I tend to avoid the YouTube channel run by Jubilee Media, and in particular “Surrounded,” their popular show in which one person sits in the middle of a room and 20 people take turns trying to talk over them.
The format — “a conservative debates 20 liberals,” “a religious person debates 20 atheists,” and infinite versions of “a reasonably intelligent person debates 20 idiots” (and vice-versa)— seems staged to encourage a whole lot of yelling and interrupting to generate unending rage clicks
It’s nothing like an actual, moderated debate, and I find “Surrounded” too stressful to watch regularly. But the conversations can be revelatory.
People are talking
Anyone who is on social media might find it difficult to escape “Surrounded,” as clips for it dominate ads on X and circulate freely on Instagram. Last week, I encountered too many promos for the newest episode: “1 Progressive vs 20 Far-Right Conservatives (ft. Mehdi Hasan).”
In the 24 hours since it was posted, the two-hour video has almost 2 million views, with the number steadily rising. And even though I would normally not, I couldn’t help but want to watch it as well. My eyeballs contributed to the count.
The conversations were wild and insightful. But one moment seemed to bother subsequent debaters, who brought it up over and over again.
Early on, Hasan, best known as a progressive talking head across mediums, as well as the founder of Zeteo News Media, stopped his conversation with one young man, a self-declared fascist, pointing out that there was no reason to continue the conversation. This upset the fascist-sympathizers.
“Why would you dismiss the point of view of an entire group of people?” the debaters asked him, not comprehending why he would dismiss all fascists. But I understand why he did it.
Because they are fascists.
After the young man in question admitted to being an avid fan of the late General Francisco Franco, the 1939-1976 brutal and repressive dictator (“caudillo”) of Spain, Hasan stared at him in disbelief for a moment.
He asked the young man again if he was a fascist. After the young man confirmed it once more, grinning ear-to-ear, declaring his support for a Trump Autocracy as at least five people clapped in support, Hasan had to stop his argument. He kept silent, letting the clock tick down, waiting until enough people voted to change who sat in the chair against him.
The only acceptable thing when faced with fascism is not to give more space to these kinds of anti-democratic views in front of millions of viewers. How do you debate the issues eroding democracy to someone who sees no need for it?
Just ignore it
A fascist, who wants to see elections and diversity removed from this country, doesn’t care if Donald Trump is pro-criminal, if the Trump Administration is dismantling the Constitution, if immigration is overall a good thing, or if the Trump Administration supports ethnic cleansing — the topics Hasan came to argue.
A fascist doesn’t care if a would-be autocrat is doing autocratic things — anything Hasan argued would be moot. How does one follow up after someone’s reply to “ethnic cleansing is happening!” is “Who cares?” much less, “great!”?
Hasan chose not to call that young man a monster in front of millions of viewers, or to debate, and thus validate, the young man’s terrifying ideas for an American dictatorship.
There was another moment, later on, when a different debater would not agree it was bad to kill Palestinian children with snipers. Hasan’s eyes widened, and he looked at the other people surrounding him, suddenly unsure of what these self-proclaimed young “Far-Right Conservatives” actually believed or valued.
A few never got the chance to face Hasan, but the ones who did could be sorted into three categories: The ones who were willing to listen and learn (roughly two), the ones who came ready to articulately defend their world-views (maybe three), and the misinformed (everyone else that spoke). Hateful rhetoric dominated.
Over the course of 120 minutes, Hasan was told to leave the country. He was told that he had no stake in America because he was a foreign-born, naturalized citizen. He was told that as someone born in the U.K., he could not possibly comprehend American culture. He was threatened with death on at least three occasions. And none of these were uttered by the fascist.
But they keep sayin’
In debate, this kind of attacks is called ad hominem, attacking the opponent instead of engaging with their opinions. It’s easier to deny Hasan has any right to speak, because he was born in another country, than it is to contend with the factually-backed arguments he came to defend.
Still — Hasan continued to engage with the xenophobic. Why not the fascist?
There’s little reason to debate the beauty of light with someone who has encountered it and still prefers to live in total darkness. You only risk encouraging others to choose the darkness.
A fascist is a fascist — the rare instance of an ad hominem claim that is utterly relevant — and decisive. Nothing more to debate.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “The Republican betrayal of rural America.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.