A friend of mine tied to the Peduto administration once told me that this year’s Democratic primary for the mayor of Pittsburgh would come down to “that undecided voter — young, professional, left-leaning, living in the 10th, 15th, 19th and 26th wards.”
In his estimation, of the 90 neighborhoods in Pittsburgh, Morningside, Hazelwood, Beechview, Brookline, Perry North and Perry South would determine the winner of the Democratic primary, which in Pittsburgh, barring a tremendous upset from the Republicans, is essentially the race for mayor.
The election will soon be over, and so will what has become a very contentious race. Spurious accusations have been made about which of the two candidates is most responsible for the state of the city, most connected to unsavory characters in the political world, and most beholden to his donors.
Is the Democratic primary a referendum on Trump, as the constant texts I’m getting from OnePA seem to imply? Or is this election about race? Is it about Palestine? Antisemitism?
Families have been drawn into the conflict, as have newspapers from the United Kingdom, and yet, most of the people I spoke to around the city, including in the 10th and 15th wards, have no idea about most of the mudslinging aimed at both Mayor Gainey and County Controller Corey O’Connor.
For them, this election is about the city of Pittsburgh itself — the aesthetics and efficiency of its public works, its plan for an ever-changing world, and the ease of life within its limits. Next Tuesday’s ballots will not be a reflection on national issues. It will be about competing visions on housing, public transportation, budgets, water fountains and potholes.
You actin’ kind of shady
And here’s the brutal truth — most of the people I spoke to in Morningside, Glen Hazel and Hazelwood are not happy with the state of the city. They were not happy with the potholes, and now that many of them have been patched, they are not happy about the bumpy mounds that replaced them.
But that dissatisfaction remains inconsistent — some voters put the problems at Mayor Gainey’s feet, while others feel like the underscoring issues predate the mayor.
One early-voter talked about how the current administration seemed keen on quick fixes instead of a long-term vision. In Highland Park, as I walked with a group, another person said that was exactly why the mayor needed another term, “he deserves a chance to execute what he’s started.” This quickly devolved into a conversation about how long mayors actually need to improve the city.
“I can’t support someone that has brought Pittsburgh so close to financial ruin,” I was told in Hazelwood, even as the person standing next to them applauded the mayor for navigating the post-pandemic world with great care for minority businesses. A voter I spoke to in Homewood pointed at all the vacant lots, where no construction has happened despite bids being out for years.
“Where’s that investment again?”
Runnin’ game
The polling on the mayoral primary has narrowed the margin between candidates, after O’Connor surged in early predictions. It seems that the Gainey campaign’s attempts to falsely paint O’Connor as a MAGA-operative have paid off. But there’s a limit to how many people will buy that lie.
Yard signs and casual discussions with voters in Morningside and other bellwether neighborhoods point to an O’Connor victory, despite Gainey’s machinations. A friend who is into local politics thinks it will be 55% for the challenger. But I wouldn’t count out the incumbent.
As my Peduto-era friend pointed out, the 2021 mayoral primary had historical turnout for younger voters and within primarily African American neighborhoods, especially given that it was an off-year for elections. If Gainey can replicate it, and enough people want to give him another opportunity to serve, there’s a chance he’ll squeak by O’Connor into four more years in office.
But I’m not sure.
There are things I like about Ed Gainey. I like his personality and his passion for the city. I find his constant promotion of the NFL draft endearing. I believe him when he says he wants a better Pittsburgh.
But I understand why so many people living in crucial wards and neighborhoods lean in a different direction. Those “young, professional, left-leaning” voters want more.
Who you with?
Undecided voters want a clean city and more housing. They want a simple tax code. They want less deterioration and better public transportation in the city — especially to the airport. Everyone wants functional water fountains and public restrooms open in the summer.
The undecided voter wants a well-managed budget. They want public festivals and public spaces. They want beds for the homeless. They want good schools and services for the most vulnerable. They want uncomplicated permitting. They want their lives in Pittsburgh to be easy.
I don’t blame them. With the exception of the “young” part, I’m one of them. And even as I try to drown out the noise, and try to find the truth at the bottom of each campaign’s accusations about the other, I cannot help but look around me and agree.
I want something different.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Heads on spikes boost morale.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.