Dave McCormick strikes me as an ambitious and intelligent man. The one time I met him, when he visited the editorial board, he spoke passionately about being a proud Republican, who voted with his own heart and did not mind standing up for what was right. But in the months since he has been elected, he has yet to demonstrate any independence from his party.

Both Pennsylvania Senators have gone to Mar-a-Lago to dine with President Trump, but only John Fetterman seems to have the luxury and political independence to vote with his conscience. Not every Fetterman vote will be in line with his party, and that’s not a bad thing for a man who represents all Pennsylvanians.

If McCormick were a man who followed his heart, could he have really voted to confirm Tulsi Gabbard as Director of National Intelligence? Could he stand by and watch as the administration undermines crucial industries in Pennsylvania?

Right now McCormick seems like another Republican suit, and there’s nothing that clearly demonstrates he has any inclination to deviate from the herd.

Advertise with us

Kick it!

I wanted to give McCormick the benefit of the doubt. Every politician deserves a fair shake, and I honestly thought that McCormick would be a more reasonable Republican than most. Perhaps I imagined someone I would generally disagree with but at least find principled — a power-hungry politician-type who also cares about the people he represents, even the ones who did not vote for him.

Look — I wasn’t expecting the guy to suddenly become a Democrat. I’m aware of the context of our times, so I am not shocked that he supports most of what Trump is doing. He’s still a conservative who doesn’t believe we should fight climate change, doesn’t care about social safety nets and has a lot of ideas about wokeness. He supports Trump’s immigration policies, including the deportation of people whose only crime is asking for asylum. None of this is a surprise.

But what is a astounding is McCormick’s unwavering support of Gabbard. What is shocking is seeing a garrulous businessman and outspoken military veteran be completely silent as our national government pushes policies that hurt the working people of our state.

What’s that noise?

On his website, McCormick touts his confirmation vote for C.I.A. Director John Ratcliffe. “In a world as dangerous as ours, America needs the strongest possible leadership at the C.I.A.,” reads a statement attributed to McCormick.

“John Ratcliffe is that leader. During his hearing, I appreciated that he promised to return the CIA to its core mission — to gather and share intelligence to protect our Nation from threats. I look forward to working with Director Ratcliffe to protect every Pennsylvanian.”

Advertise with us

His website does not tout his vote in support of Gabbard, though. Gabbard — who is referred to as “our girlfriend Tulsi” on Russian state media — faced what would normally be an uphill battle for confirmation. But because she was Trump’s choice, any scrutiny or protest was only symbolic.

Still, Gabbard’s ties to nations we traditionally have considered our enemies is problematic. She has also repeatedly echoed the Russian propaganda that Ukraine somehow invaded itself.

It’s good to know that McCormick does not share that view, as he told ABC27, “the war was clearly started by President Putin invading Ukraine, I don’t think there’s much to dispute about that. And I also don’t see much evidence that Zelenskyy is a dictator. I do agree with the president that it’s time to bring peace to this horrible conflict.”

But he still had no problem voting “yea” for Gabbard.

You gotta fight for your right

McCormick will be in office until 2030. As someone who will outlast the Trump administration, he should not be as scared as others running for reelection under a Trumpian gaze. He should feel more comfortable disagreeing.

Advertise with us

But I’m not sure he can. McCormick seems beholden to the administration, and no matter how much he touts standing by Pennsylvanians, even our chicken farmers, his actions say otherwise. It was the Trump administration, after all, that pushed the USDA to fire all its experts on bird flu, but he made no statement about that, despite the obvious dangers ahead.

He’s now announced that he is working with Fetterman and the “USDA to strengthen its response to the avian influenza outbreak,” as he wrote on X, without a mention of why the USDA needed strengthening in the first place.

If good leadership, as defined by McCormick, is gathering and sharing intelligence to protect our nation from threats, then McCormick himself, only a little over a month into his new gig, has yet to prove himself a good leader. Despite all his words, he seems committed to his party’s Trumpian line.

As of today, McCormick’s confirmation votes and silence prove he is simply another follower, lock-step with the administration — even against his own stated principles. I’m not going to lie, I’m a little disappointed. I thought the West Point grad had more fight in him.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “We are betraying the Greatest Generation.”