My neighbor Mary asked me on Saturday morning if I was going to the protest Downtown. I told her I was exhausted, having stayed up rather late the night before working on the final draft of my book, which is a family memoir that begins with the last Colombian civil war in 1948.

The idea of joining the thousand or so folks who attended the “Hands Off!” protest was appealing, but given my tiredness and commitment to attend the musical “Peter Pan” at the Benedum with my children a few hours later, I decided it was wiser to take a nap.

Yet even as I explained this to my lovely neighbor, I couldn’t help but consider my own immigrant-born anxiety. For all my desire to march, I know it’s better to leave the protesting to the people who are safe, like my neighbor Mary, far more secure in her American-born ability to publicly disagree.

I’ve studied enough Latin American history and politics to grok that despotic presidents in the Americas have been historically inclined to use the act of protest against the people, usually as an excuse to declare martial law, arrest citizens and shut down the free press.

Advertise with us

Hail to the chief

One can see shades of despotism happening now, as the Trump Administration detains and deports legal residents for exercising the right to demonstrate. Lawyers are being asked to capitulate to the administration for having dared to use the courts to adjudicate the law. And our economy is tumbling because someone once told the president that “tariffs” was a beautiful word.

President Trump has decided to reject the ethos of Western Europe. Instead, he’s positioning the U.S. to be an isolated nation that answers to an executive with supreme power, who demands cult-like fealty from his followers. Welcome to Latin American Politics 101.

My friend Tiko, who is Argentinian, keeps comparing Trump to his country’s Dirty War, which began in 1976 with a coup. A military junta took over Argentina in the aftermath of President Juan Peron’s death and devoted themselves to imprisoning, disappearing and torturing any dissidents.

Unions were disbanded. Journalists were silenced or imprisoned. Anyone who disagreed was disappeared. Foreigners were deported. The judiciary worked for the executive. The protesting working class were declared Communist enemies of the State.

There are certainly parallels. And it might be a hilarious coincidence that current Argentine President Javier Milei was in Mar-a-Lago after last week’s Liberation Day, hanging out with President Trump at his Saudi-backed golf tournament as the stock market began to nosedive.

Advertise with us

“These two have a lot more in common than you think,” Tiko texted me. “They’re both great at regressively taxing the working class.”

I ain’t no fortunate one

A Chilean friend on Facebook compared Trump to Augusto Pinochet, former dictator of Chile from 1974 to 1990. A Paraguayan friend compared Trump to Alfredo Stroessner, the “president” of Paraguay from 1954 until his removal in 1989. A Mexican friend told me that Trump is the new Porfirio Díaz, dictator from 1876 to 1911, intent on enacting policies that benefit his allies. You can imagine what my Venezuelan friends believe.

I think all these comparisons are unfair. While Trump may be echoing some of the mechanisms these men used — making quick and sweeping changes without congressional approval, appointing loyalists over experts, etc. — he has yet to foment the kind of violence these men unleashed on their own people. Trump has outsourced all his cruelty towards non-citizens to El Salvador, another Latino nation with an authoritarian regime.

Trump has still not declared martial law. He has not imprisoned or disappeared any American citizens yet. But my friends are not wrong to point out the increasing similarities between Trumpism and the caudillos south of the border. His dismantling of checks and balances, as well as his treatment of lawful permanent residents and undocumented immigrants, comes straight from their despotic playbook.

We are flirting with the politics of strongmen who crave absolute power — which asks its people to support these kinds of drastic measures. And that has generated a toxicity in the air that cannot be denied, mostly from Trump supporters who are deeply unwilling to criticize the president and who enjoy sending deportation threats to journalists with Latino surnames, regardless of their immigration status. This has happened to several I know, including me.

Advertise with us

It ain’t me, it ain’t me

I take hope from the folks protesting. But I also know that I probably won’t be out there anytime soon.

My family survived a civil war by keeping their heads down. They tended to their farms and stayed in their homes, except to do what was absolutely necessary.

I’m not saying seeing “Peter Pan” was absolutely necessary — but being with my family was. And for them, I’ll leave the protests to my neighbors who can do so with more freedom. I find comfort in the photographs, in the people willing to mount a resistance. In another world, I’d be there as well.

I just know too much about the political history of the Americas to take the chance.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Please come back, rubber duckie! Pittsburgh needs you.”