“For a long time, I did not understand why middle class people hated me,” Jenna told me over lunch. “Like, it’s not my fault that I received benefits. I was broke. My man was broke. These kids needed to eat.”

For over five years, Jenna (who prefers not to share her last name) received housing, childcare, healthcare and food subsidies from state and federal agencies. Her husband, injured at his job a decade ago, receives disability. Together, her family of five survived on roughly $30,000 a year.

“It wasn’t pretty, but we made it work.” After all her expenses, she usually had a hundred dollars or so left over every month, something she could put into savings, or something she could use to treat her family to something nice. “Ice cream night is important for my kids to feel like kids.”

But making it work did not erase the shame that Jenna felt. “I heard all these people call us lazy, saying we don’t work — I work,” she said. “But it isn’t my fault that no job I could get paid good enough for us to live without benefits.”

Advertise with us

Still, she tried to do better, hating the way people looked at her kids whenever her subsidies came up in conversation. After years without being able to improve her situation, Jenna studied hard in the evenings and received an online certificate that allowed her to apply for a better position at the company where she works.

“I got educated, missed out on a lot of good nights with my babies, so I could get a better job,” Jenna continued. And she did. She was able to get a promotion that increased her family’s annual pay. Unfortunately, earning more meant that she was no longer eligible for certain benefits — including her housing.

“We can’t even scrape together enough for an ice cream night anymore,” she said. “I got one kid in daycare, bigger health bills, and now I gotta find a new place to live.”

“I make too much money to be poor enough to get help, but without that help, I don’t have enough money to live,” she continued. “Yeah, now I look at the people on assistance, and I’m like…. Dang, they got it easy. I shouldn’t have gotten a better job. I should have stayed as poor as I was. Things were better for me when everyone just thought I was lazy.”

The realest

Michael W. Green, a chief strategist and portfolio manager for an asset management company, blew up certain corners of the internet earlier this week, with his essay, “My Life is a Lie: How a Broken Benchmark Quietly Broke America.”

Advertise with us

In it, Green uses budgetary math to come to the conclusion that in order to escape the poverty line, a family of four in the United States needs to earn at least $140,000. The previously considered number, $31,200, was developed using an outdated model from the 1960s that predicted that food costs were roughly one-third of a family’s expenses.

But nowadays, that math doesn’t math. “If you measured income inadequacy today the way [Social Security Economist Mollie Orshansky] measured it in 1963, the threshold for a family of four wouldn’t be $31,200,” Green writes. “It would be somewhere between $130,000 and $150,000.”

He continues: “If the crisis threshold — the floor below which families cannot function — is honestly updated to current spending patterns, it lands at $140,000. What does that tell you about the $31,200 line we still use? It tells you we are measuring starvation.”

So fancy

“When you run the net-income numbers, a family earning $100,000 is effectively in a worse monthly financial position than a family earning $40,000,” Green writes. Why? People like Jenna can answer this question.

Or as Green put it, “Our entire safety net is designed to catch people at the very bottom, but it sets a trap for anyone trying to climb out. As income rises from $40,000 to $100,000, benefits disappear faster than wages increase.”

Advertise with us

Only 34% of American households earn over $150,000. Given that the median household income in the United States is $80,000, this means that more Americans fall in the category of “working poor” than what we used to consider the middle class.

In Green’s estimation this “explains the rage we see in the American electorate, specifically the animosity the ‘working poor’ (the middle class) feel toward the ‘actual poor’ and immigrants.”

Many Americans are angry at people who receive SNAP benefits, as well as healthcare and housing subsidies, because they are struggling to make ends meet. And it’s not getting better. This year alone, our electricity is up 10% statewide, grocery costs are up 2 to 10% (depending on where you live), and healthcare spending is up 8.2% nationally.

And for the people who receive no benefits, seeing someone with an EBT card getting ice cream can evoke nothing short of homicidal indignation.

In the fast lane

Jenna is hoping that when her youngest child enters public school, things will get better. But until then, ice cream nights are on hold. As is getting a new phone. As is ever going on a vacation again.

Advertise with us

“This was supposed to be the richest, best country in the world,” she said. “Why does everything feel so broken?”

She hates being poorer for having a better job, but she tries to focus on the pride that the promotion at work gave her. But even that has its limits.

“Part of me wonders if I should just go back to my old position. I could afford to go to the salon back then. Now,” she pointed at her disheveled hair, “I’m too rich to afford it.”

“Maybe it was worth it, being called fat and lazy and whatever. At least I looked better.”

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Living by the links linked with Parkinson’s?”.