Years ago, Dr. Marla A. Ramírez (no relation), a historian who now teaches at University of Wisconsin-Madison, began researching immigration narratives of undocumented immigrant youth from the U.S.-Mexico border. As she interviewed them, she began with the question: “How do you identify yourself?”
One young man answered with, “I’m a U.S. citizen, but not legally recognized as one.”
It was a record-scratch moment, and one that would eventually complicate her notion of the United States’ history of deportations. She thought that perhaps he meant that he felt culturally American. How could someone be a citizen but not recognized?
“Well, my paternal grandmother is a U.S. citizen, she was born here, but she was kicked out during the Great Depression,” her interviewee said. “Thus, my father was born in Mexico, and I was born in Mexico as well.”
The young man was a direct descendant of a U.S. citizen, but “we haven’t been able to open an immigration case, because she passed away when she was really young. And now I’m undocumented here.”
As Ramírez put it, her “mind was blown,” as she considered this secret history. But as she began digging deeper into families like this, she unearthed the story of hundreds of thousands of U.S. citizens who were deported to Mexico, mostly the wives and children of Mexican nationals.
Three generations later, many of their descendants have returned to the U.S., existing in a liminal space defined by the inherent tension in their status, both rightfully U.S. citizens and also illegal in the country of their mothers and grandmothers.
Born in the U.S.A.
The result of all this research is Ramírez’s extraordinary book, “Banished Citizens: A History of the Mexican American Women Who Endured Repatriation.”
Ramírez well documents how between one and two million people of Mexican descent were deported in three waves before WWII, beginning in 1921, primarily in California, although states all across the southwest as well as midwestern states like Michigan and Illinois made similar efforts.
These “repatriations,” as they were called, hoped to send people back to their places of origin within Mexico. There was tremendous collateral damage, as after enough time in the U.S., the idea of “origin” got muddied.
Consider the story of Trinidad Rodríguez, who was an American citizen and the daughter of two American citizens. After losing her father, her mother remarried an undocumented Mexican immigrant living in the United States. A few years later, her mother passed away, leaving a preschool-aged daughter who then lived with her step-father and half-sister.
In 1922, during one of the first repatriation waves in California, Rodríguez, her siblings and other family members were deported because of her step-father’s status, their papers confiscated by immigration agents. This is how Trinidad Rodríguez found herself in Yahualica, Jalisco, a city she’d never been to or visited, a city without (outside of her half-sister) any blood relatives, where she’d always be an outsider.
But because she was a minor and her step-father was her guardian, she was stuck in Mexico instead of Redlands, California, where her mother’s side of the family remained. As Ramírez uncovered, Trinidad Rodríguez never reconnected with her aunts and cousins on that side of the family again. She grew up unanchored, as her native country was taken from her by its government, and she spent a large part of her life trying to get back.
Sent me off to a foreign land
“Essentially what is happening now, happened 100 years ago,” Ramírez told me in an interview, referencing the efforts of Immigration and Customs Enforcement under the second Trump administration. “Mixed-status immigrant families” are once again experiencing a “dangerous reality to live under.”
In Ramírez’s view, these deportations have a cyclical quality to them, and they tend to come in moments of financial hardship and uncertainty. “It’s economic,” she said, “there’s an economic benefit to these deportations,” and not just the the billion-dollar detention center industry.
“Our system in the U.S. is that if you engage in mass removals, you can then bring in new waves of immigrants who are exploitable because they know less about their rights,” she continued. “There’s a reason they are raiding specific places like construction sites and street vendors. They are targeting the working class, the people who know less about their rights and how labor systems work here.”
Not knowing something can have devastating consequences, not only in speaking, but in action (or lack thereof). In the case of Trinidad Rodríguez, for example, not knowing she could get a copy of her birth certificate at any U.S. consulate meant that it took her over 50 years to acquire an absolutely crucial document.
“Nonetheless, some women found creative workarounds,” Ramírez writes, “Tourist visas allowed migrants to stay up to six months in the United States, which could have given some people enough time to secure copies of their U.S. birth certificates and reclaim their citizenship. This is what Trinidad [Rodríguez] was eventually able to do, using this legal strategy as her way of fighting back, of rejecting her banishment.”
Still, she died soon after finally getting the document and before she could get everything perfectly in order. And now her grandchildren, living without papers in the city of her birth, continue to pay the price.
In the U.S.A. now
“If we ignore our past, then we are blindfolded on how to best move forward as a nation,” Ramírez said. “And if we ignore who we are as a nation, then we also can come to incorrect assumptions of who doesn’t belong and who does.”
“There’s a misconception that immigrants from Latin America are a new phenomenon, a new presence in the United States,” she went on to say, “and that too is ignorance.”
Efforts have been made to un-erase this chapter in our history. The California State Legislature passed the “Apology Act of the 1930s Mexican Repatriation Program” in 2005, which culminated in a 2012 official plaque-installation ceremony to commemorate those removed.
While the apology might feel too late, as Ramírez sees it, when it comes to inter-generational trauma, it’s never too late: “There’re prolonged consequences that are still being felt today by the people who are descendants of the women and children banished then, people living these legacies of banishment in the flesh, robbed of property and upper mobility and political power.”
“We need to reckon with our past and be able to recognize that this has happened before,” she continued. “How else can we become better and learn from the dark moments of our past? We made these mistakes 100 years ago, not being careful and banishing our own women and children.”
The stories in the news of American citizens mistakenly taken by immigration officials don’t bode well for us. One can imagine the plaques that will be installed in 2125. Ramírez is more hopeful than I am, but she knows that accountability matters.
“If we agree to support the mass deportations that are happening now, without due process, then we as a nation, as a society, need to also be ready to take responsibility, to deal with the prolonged consequences three generations later.”
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “The NFL wants your halftime outrage.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.