We pay sales taxes on most products we buy, income taxes on the money we earn, excise taxes on the gasoline and vices we consume and even taxes when we sell our homes for a profit. And then there’s the inherently difficult-to-comprehend realm of property taxes. Why do we have to continually pay taxes, even on what we already own, and have owned for decades?

Because everyone in our community benefits when we do.

One for you, nineteen for me

Still, taxes are wildly unpopular, especially when they are most necessary.

Two decades after the American Revolution, which occurred because British American colonists hated unfair excise taxes, protests and skirmishes broke out here in Western Pennsylvania in response to excise taxes levied by George Washington’s administration — to pay for said revolution. The Whiskey Rebellion did not get its name from the spirits consumed before violently rioting.

Advertise with us

That historical conflict highlights the fine line between a tax that is considered necessary and a tax that is considered an aggression. This has forever been a divisive issue, with most of us happy to pay our fair share — until it suddenly doesn’t seem fair anymore.

It’s hard to see the fairness. Our salaries do not reflect the number deposited in our bank accounts. Our game show and lottery winners forfeit a large portion of their earnings. The price of a soft drink is always roughly 7% more than what’s listed on the price tag.

And because our taxes come from a variety of sources, not just from money earned, there are also plenty of people without representation who are still subject to taxation. For example, undocumented immigrants contribute about $100 billion in taxes every year.

Tourists also pay taxes, whether they want to or not. Pennsylvania took in almost $5 billion in sales taxes from tourism according to a recent report from the PA Department of Community and Economic Development.

Be thankful I don’t take it all

“We’ve gone 12 years without raising taxes in Allegheny County,” County Executive Sarah Innamorato told KDKA last week. But in the last 12 years, the price of goods and services has increased for the county, and while special federal and state funds kept the operation afloat, it’s clear that a tax increase is necessary to keep the parks open and medical examiner on staff.

Advertise with us

The proposed 46.5% increase, or 2.2 mills above the current millage rate of 4.73, would increase the tax burden of a house valued at $110,400 by $182.50, or $15.21 per month. Thanks to inflation, though, that $15.21 can start to feel like a lot for many families doing their best to balance their needs with their desires and available funds.

County council agrees with the executive that a tax increase is necessary, but disagrees on the exact amount. Still — Innamorato is standing her ground on 2.2 mills. Anything less, she argues, would create destructive shortages.

“We architected a memo with our budget director and our county manager, and it showed that the cuts would be absolutely catastrophic to the county,” she said. “There would be mass layoffs, including layoffs of police, complete decimation of our parks department.”

It all comes down to math, and without incurring debt, less income means less to spend. Most people in Allegheny County have at some point or another used services funded by Innamorato’s office. So as we ponder this increase, we have to ask ourselves: What is local government worth to the people who have literally bought into this county?

Her critics point to day-one promises made during her administration to increase pay and benefits for non-union county workers. And while these two actions may look contradictory, they are not. In order to retain staff, the county needs to pay their employees a fair wage. Those folks have their own tax increases to pay, after all.

Advertise with us

I’ll tax the street

Look, I don’t love the idea of paying more taxes. But I also enjoy county playgrounds, having a district attorney and public defenders. I enjoy that the county helps with children’s initiatives and funds the sheriff’s office.

I like ice rinks and water fountains. I like functional public restrooms. I like that seniors without transportation get rides when they need them. I like working street lights on lonely roads.

So I’ll pay my county taxes — grumbling the whole time, probably — because I believe in my community being great, which should increase my property value, and then again, my taxes. But the truth is that most people with homes valued at $110,000 can afford to pay the extra $15 a month. And for those who disagree with assessments? Under Innamorato, it’s gotten easier for home owners to lower their appraised value.

Property taxes are the worst. I hate them. But until we come up with a better way to collectively fund and invest in local governance, I’ll pay. No matter how much I wish for a tax system that feels fair to all.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Send in the clowns.”