A friend, who is getting a PhD in education, recently shared the 2023 reading proficiency scores from her child’s Pittsburgh charter school. She sorted the list by race, and the results were shocking. The gap between reading and math proficiency rates between white and Black students was huge, like 30-points huge.

Then my friend found another tab and sorted that list by income levels. And lo and behold, the differences remained just as massive. So when we think about issues regarding educational equity in our region, have we been framing it incorrectly?

Should we be talking about student achievement gaps in terms of income inequality instead of institutional racism? Or do the two go hand-in-hand in Pittsburgh?

As my friend and I compared her child’s school to other schools in the district, though, the numbers began to vary. Don’t get me wrong — there is always a gap (one Pittsburgh school had 60-point spreads). But some public schools in Pittsburgh were putting up better numbers than charter and private schools when it came to under-performing demographics.

Advertise with us

As we delved deeper and deeper into her series of spreadsheets, contrasting numbers and trying to understand what made some schools more successful at educating Black students, we kept finding a common denominator in successful schools: Black teachers.

A time to build up

Income and race proficiency gaps persist nationally, all over Pennsylvania, and in the Pittsburgh suburbs. These gaps exist in all our publicly-funded schools, and even in plenty of private schools.

The top three predictors of student success in reading and math proficiency are parental income, parental education level, and parental literacy habits (reading in the home). The fourth? Impact of teachers.

We cannot do much about the first three. No immediate solution will raise the earnings and educational attainment of low-income parents overnight. No one can make parents read to their children every night.

But we can hire the right teachers. And that means one type of teacher in particular.

Advertise with us

A study led by Seth Gershenson of American University for the National Bureau of Economic Research concluded that “Black students who have at least one Black teacher in elementary school are 9 percentage points (13%) more likely to graduate high school and 6 percentage points (19%) more likely to enroll in college than their peers who are not assigned to a Black teacher.”

These results were replicated around the country. Gershenson’s study provides consistent evidence “that some exposure to Black teachers improves Black students’ long-term academic outcomes.” But, the authors hesitated to assign a reason for this phenomenon.

Is it because Black teachers are better role models? If so, we could better develop the mentorship programs for kids in our communities. Is this because Black teachers have less bias towards Black students? We could work on better training our teachers to be aware of their implicit bias.

But before we get too bogged down in the “why,” we need to start by doing the obvious: train and hire more Black teachers.

A time to lose

PPS gets a lot of flack for its reading and math proficiency numbers, mostly because they tend to skew low — 37% of elementary students tested at or above the proficient level for reading, and 21% tested at or above that level for math, according to U.S. News and World Report.

Advertise with us

But that doesn’t tell the real story: U.S. News and World Report also notes that 78.6% of students at PPS are economically disadvantaged. When adjusted for race and income, the district has similar outcomes to many other school districts in the area. Economically stable students are thriving, while low-income students face an incredible climb to match their peers.

And, in Pittsburgh, once called an “unlivable city for Black people” by Bloomberg, most of those low-income students are Black. As pointed out in a study commissioned by the Heinz Endowments in 2021, Black folks in the Pittsburgh area “continue to be extremely disadvantaged,” by almost every metric, but mainly health and employment outcomes.

We’re losing the Black teachers we have. WESA points out that “Black teachers in Allegheny County are facing heavier workloads, feelings of isolation and racial microaggressions from their peers — all factors that could help explain why the number of Black teachers in the county is sharply declining.”

And we’re struggling to replace them. Among new hires for the 2024-2025 PPS school year, only 8 of 90 were Black.

A time to gain

Last year, a nonprofit called Research for Action released a study of local Black teachers, directed by Siettah Parks.

Advertise with us

“A lot of folks wanted to be there for the students — and for Black students specifically — to make sure that they felt supported and to make sure that they saw Black teachers during their time in Allegheny County schools,” Parks told WESA.

But we’re still losing Black teachers, and Black middle-class folk, at an extremely high rate. They’re in demand all over the country, after all.

If we actually want to do something to close income and racial testing gaps, we should start by training and hiring the group of people who are making the biggest impact. In order to do that, we need to make sure their jobs, and our city, is as livable for them as it is for everyone else.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “The customer is no longer right, and the investor is never satisfied.” The U.S. News and World Report’s study can be found here.