Jim Crow laws, upheld by the Supreme Court in 1896 in Plessy v. Ferguson, made it perfectly legal to discriminate against a person based on the color of their skin. Into the 1960s, a Black or Latino person asking to be served in an ice cream parlor’s section reserved for white patrons could be arrested for trespassing, found in violation of the law and possibly jailed for stepping across a line.

After 70 years of “separate but equal,” the Civil Rights Movement organized protests and sit-ins, asking for access to public spaces with dignity, and therefore the end of Jim Crow. While we look back on the work of these brave men and women positively now, elevating Martin Luther King Jr., Rosa Parks and John Lewis into heroes for all, most Americans did not feel that way during those years.

According to a Gallup poll in May 1961, 61% of Americans disapproved of “what the Freedom Riders are doing.” 57% believed that “sit-ins at lunch counters” overwhelmingly harmed any chances at integration.

31% of Americans back then did not know who the Freedom Riders were, or what they fought for. According to data published by the Roper Center for Public Opinion Research, 17% called them “agitators, troublemakers, communists, etc.”

Advertise with us

I wish I could say the American public has grown more aware, more learned, about issues affecting those ostensibly in the wrong place at the wrong time. But our collective ignorance lingers — to our collective detriment.

Best educated, best equipped

Existing without authorization is not a crime. It is a civil offense, which is why people who are found in this country without proper paperwork are not put through criminal proceedings.

Undocumented immigrants, when caught violating the law, are not read their Miranda rights, they are not given lawyers or put through the criminal court system. Immigration courts are civil courts, charged with administrative duties and able to remove and detain, but not imprison.

Requesting asylum is also not illegal. If one enters the country and subsequently does not seek asylum, it is considered a misdemeanor with civil consequences (a fine, detention and eventually deportation).

Yes, immigration violations can lead to criminal charges — namely if one is caught actively crossing without authorization, or if one is caught reentering after having been previously deported. According to Title 8 of the U.S. Code, § 1325 and 1326, these are the only two offenses that are actually criminal.

Advertise with us

Someone existing in our country without papers is not a criminal — no more than someone who receives a parking ticket. But that hasn’t stopped millions of Americans from repeating the lie so often that, for them, it feels true.

Make everybody see

Robert Lovato coined the term “Juan Crow” in a 2008 article for The Nation describing “the matrix of laws, social customs, economic institutions and symbolic systems enabling the physical and psychic isolation needed to control and exploit undocumented immigrants.”

I’m more partial to the Spanish word for “crow,” “cuervo.” And in the era of Juan Cuervo, public polling indicates a majority unswayed by moral and factual evidence.

Despite the Supreme Court affirming that deportation is “not a criminal punishment,” most Americans are unaware that it is a civil offense. Most Americans are unaware that even undocumented people have rights under the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Amendments. Most Americans cannot wrap their minds around the fact that undocumented people pay sales, property and consumption taxes without receiving any Social Security benefits.

Most Americans are unaware of a study that shows that “immigrants, regardless of status, will pay on average $80,000 per capita more in taxes than they use in government services over their lifetime.”

Advertise with us

According to the Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, research over the last 20 years has “found no support for the immigration-crime connection. Although there are always individual exceptions to aggregate patterns and trends, immigrants commit fewer crimes, on average, than native-born Americans.”

Consider this: when the U.S. has gotten it right, regarding the humane treatment of minorities, it’s been despite the opinions of the polled majority.

Fight the powers that be

In 1963, 60% of Americans viewed mass civil rights rallies unfavorably, according to a Gallup poll. In October 1966, in answer to a question on whether civil rights demonstrations “have helped more or hurt more in the advancement of Negro rights,” 85% of respondents, all of whom were white, indicated “hurt.”

Last weekend’s “No Kings” protests are being called the biggest in U.S. history, with estimates that up to six million people across the country assembled against Trump and his increasingly authoritarian policies, especially concerning immigration.

Already, right-wing media are saying that the protests will hurt the cause, that the people on the ground are “agitators,” “troublemakers,” “communists,” etc., as if good trouble doesn’t exist.

Advertise with us

The border is a complicated space – and while we need to revisit our immigration policies and laws to end up somewhere humane and practical for everyone, we should also acknowledge that the shadow of Juan Cuervo will be as long as Jim Crow’s. Doing the right thing might mean ignoring the loudest voices in the room, no matter how popular they might be — and working to change our policies now so that someday Americans will look at Juan Cuervo with the same shame with which we look at Jim Crow.

Adriana E. Ramírez is the editor of InReview and a columnist who writes about books, popular culture and politics for the Post-Gazette. She is the PEN-award-winning author of “Dead Boys.”