Last weekend, I attended a birthday party on the Squirrel Hill side of Mellon Park. Probably twenty children, of all ages, were running around and the adults around the picnic table drinking mocktails in the mid-afternoon, gazed upon their children as they frolicked.
My kids were standing by a large tree with some friends, about a hundred yards away from me, when something caught my eye. Ambling toward them was a man, ambiguously middle-aged, and his big, fluffy teddy-bear-like dog.
The dog was cute, but unleashed. I knew that one of my kid’s friends had a deep terror of dogs. “Kids, there’s an unleashed dog heading your way,” I projected across the park. My son looked up and immediately moved his sister and friend away from the dog.
All my dogs is with me
The wind picked up and all I could hear was the end of the dog owner’s response, “a good dog, well-trained.” He increased his volume when he saw my perplexed face. “We come here every day.”
“Then, sir, you should have seen the many red signs indicating that dogs must be leashed,” I responded, pointing at the aforementioned displays.
He argued something about how everyone should universally recognize his dog as a Good Dog Who is Who is Well-Trained, unlike the dogs the signs warned about, the ones that needed to be leashed.
“There’s a child afraid of dogs here, sir,” I countered. “Is your dog more important than them?”
Outnumbered, he murmured an insincere apology and put a leash on his dog. The other parents who had gathered behind me thanked him, and we all went on with our day.
But I can’t stop thinking about his excuse — his Good Dog Who Always Behaves and his clearly expressed belief that I was in the wrong, despite the publicly visible ordinance.
The easiest explanation is entitlement, a characteristic of our time. This man felt that his Good Dog Who is Always Here deserved special treatment, something above the ordinary dogs that misbehave. But his dog is a dog, and like all dogs (and sentient creatures!) not every action or reaction can be predicted.
I am a dog owner myself. On the rare occasion when I find myself leash-less in public with my 12-pound Lhasa Apso, I scoop her up and carry her, despite the fact that Maleta (her name means “suitcase”), would lose a fight against a stuffed animal. Still — on the rarer occasion that she wanders freely, I know I am accountable for what she does.
So extracurricular
We cannot imagine everything we will encounter. One time, as I walked Maleta on leash, a neighborhood German Shepherd bounded up to her, without a tether in sight. When she resisted his initially playful sniffs, he began attacking her, all teeth and gnashing. I had to kick the German Shepherd away while carrying a terrified Maleta, clawing her way up my body.
The owner came chasing after her dog. “I’m so sorry,” she said. Normally, she explained, her dog was a well-trained Good Dog Who Would Never. “I have no idea what came over him!”
Entitlement is too easy of an explanation — it contains a kind of narcissism I think is actually lacking in these situations. It’s not that these people think that they are better than everyone else, it’s that they think their dogs are.
A dog that has taken classes, been to school, loves everyone it meets, is still a dog — a animal with a will and desires of its own. The most domesticated creature is still unpredictable. It’s one reason we love our furry friends.
It’s also the reason we have leashes, so that we may promenade with our creatures while still maintaining boundaries and control. We can’t let them go even in the very tempting open grass of Mellon Park.
To be in a society is to understand that public spaces are to be shared by all. The dog owners, and the kids who are scared of dogs. And that puts some restrictions on everyone — sometimes marked by many red signs.
Dog runs and open (and unleashed) play areas exist for a reason. To contain the chaos, to add an element of consent, to separate those we can only trust will heed our calls from those they might frighten or endanger.
Regular-degular
A section of my right eyebrow is missing. When I was around eleven years old, I picked up an unleashed puppy that ran up to me near a public swimming pool. This fluffy, white dog, scared of my sudden affection, bit me, requiring a hospital visit and stitches.
That day, though, the dog’s owners screamed at my parents, blaming me for picking up an unknown dog. Their dog, they told my parents, was a Good Dog That Would Never — the blood on my face didn’t matter.
But there are no Good Dogs That Would Never. There are only Ordinary Dogs Who Might, and, unfortunately, some owners who are sure the creatures they love are not the subject of the rules.
The rules are for other people’s regular old dogs, the Bad Ones — the ones that would terrify a child.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Does Stacy Garrity have a chance?”.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.