Last Monday, state treasurer Stacy Garrity declared that she is running for the Republican nomination for governor, even as State Sen. Doug Mastriano (R, Franklin), who is leading polls, considers another run for the office.
Garrity is a popular state treasurer, best known for quickly, and without hassle, returning unclaimed funds to the one in 10 Pennsylvanians who qualify for a rebate. The checks, with Garrity’s name prominently displayed, have made a difference in the lives of families struggling in the present economy.
After I looked through the easily searchable database, I found a decade-old DirectTV reimbursement sent to an address we moved away from long ago. I quickly claimed it. It felt like my government was actually working for me.
Returning unclaimed property has done as much for Stacy Garrity as current Democratic Governor Josh Shapiro has, whose refusal to publicly support her opponent in the treasurer’s race allowed her to scoop up crucial labor endorsements.
Mean mugs
And while Garrity has often praised Shapiro, things are different now that she is running for his job.
“I am well aware that this is going to be a tough race, but I’ve never backed down from a challenge,” Garrity wrote in an email to GOP state committee members on Monday, as reported by the Inquirer. “We will be viewed as the underdog by many. But with grit, hard work, and dedication, I am confident that we can end Josh Shapiro’s time in Harrisburg.”
But do voters want to end Josh Shapiro’s time in Harrisburg? Every metric would indicate otherwise.
He has a net approval rating of +35. His war chest is enviable (he ended 2024 with $11 million in the bank). And there’s a lot motivating Democrats to win. All elections in the Trump era are a referendum on D.C. — and Democrats, here and nationally, cannot afford to lose Pennsylvania.
Shapiro has been on the front lines of the battle against federal budget cuts, rising electricity prices, and food insecurity — to mixed results. The man is not without skeletons in his closet. But overall, one gets the sense that a safe majority of Pennsylvanians see a champion in Governor Shapiro. Any opposition is going to have to be very, very strong to unseat the person who received the most gubernatorial votes in Pennsylvania history.
“The fact is, Josh Shapiro is going to be reelected governor of Pennsylvania. It’s not a question of if, it’s a question of [by] how much,” Larry Ceisler, a Philadelphia-based public affairs executive and a Democrat, told ABCNews.
Shoulder shrugs
It also doesn’t help Stacy Garrity that at a rally in Pittsburgh last May, President Donald Trump endorsed U.S. Rep. Dan Meuser (R, Dallas). “He’s been a great congressman,” Trump said. “And if you run, you have my full support. And you’ll win. The people are going to get it real fast.”
After mulling it for a few weeks, Meuser declined to run — most likely to avoid losing to Shapiro. Mastriano has not officially announced either, although he did misogynistically state that Garrity should be his Lt. Governor.
“The big question I have is, ‘Would you as a Republican thinking about this office want to choose 2026 as the time you want to make that run?’” Christopher Borick, a pollster and director of the Muhlenberg College Institute of Public Opinion, told Spotlight PA.
“You’re thinking, ‘Well I want to be governor,’ but you’re thinking, ‘I have to first take on a well-funded incumbent who’s never lost a race in the state, and I have to do it in a period where my party is facing headwinds.’” I think he’s saying your answer should be no.
Stacy Garrity — the staunchly anti-abortion politician who supports federal cuts for Medicaid, and who continues to parrot the lie that Trump won the 2020 election — has been a fine state treasurer. Her military, business and managerial experience work there. But I’m not sure she’s ready for the biggest office in the state.
In many ways, she’s an echo of Mastriano, spouting similar messaging on stolen elections and eliminating funding from public schools. One gets the feeling that Garrity has not looked at state-wide polling on these issues.
Let me in now
But that’s the problem with running as a Republican these days. GOP candidates are required to show fealty to their party’s leader and endorse his unpopular policies.
Perhaps that’s why Stacy Garrity’s campaign website lists no proposed policies, and instead focuses on purely biographical information. Given how impressive her public service resume is, this is her biggest strength — along with unclaimed property checks.
Now that actually improved people’s lives. Still, she’s going to need to do a lot more than put a few hundred dollars in some Pennsylvanian’s pockets to secure the nomination over Mastriano, not to mention defeat Shapiro.
And the governor? He speaks like a man who has nothing to worry about.
“The Republicans are going to deal with their intramural fight,” Shapiro said last Friday. “I’m not going to get into their parlor games.”
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Finding hope in an exorcism.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.