I am writing from Missouri this week, as I was invited by the St. Louis Jewish Community Center to present in their St. Louis Jewish Book Festival and Speaker Series. The morning after my talk (on storytelling and faith), I decided to attend the J.C.C.’s “Books and Bagels” brunch series, which featured Dr. Gerald Early, whose work I’d last seen in Ken Burns’ documentary “Baseball.”
Early was there to promote his new book, written in collaboration with the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum in Cooperstown, N.Y., titled “Play Harder: The Triumph of Black Baseball in America.”
As I added some schmear to my everything bagel, I listened to Early’s comments on the Negro Leagues and felt some pride when he named Pittsburgh as an epicenter of Black baseball, after Chicago and Philadelphia. The Homestead Grays got a shoutout or two.
But I really perked up at Early’s discussion of what it was like to consult on the redesign of the Black baseball exhibit at the National Baseball Hall of Fame. He explained how the hall had been designed in such a way that no matter from which direction the museum-goer approached, whether entering from the front, or a side entrance attached to another exhibit, the story made sense.
“There is the way a museum space is designed, the way a curator wants the visitor to walk through and learn. But most visitors do their own thing, seeing things in all kinds of orders — and the exhibit still has to work.”
During the question and answer portion of Early’s visit, this detail came up again and again from my fellow bagel-consumers. “How is this done?” one woman wondered.
“With careful curation,” he replied.
There is no team, like the best team
Without such caution, Early explained, a visitor could risk confusion — something museums tend to want to avoid, as they are places we go to understand the world a little better, whether through art, history, aviation, science or sport.
It makes sense that a museum would be curated, planned and designed to the smallest possible detail. As Early explained the need for interactive features (“to better engage children”) every few feet, I considered the power of curation, of best presenting what is known to be true.
It was a big deal, for example, when Negro League statistics were folded into Major League Baseball’s numbers, as it gave Pittsburgh’s Josh Gibson the highest career and single-season batting averages.
This ruffled some feathers, mostly from Ty Cobb fans, who did not appreciate the previous highest-career-batting-average player suddenly falling to second. When I asked Early about this, he demurred diplomatically, explaining the importance of recognizing Gibson’s greatness, and that few realized the Negro Leagues were “major” enough to count.
But Early is not interested in a story of complaint, and neither is the exhibit he consulted on, “Souls of the Game.” There’s a reason “triumph” features heavily in his accompanying book’s subtitle.
Which is our team, right here
The title of the book,“Play Harder,” is something Early says reflects the persistence of Black American baseball players.
“When asked how it felt not being recognized, these men unequivocally responded that they would ‘play harder’ — it was a philosophy,” Early said.
A previous version of the exhibit had focused on the struggles of Black players, but Early said the museum wanted to move away from that message to one of accomplishment, a message that would be more appealing to the visitors of the National Baseball Hall of Fame.
It is an important story to tell. The story of Black Americans in baseball is a story of triumph, as well as resistance and tenacity, resolve and determination — all the virtues we associate with being quintessentially American. The story of the Negro Leagues, which included the Pittsburgh Crawfords and the Homestead Grays, is also the story of Pittsburgh, the story of baseball, and, to some degree, the story of America.
It is the latter I am most worried about these days — who is telling the story of this nation today? We have too many competing narratives and too many realities — too many silos of information.
It’s starting to get messy. Where are the careful curators — the ones concerned with telling an honest story, one that makes us all better for having engaged?
Win just one more
I appreciated knowing that the National Baseball Hall of Fame chose to reframe the story of Black Americans in baseball, rather than censor or erase the very real struggles faced by these players of America’s favorite pastime.
It speaks well of us, to acknowledge the blemishes in our history, to see our people as capable of evolving. Just like baseball statistics, there’s always new information to consider, new numbers that must be counted.
It matters — to Josh Gibson, to Pittsburgh, to us all. We should get the facts right, and then worry about how to tell it in a way that engages and entertains as well.
Perhaps we should all take a trip to Cooperstown in the near future, to see how to best tell a story of struggle and redemption. During this time of great capitulation, I could use a story of hope, perseverance, and triumph.
It might be time to just play harder.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “When cancel culture and irony collide.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.