Less than an hour after he set a fire in Governor Josh Shapiro’s home last week, the alleged arsonist called police dispatchers, asking them to inform Gov. Shapiro that he “will not take part in [Gov. Shapiro’s] plans for what he wants to do to the Palestinian people.”

The timing of the attack, on the first weekend of Pesach, or Passover, immediately evoked questions regarding antisemitism. The governor is a prominent Jewish politician and had just held a seder in the room where the arsonist set his fire.

Despite his thoughts on the Palestinian conflict, the motives of the alleged arsonist remain unclear: Was this a crime motivated by hatred of Jewish people? Or was this a crime motivated by politics?

Was Shapiro attacked for his faith or for his firm stance regarding Israel? Can most Americans even tell the difference anymore?

Advertise with us

Trusting who we are

Like many Jewish people, myself included, Gov. Shapiro has a complicated position on the war in Gaza. After the initial attack in October 2023, Shapiro confirmed he believed in “Israel’s right to defend itself.”

In the ensuing months, he was critical of pro-Palestinian student encampments, calling for them to be dismantled, but at the same time, he has also lambasted Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu as “one of the worst leaders of all time.”

There is no unified Jewish response to the conflict. Jews can denounce the killing of a people, given our own people’s history, even when the perpetrators are Jewish. They can also support Israel’s right to self-defense.

Being Jewish has never been contingent on political views. Still, targeting a prominent Jewish Democrat on Pesach seems deliberate. The alleged arsonist could have attacked any of the Christian Republican politicians who have also vehemently stood by Israeli choices in Gaza (we have a lot in Pennsylvania), but chose to set fire to the home of a Jewish family on a Jewish holiday.

He has since been arrested and charged with attempted homicide, terrorism, arson, and “related crimes for allegedly attempting to kill Shapiro,” to quote the Philadelphia Inquirer. But all these charges are at the state level.

Advertise with us

What did the U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi have to say? “We have been praying for Josh, for his family. Those photos, it was horrible. I firmly believe that they wanted to kill him.”

But she did not immediately designate the attack an act of domestic terrorism, insisting that federal investigations are ongoing.

This is strange, coming from the same Attorney General who quickly declared assaults on Tesla dealerships and vehicles “politically-motivated” acts of “domestic terrorism” and promised to prosecute anyone caught vandalizing a Tesla to the fullest extent of the law, including arsonists.

How could the attack not be antisemitic terrorism? The target wasn’t just any pro-Israel pol, it was the Jewish governor of Pennsylvania on a Jewish holiday.

Never cared for what they do

But the Trump Administration wants to eradicate antisemitism, right? According to the government, extorting universities, including Harvard and Columbia, for ideological compliance is intended to eliminate antisemitism.

Advertise with us

The administration argues that those universities allowed students to protest, and as such, they permitted an environment hostile to Jewish people, which is a violation of equal protection.

So forgive me for believing that when confronted with an actual act of antisemitism, the administration would put aside political partisanship, and immediately focus on their stated task.

But if they were interested in such a thing, they’d probably start with the anti-Jewish rhetoric within the political extremes. The far-Right still believes too-awful to mention stereotypes about Jewish folks, and the extreme Left confuses being Jewish, or Israeli, with being a Zionist.

I understand why so many Jewish people I know are a little nervous these days. Students with green cards are being disappeared overnight into detention centers or deported for daring to have opinions — all in the name of Jewish people. A Jewish people, I would add, who do not feel any safer for it.

President Donald Trump described the alleged arsonist as “probably just a whack job.” He might be right. The initial reports about the alleged arsonist’s mental health situation seem to indicate that things are, as usual, more complicated than they seem.

Advertise with us

Still — the timing and initial phone call cannot be ignored. One can be unwell and antisemitic.

Nothing else matters

As Shapiro put it, “This level of violence has to end.”

In October 2024, before President Trump was elected to his second term, the Anti-Defamation League reported a record high of antisemitic incidents in the United States, stating that “24% of Americans harbor extensive antisemitic prejudice.” But that doesn’t seem to be the focus.

If the Trump administration doesn’t actually care about attacks on Jewish people, they are simply reviving McCarthyism, but with antisemitism as the cause du jour. If this is the case, all they will do is increase the number of people who hate Jews — like an entire generation of students protesting against Israel already.

What happened to Gov. Shapiro needs to be condemned, immediately and vociferously, by those who do not agree with his politics as much as those who do. Talking about eliminating antisemitism does nothing if we cannot acknowledge anti-Jewish terrorism when we see it. We should matter at least as much as a car.

Adriana E. Ramírez is the editor of InReview and a columnist who writes about books, popular culture and politics for the Post-Gazette. She is the award-winning author of “Dead Boys.” Her previous column was “The present dystopia.”