different from Tim Walz doing volunteer and teaching work in China. Walz, the one Harris picked as her running-mate against Trump in the 2024 election, was similarly grilled by the Harris campaign over these Chinese connections.

Advertise with us

Turns out, confirming that someone is not an agent of a foreign government is a standard question, asked because if it were true, it would disqualify anyone attempting to hold office.

The law is the law.

Your intention

That hasn’t stopped Deborah Lipstadt, the former antisemitism envoy under President Joe Biden, from calling the Harris campaign’s questions “classic antisemitism” on social media.

Abraham Foxman, formerly a leader of the Anti-Defamation League, called it “very disturbing” that Shapiro was asked about Israel, considering it a sign of “something very troubling about our current political culture.”

Neither Shapiro nor other Jewish political operatives are wrong that antisemitism, especially in political discourse, is on the rise and Shapiro has a right to be more sensitive than most. His family is still recovering from a religiously motivated arson attack and assault on their home last April during Passover. Anyone can easily forgive him for overreacting when there’s even a whiff of mistreatment on that front.

Advertise with us

But calling out the Harris campaign’s vetting question as antisemitic without first confirming if other candidates were subjected to the same scrutiny, risks damaging Shapiro’s future ambitions as well. He comes across as ignorant of standard questions and too focused on possible slights.

When asked by CNN for his updated thoughts on the parallel Walz vetting process, Shapiro’s spokesperson insisted “the chapter about 2024 politics is part of a much larger book about the governor’s faith,” choosing not to comment further.

It’s a strange move: writing about the Harris campaign in a way that would inevitably invite coverage but then refusing to comment when caught on an embarrassing detail that undermines the entire premise of his accusations.

Relax, don’t do it

At this point, Shapiro would do best to let the entire issue go, not just the bad vibes from the vetting process but the Harris campaign all together. That might be impossible, though, as the memoir isn’t even out yet, due to the reading public next Tuesday.

As a Jewish person about to publish a family memoir, I understand the perils of writing such a thing. I too am worried that some of my quotes will be cherry-picked and placed outside of the larger context. But that’s the risk of writing something for public consumption — no writer can control how their work will be perceived or which quotes will make the news.

Advertise with us

It’s why writers should double-check everything. Especially their own memories. Sometimes a slight is a slight. But I promise you, the law is always the law.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column is “Donald Trump has been a great president, for some.”