“You know, our brain starts to hurt when we have too many variables to consider, but the world is obviously a complicated place and nothing — nothing — is simple,” acclaimed anthropologist and MacArthur-fellow Jason De León told me in a recent interview.

We were discussing “Soldiers and Kings: Survival and Hope in the World of Human Smuggling,” his latest book, winner of the 2024 National Book Award in Nonfiction. A professor of anthropology at the University of California, Los Angeles, he is an expert on ethnographic research on border security and its policies. His work entails documenting the very real people who are often lost in our discussions of immigration.

His previous book, “The Land of Open Graves: Living and Dying on the Migrant Trail,” focused on the people who live and die trying to reach the American Dream. “Soldiers and Kings” focuses on the smugglers, the coyotes or (in their preferred parlance) the guides.

Tomorrow never came

There is nothing simple about human smugglers, and they have a vested interest in distrusting outsiders. In order to overcome their barriers, De León did seven years of first-hand research, “hanging out” with and gaining the trust of several groups of smugglers who help mostly Central American clients move illegally across Mexico and into the states.

Advertise with us

Smugglers are not the same as human traffickers. Smugglers are paid by their clients to navigate them through difficult terrain, while traffickers move people against their will. While many smugglers can turn out to be evil, abandoning, extorting and even killing some of the people who pay them, most are just there to do an extraordinarily dangerous job.

“They think about themselves often as a service provider, and they will make a distinction — I’m a good one, that’s a bad one — even though every human smuggler is a small part of this whole exploitative economic system,” he told me.

Anthropologist and author Jason De León

De León is great at employing cosmic zoom, considering the finest details as well as the biggest lines of inquiry possible.

Which means that as good as De León is at capturing the individuals who are directly affected by general policies, he’s also good at grounding us in the larger, systemic issues that constantly inform how we feel and talk about immigration. But that involves thinking about the border and recognizing the complexity.

South of the border

How complex is it? In De León’s estimation, someone who is truly anti-immigrant, who actually wants to prevent illegal migration, “should become a climate activist.”

Advertise with us

Climate change in Central America produces less rain and more extreme heats, which drastically reduces food production. That, along with gang violence derived from instability, part of which results from food insecurity, drives people to leave their homes. As one American-trained immigration officer in Honduras noted to De León in “Soldiers and Kings,” “it hurts me that people have to migrate, but they have no options.”

He continued: “They live in cardboard houses in extreme poverty. They have to migrate because they have nothing. They can’t live in our country. They have to leave for the United States because there is no other road for them. There is no other way out.”

The officer in Honduras knows that “we have to uphold the law. But when you catch someone and get to know their story about why they are migrating, it makes your heart hurt. It really impacts you. But I have to block out those thoughts because this is my job, and with pain in my soul I have to do it.”

De León’s interviews echo ones that I’ve conducted with Border Patrol Agents in South Texas. They have to compartmentalize themselves to perform the job of enforcing our laws.

American immigration policies only make the job harder. By cracking down and severely limiting legal asylum claims, the U.S. has forced more and more people to cross via the desert, risking their lives, as well as the mental health of the men and women who find and process their bodies if they fail.

Advertise with us

Down Mexico way

De León’s work is an extraordinary read, blending narrative and policy discussion in a way that is thrilling and never too technical or boring. We also encounter the difficulties, obstacles and impediments that prevent us from having a productive discussion around the topic. Do we begin with the intergenerational trauma affecting smugglers? With the violence and ecological disasters driving people north? Or is it easier to demonize immigrant and smuggler alike, leading to an untold number dying under our averted gazes? There’s never a simple answer.

And now, in the age of disinformation and low media literacy, it’s even harder to sort it all out.

“The farther you get away from the border, the less you know about it and understand about it, and the stronger you feel about it,” De León told me. “But it’s a straw man — immigrants on the border as the problem. Still, it really resonates, because politicians are able to use the border to sneakily distract from other issues.”

“No politician will ever say ‘the border is not the problem.’ The problem is the economy. The problem is the global divide between the rich and the poor. There’s no incentive for those guys to say that.”

I asked De León why “Soldiers and Kings” was subtitled “Survival and Hope in the World of Human Smuggling.” I was having a hard time finding “the hope” part. It all seemed so complicated and easy to distort, like the very real stories of human smugglers that De León captures in his book.

Advertise with us

“I hope that I’m not writing a border story or a migration story,” he said. “I’m hoping I’m telling a story about these people who happen to be at the U.S.-Mexico border, who happen to be migrating, who happen to be smuggling — but who are so much more.”

“I think we need to be able to see ourselves, and see familiar things in these other experiences, so that we can begin to think about this as a collective problem. If we can start to see the struggles of other folks as closer to our own, instead of being so foreign, then maybe that’s the first step towards any kind of comprehensive immigration reform,” he continued.

“I’m also leaning on hope right now, because I don’t want to live in fear.”

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Food prices aren’t dropping, and even Trump knows it.”