The columnists, contributing writers and others this week will be commenting on Donald Trump’s first year, on the anniversary week of his second inauguration.

Donald Trump is keenly aware of his legacy. Otherwise, why would he care about renaming venerated institutions after himself? And why declare his own birthday a free admission day at national parks after canceling the same status for MLK Day and Juneteenth?

A year into his second term, though, and Trump is struggling, his legacy in danger. As the newspaper The Independent put it, citing a SSRS survey for CNN, “a majority of Americans believe President Donald Trump’s first year back in the White House has been a ‘failure’ and that he has spent too much time of it focusing on the wrong priorities.”

While most of the poll considers how Trump has handled the economy, international relations, law and order, immigration and abuses of power, there’s a telling result at the bottom of the results: “The poll also revealed a shift in perceptions regarding the president as a person, with just one in three telling SSRS/​CNN they believed Trump cares about people like them, down from 40 percent in March.”

Advertise with us

I’m honestly surprised, given his track record, that one third of those polled actually think he cares about them.

The good

I’ll say this: President Trump promised to release the files surrounding the assassination of John F. Kennedy, and he did. He promised to remove us from the Paris Climate accords, and he did. He declared he would support the fossil fuels industry, and he has.

He has closed the border, as promised. He has waged war against transgender people, as promised. He made his tax cuts permanent, as promised.

We can debate how good any of these promises actually were, certainly. Those of us who care about climate change might be horrified, as are those of us who care about equal rights, humanitarian causes and refugees. But this is exactly what his supporters wanted.

And sure, the Trump tax cuts, “stand to benefit the highest income earners” according to the Treasury’s Office of Tax Analysis, with very little actually making it to the middle class, but this is another promise he made to the American people and one he fulfilled.

Advertise with us

For Trump and his acolytes, these are his victories, his attainments, and as the White House put it in a press release, “he has unquestionably delivered.”

The bad

But Trump’s biggest promise, the one that he rode into office, was to reduce the cost of living. A worldwide pandemic, and a loss in human productivity, led to an increase in the cost of goods during President Joe Biden’s tenure. And despite the U.S. hurting less than the rest of the world, people were unhappy with prices and wanted lower costs.

Trump promised to change all that by leaning into tariffs and protectionism. But he hasn’t. Almost two-thirds of respondents to the SSRS survey (63%) said that Trump has not done enough. That included 42% of Republicans, who said “more needs to be done to lower the price of groceries and everyday goods.”

And while the entire world is in the middle of an affordability crisis, the Trump presidency has only made things worse for average Americans than needed. Tariffs have driven up prices, shutting down solar and wind projects has diminished our energy supply and his Congress passed Trump-supported legislation that will increase health costs for at least 22 million Americans directly and the rest of us indirectly.

In this regard, Trump has been an absolute failure. And while he can try to blame the Biden administration for economic issues, the longer he does so, the more he reveals his inability to handle or grasp the enormity of the problem.

Advertise with us

The ugly

Thanks to Trump’s aggressive local deployment of border enforcement officials, civil unrest is at an all-time high. His obsession with imperial expansion into Greenland has us on the verge of a World War with NATO and Europe (who were our staunch allies a year ago). His invitation to have DOGE eliminate waste only increased our spending by 6%, failed to reduce our budget, and eliminated many members of the government workforce whose knowledge and skills the government still needs.

We’re not a better country today than we were a year ago, by no objective measure. There are fewer people employed than a year ago. There is less trust in the government. There are more protests and anger.

But Trump is already crowing victory, promoting all the amazing things he has done for the people of the world. But like his assertion that he’s ended eight wars, it’s pretty easy to debunk almost all his claimed accomplishments with a little research.

Still, he’ll continue to tout his wins, and some will continue to believe him. But most of us will not. As two-thirds of polled Americans noted, it’s because his actions have never been to benefit ordinary people. From his policies to his pardons-for-cash, it’s clear that Trump is only interested in enriching himself and his friends, other billionaires.

And on that measure, a year into office and a year into massive increases to his net worth, it cannot be denied, he’s been a wild success.

Advertise with us

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Oh, the places we will go, Mike Tomlin and me.”

The other entries in this series are Peter Kalis’s “Donald Trump knows what the U.S. must do to survive”; Seth Cropsey’s “Donald Trump's operational masterstrokes”; and Gene Collier’s “A dark year with the Threatener-in-Chief.”