This weekend I traveled to Texas for my friend Daniel’s wedding. It was a beautiful ceremony in the beflowered outdoor terrace of the turn-of-the-20th-century lawyer and politician William Jennings Bryan’s former winter home.

It was nice to run into old high school friends and catch up. Lisa, after discussing someone’s divorce, joked that she hoped she might one day get the chance to do that too.

We all laughed a sad laugh, aware that Lisa, like millions of other Americans like her, wanted all the ups and downs associated with joining your life with another human, whether the hopeful beginning we had just witnessed or the sad end that affects so many old friends we knew.

Goin’ to the chapel

At the heart of Lisa’s joke was her queerness. She knew, like we all did, that the Supreme Court was considering taking up a petition from former Kentucky clerk Kim Davis to overturn Obergefell v. Hodges and, thus, same-sex marriage. At the core of her joke was her right to build a life with the woman she loves.

Advertise with us

According to statistics from last June, there are over 823,000 same-sex marriages in the United States. And on Monday morning, I’m sure most of those couples breathed a sigh of relief, as the Supreme Court of the United States chose not to revisit the 2015 case that enabled those marriages to exist.

The court’s decision not to re-litigate Obergefell, though, doesn’t give same-sex couples the reassurance it should. The court reportedly did not take up case because Davis’ petition lacked sufficient standing, evidence and merit, not because the justices accepted the constitutionality and legality of the Obergefell decision.

Justice Clarence Thomas, after all, signaled that Obergefell was not considered resolved law after overturning Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization in 2022, saying that both cases relied on the same interpretation of privacy.

There are three justices on the court right now who dissented in Obergefell (Chief Justice John Roberts as well as Samuel Alito and Thomas), and only two who voted for it (Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan). If the court had accepted the Davis petition, the Roberts Court would have been forced to uphold or overturn the decision once and for all.

That 3 to 2 split would put the decision in the hands of the remaining four justices — one Biden appointee (Ketanji Brown Jackson) and three Trump appointments (Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett).

Advertise with us

Roberts himself has not spoken much about same-sex marriage since his 2015 dissent, which might indicate that to him, despite disagreement, it’s settled case law. But, given that the Davis petition was dismissed without commentary or explanation, there is no certainty about the future of almost one million American marriages.

Gonna get married

Detractors of same-sex marriage argue that, fundamentally, marriage is a religious act, a sacred rite. But the truth is that marriage, from its inception, has been woven into civil rights, especially regarding dowries, property and inheritance, or, in more modern times, the benefits granted to people legally bound today.

Auto insurance rates, custody rights, hospital visitations, survivor benefits, health insurance, are clearly not inherently religious. To simply undo that would leave over 1.5 million people in a state of permanent uncertainty about a life they have built with their partners.

But for some, marriage is far more spiritual and sacred than contract law. And to many of those people, marriage cannot be secular. Hence, the situation we found ourselves in, where one woman, who firmly believes that only a man and woman can be wed, can claim that it is her right to deny anyone that doesn’t fit that definition the opportunity to build a life outside the confines of her religion.

How can the law reconcile the reality of contemporary marriage with the religious meaning so many want to give it?

Advertise with us

Which brings me back to William Jennings Bryan. The famed former Secretary of State under Woodrow Wilson, who argued against evolution in the 1925 Scopes Monkey Trial, is often considered the father of liberalism as well.

Or as author Scott Farris put it, “many fail to understand Bryan because he occupies a rare space in society,” as someone who is both “too liberal for today's religious [and] too religious for today's liberals”.

Love until the end of time

Some people try to reconcile religion with contemporary marriage by proposing that civil unions should be separated from marriage, but that ignores how people actually live and love.

In the last five years, I’ve attended ten weddings, most of which involved a man and a woman, including Daniel’s. But all those weddings were different, picking and choosing from various traditions to best reflect the tastes, cultures and desires of the couple getting married.

I’ve been to celebrations without officiants, without a ceremony, without dinner, without alcohol, without dancing, and even without dessert. But none of those things are what define a wedding — or a marriage for that matter.

Advertise with us

A marriage occupies a rare space in society. It is about the legal union of two people, about the creation of a new family, and about love. Lisa deserves that as much as Daniel, as much as me, as much as anyone else.

And she deserves the certainty that comes with knowing that her ability to make that rare space is as secure as my own.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “The kind of losers losing candidates should be.”